Really need some quick help.... XP or VISTA?
Really need some quick help.... XP or VISTA?
Author
Discussion

Jolly

Original Poster:

830 posts

259 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
Hi guys.

Im really not very technical at all when it comes to OS's...

But baisically my brother's laptop has died, and he needs to replace it pretty quickly, as he has school work and exams going on, and the laptop gets used all the time to help him. He's going to Uni next year aswell, so he wants a system that will last...

The current laptop he had was a Dell, and considering he operated it without anti-virus software for most of its life, it seems to have stood the test of time.

The question is though, should the replacement be another XP machine, or should he go for a VITSA system? The laptop hes seen on the Dell site comes with a choice, and the price remains the same, no matter which operating system is chosen? So in a nutshell, whats the best option?

Any help much appreciated,

Regards,

James.


Strangely Brown

16,266 posts

262 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
If he wants a system that will last then the answer is neither, he should buy a Mac. It will be built better and be "useable" for longer.

plasticpig

12,932 posts

256 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
I use a simple rule of thumb: Never use an MS OS which has not had Service Pack 1 released for it.


wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
Based on my experience with Vista I would say go for that as long as the spec of the laptop is reasonable.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
Based on my experience with Vista I would say go for that as long as the spec of the laptop is reasonable.
I'd go along with that.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
wolves_wanderer said:
Based on my experience with Vista I would say go for that as long as the spec of the laptop is reasonable.
I'd go along with that.
Me too, using it now and on a Media Center, not put a step out of line.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 31st May 2007
quotequote all
It you don't play games and just want it to work. Go with which ever is cheaper biggrin

Agent006

12,058 posts

295 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
If you need to ask, you don't need Vista.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Need vista? no, but its an improvement in a fair few areas over XP.

IMO though if the lappy is going to have 1gig or less of memory go for XP, else go for vista.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
James, if the laptop is just going to tootle around the internet and not a lot else perhaps buying a 'blank' from a place like novatech (god I sound like an advert for them sometimes) and slapping Ubuntu on it.

No AV, no spyware... cheaper laptop.

Simpo Two

93,087 posts

296 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
a place like novatech (god I sound like an advert for them sometimes)
I'll save you further embarassment! www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/nbranges.html I got the X20i and it's great.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
If your going to run vista as said above go for at least 1 gig of ram. And i'd suggest a dual core chip as well. It seems a bit inefficient on the proc as well as ram so for the few extra £££ it'll be worth it.

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Strangely Brown said:
If he wants a system that will last then the answer is neither, he should buy a Mac. It will be built better and be "useable" for longer.
Why do Mac people always have this very odd (and silly), arguments?! I ran XP on a machine for 5 years without any problems. The memory was upgraded and so was the graphics card but the rest remained the same..... rolleyes

Strangely Brown

16,266 posts

262 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
beanbag said:
Strangely Brown said:
If he wants a system that will last then the answer is neither, he should buy a Mac. It will be built better and be "useable" for longer.
Why do Mac people always have this very odd (and silly), arguments?! I ran XP on a machine for 5 years without any problems. The memory was upgraded and so was the graphics card but the rest remained the same..... rolleyes
I believe the requirement was for a laptop. My original statement stands.

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Strangely Brown said:
beanbag said:
Strangely Brown said:
If he wants a system that will last then the answer is neither, he should buy a Mac. It will be built better and be "useable" for longer.
Why do Mac people always have this very odd (and silly), arguments?! I ran XP on a machine for 5 years without any problems. The memory was upgraded and so was the graphics card but the rest remained the same..... rolleyes
I believe the requirement was for a laptop. My original statement stands.
Thread title said:
XP or VISTA????
rolleyes

trooperiziz

9,457 posts

283 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Strangely Brown said:
beanbag said:
Strangely Brown said:
If he wants a system that will last then the answer is neither, he should buy a Mac. It will be built better and be "useable" for longer.
Why do Mac people always have this very odd (and silly), arguments?! I ran XP on a machine for 5 years without any problems. The memory was upgraded and so was the graphics card but the rest remained the same..... rolleyes
I believe the requirement was for a laptop. My original statement stands.
If he needs it for school and uni work, then buy a windows machine, it will save no end of compatibility issues, and yes I do own a Mac...


littlegreenfairy

10,134 posts

252 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
Go for XP and word 97.

Reason I say this is the uni most likely wont update all their computers and it just makes life a lot easier if you're using something that most people are.

I run a mac with vista and OSX and have found that some of the specialist programmes don't run with OSX or vista and its been a bit of a pain.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
With a sub £500 machine go for XP, with a higher end machine I would stick in extra ram and go for Vista...

Strangely Brown

16,266 posts

262 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
beanbag said:
Strangely Brown said:
beanbag said:
Strangely Brown said:
If he wants a system that will last then the answer is neither, he should buy a Mac. It will be built better and be "useable" for longer.
Why do Mac people always have this very odd (and silly), arguments?! I ran XP on a machine for 5 years without any problems. The memory was upgraded and so was the graphics card but the rest remained the same..... rolleyes
I believe the requirement was for a laptop. My original statement stands.
Thread title said:
XP or VISTA????
rolleyes
To which a perfectly valid answer is "neither'.

Strangely Brown

16,266 posts

262 months

Friday 1st June 2007
quotequote all
trooperiziz said:
If he needs it for school and uni work, then buy a windows machine, it will save no end of compatibility issues
Absolute rubbish... lack of compatability is a myth. And anyway, if he buys a Mac he can still run XP or Vista if he absolutely has to.