Possible dodgy shocks maybe?
Discussion
After changing the shocks on my car from the Koni's to the S2 Billys about 3 weeks ago, I thought they were the miracle cure for my ride, comfort, handling and all round general refinement.
But, three weeks in and the car is beginning to rattle and bang like it did before I changed them. Also, the car feels "looser" too. Its not exactly back to where it was before the change over, but I am scared that it might get that way. Its banging and clonking over the bigger dips, ruts and holes in the road and the ride seems "harder" somehow.
I have yet to have a look and check for loosness in the fixings and so on, but would it be possible that Lotus supplied dodgy kits at all? If this is the case, then would there be and could there be a "money back" guarantee or would they be able to supply replacements at all?
I am just worried that after spending nearly the best part of £1000 on my car in the past 3 weeks trying to get it ship shape that I am going to revert to how it was so bloody quickly! That would probably be the most expensive 3 weeks I have ever spent!
Any ideas guys?
But, three weeks in and the car is beginning to rattle and bang like it did before I changed them. Also, the car feels "looser" too. Its not exactly back to where it was before the change over, but I am scared that it might get that way. Its banging and clonking over the bigger dips, ruts and holes in the road and the ride seems "harder" somehow.
I have yet to have a look and check for loosness in the fixings and so on, but would it be possible that Lotus supplied dodgy kits at all? If this is the case, then would there be and could there be a "money back" guarantee or would they be able to supply replacements at all?
I am just worried that after spending nearly the best part of £1000 on my car in the past 3 weeks trying to get it ship shape that I am going to revert to how it was so bloody quickly! That would probably be the most expensive 3 weeks I have ever spent!
Any ideas guys?
It's difficult to comment without knowing what is going on... You won't get rid of secondary ride issue on the car completely but there shouldn't be 'big' bangs coming through the suspension unless you have other issues.. Are you front ARB rubbers in good shape, they may a lot of noise when they go..
The car will feel stiffer as the spring rates on S2 suspension are about 40% higher. What do you mean by looser? Is the ride height the same?
The car will feel stiffer as the spring rates on S2 suspension are about 40% higher. What do you mean by looser? Is the ride height the same?
Mark B said:
It's difficult to comment without knowing what is going on... You won't get rid of secondary ride issue on the car completely but there shouldn't be 'big' bangs coming through the suspension unless you have other issues.. Are you front ARB rubbers in good shape, they may a lot of noise when they go..
The car will feel stiffer as the spring rates on S2 suspension are about 40% higher. What do you mean by looser? Is the ride height the same?
No, the ride height is 10mm lower than it was. When I say "looser" its as though everything is not quite "tight" enough, almost like the springs are not completely compressed and they are rattling in their mountings or something. The car will feel stiffer as the spring rates on S2 suspension are about 40% higher. What do you mean by looser? Is the ride height the same?
As for the big bangs, there seems to be more of this when the car is accelerating and then goes over a dip/hole......its like the wheels "skip" through them then bounce very fast back down onto the road and regain traction again.
I have a feeling the ARB rubbers might be on the way out though too. Not sure how I would check them though without actually having the car under load. Is there a way of doing this and are they easy to change?
And yeah, the car DOES feel stiffer. That I expected and was comfortable with for the first three weeks. Now, with the secondary ride "issues" that probably aren't there (my paranoia maybe?), then I am not so sure there is something else fundamentally wrong. I just hope not.........
TheYeti said:
I have a feeling the ARB rubbers might be on the way out though too. Not sure how I would check them though without actually having the car under load. Is there a way of doing this and are they easy to change?
Try bouncing the front corners of the car and see if you here any noises (it's easier to hear in the car IIRC), like Mark says it's pretty obvious when they are on the way out. It's got be worth checking all the fastening for the new shocks as well if only for your own peace of mind.Edited by Cuzza on Tuesday 5th June 11:18
Cuzza said:
TheYeti said:
I have a feeling the ARB rubbers might be on the way out though too. Not sure how I would check them though without actually having the car under load. Is there a way of doing this and are they easy to change?
Try bouncing the front corners of the car and see if you here any noises (it's easier to hear in the car IIRC), like Mark says it's pretty obvious when they are on the way out. It's got be worth checking all the fastening for the new shocks as well if only for your own peace of mind.Edited by Cuzza on Tuesday 5th June 11:18
I will check the fastenings too and make sure they are all torqued up again.
Paul RN said:
Who fitted them and did you get a geo?
Myself and my Dad fitted them (to the letter!) and I got a geo done the day after they were done. I followed a step by step guide that is over on the SELOC Techwiki and I just can't see where they would go wrong as the job is a simple as pie.........Sorry for this comment, but I'll say it anyway..... You have got them the right way up?? I think the front is difficult to get wrong, but do check the rear... It is actually an easier mistake than it sounds...
Oh, they won't work very well upside down
A quick spanner check is well worth doing too..
Oh, they won't work very well upside down

A quick spanner check is well worth doing too..
Mark B said:
Sorry for this comment, but I'll say it anyway..... You have got them the right way up?? I think the front is difficult to get wrong, but do check the rear... It is actually an easier mistake than it sounds...
Oh, they won't work very well upside down
A quick spanner check is well worth doing too..
Believe it or not, I was thinking the same thing, but I really can't see how I have. The writing on the shocks are all the right way up and the struts when back on the same way up as the ones that came off. I will check again, but pretty damn sure they are the right way up! LOL!!Oh, they won't work very well upside down

A quick spanner check is well worth doing too..
Still going to do a spanner check and so on though. At least if I can eliminate that, then thats one things down........
Sorry to bang on about this, but a little worrying now..........
I am thinking of getting the left rear shock checked over by a garage. It seems to "kick" when under power over even the smallest indentation in the road and gives an almighty thump through the chassis, almost as like the wheel is off teh ground and spinning, then drops fast and grips. Sounds really painful.
Also, I came of a slip road this morning with no traffic and going round a fast right sweeper, the car didn't feel that planted, if a little "floaty"........Ok, I haven't really had chance or done much spirited driving since they have been changed, so nothing to compare it to really, but I really am not sure its right. It would be really nice to get the opinion of someone else in the car with me who knows Elises or for me to go out in theirs as Pax and see what thiers is like. Any offers?
Does anyone know if I would have any recourse back to Bell & Colville on this if it turns out the shock IS knackered. They have only been on the car three weeks.............
Mind you, I could well be just being very, very paranoid about this and would just have to put this all down to TADTS, but I need to be sure............
I am thinking of getting the left rear shock checked over by a garage. It seems to "kick" when under power over even the smallest indentation in the road and gives an almighty thump through the chassis, almost as like the wheel is off teh ground and spinning, then drops fast and grips. Sounds really painful.
Also, I came of a slip road this morning with no traffic and going round a fast right sweeper, the car didn't feel that planted, if a little "floaty"........Ok, I haven't really had chance or done much spirited driving since they have been changed, so nothing to compare it to really, but I really am not sure its right. It would be really nice to get the opinion of someone else in the car with me who knows Elises or for me to go out in theirs as Pax and see what thiers is like. Any offers?
Does anyone know if I would have any recourse back to Bell & Colville on this if it turns out the shock IS knackered. They have only been on the car three weeks.............
Mind you, I could well be just being very, very paranoid about this and would just have to put this all down to TADTS, but I need to be sure............
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


