Boxter-S Vs 111R……
Boxter-S Vs 111R……
Author
Discussion

bing

Original Poster:

1,946 posts

269 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….

Stewart Rush

93 posts

237 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
nope!

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
bing said:
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….
In a straight line, probably. In the corners, doubt it. Really depends on the driver though.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
I think I'd expect the Elise to be quicker anywhere below the legal limit, although you'd have to work the gearbox harder to extract reasonable performance.

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
bing said:
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….
Bing I've been down these road's myself don't bother looking at a Porsche unless you can afford a decent 911? your going to end up with a Car that you just won't connect with, I've driven all of them Boxter\S Cayman\S 911\C2s\C4s but not the GT3 or the Turbo. You wont like either the Cayman or the Boxter if you like Elise's or Exige's they just aren't the same sort of car. Before anyone else comment's I agree the 911 is also not the same car but it's a cracking car never the less and probably the only other sub 50k car I'd look at. Forget them and buy your Exige S

Boggy

bing

Original Poster:

1,946 posts

269 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
Boggy said:
bing said:
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….
Bing I've been down these road's myself don't bother looking at a Porsche unless you can afford a decent 911? your going to end up with a Car that you just won't connect with, I've driven all of them Boxter\S Cayman\S 911\C2s\C4s but not the GT3 or the Turbo. You wont like either the Cayman or the Boxter if you like Elise's or Exige's they just aren't the same sort of car. Before anyone else comment's I agree the 911 is also not the same car but it's a cracking car never the less and probably the only other sub 50k car I'd look at. Forget them and buy your Exige S

Boggy
Bad devil boggy Bad Devil!!!!

When do you get the new car mate???

Andy T

468 posts

259 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
I agree with Boggy. I made the mistake of swapping my Elise for a Boxster S. Hated it. Now gone back to a 111S. Far better car if you like driving not posing.

JTBUSH

629 posts

239 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
Boggy said:
bing said:
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….
Bing I've been down these road's myself don't bother looking at a Porsche unless you can afford a decent 911? your going to end up with a Car that you just won't connect with, I've driven all of them Boxter\S Cayman\S 911\C2s\C4s but not the GT3 or the Turbo. You wont like either the Cayman or the Boxter if you like Elise's or Exige's they just aren't the same sort of car. Before anyone else comment's I agree the 911 is also not the same car but it's a cracking car never the less and probably the only other sub 50k car I'd look at. Forget them and buy your Exige S

Boggy
In a recent Autocar test, the Cayman was voted best drivers car. Beat the Exige, Caterham, Aston etc etc etc.

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
JTBUSH said:
Boggy said:
bing said:
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….
Bing I've been down these road's myself don't bother looking at a Porsche unless you can afford a decent 911? your going to end up with a Car that you just won't connect with, I've driven all of them Boxter\S Cayman\S 911\C2s\C4s but not the GT3 or the Turbo. You wont like either the Cayman or the Boxter if you like Elise's or Exige's they just aren't the same sort of car. Before anyone else comment's I agree the 911 is also not the same car but it's a cracking car never the less and probably the only other sub 50k car I'd look at. Forget them and buy your Exige S

Boggy
In a recent Autocar test, the Cayman was voted best drivers car. Beat the Exige, Caterham, Aston etc etc etc.
I think they must have been smoking somthing

Boggy

Boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
bing said:
Boggy said:
bing said:
I good friend of mine has just bought an 04 Boxter S and took me for a test drive last night, although it felt like a very well put together car, and seemed fairly stable at speeds through corners it just didn’t feel as ‘planted’ as my standard 111r!!! My question is are the Boxters any quicker then the 111r in the real world?????

PS it sounded dull compared to El’beast which has a stage 2 and PiperCross!!!!

Discuss…….
Bing I've been down these road's myself don't bother looking at a Porsche unless you can afford a decent 911? your going to end up with a Car that you just won't connect with, I've driven all of them Boxter\S Cayman\S 911\C2s\C4s but not the GT3 or the Turbo. You wont like either the Cayman or the Boxter if you like Elise's or Exige's they just aren't the same sort of car. Before anyone else comment's I agree the 911 is also not the same car but it's a cracking car never the less and probably the only other sub 50k car I'd look at. Forget them and buy your Exige S

Boggy
Bad devil boggy Bad Devil!!!!

When do you get the new car mate???
End of July beginning of August

Boggy

L888DER

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
but people forget that you dont buy a boxster expecting it to be as raw or as nippy as an elise or Exige! people take this decision all out of context. The cars are massivly differant.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
L888DER said:
but people forget that you dont buy a boxster expecting it to be as raw or as nippy as an elise or Exige! people take this decision all out of context. The cars are massivly differant.
I know 3 people with Boxsters. One of them bought it because it was a good compromise between handling and comfort; the other two bought them because they had a Porsche badge on the front. I suspect that's not far from a representative sample wobble

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
We have found the Boxter S to be a really capable car. In a straight line they are a about equal till about 70 - 80 then the porker is ahead. The 111R is better in the bends (as you would expect) but you have to be a very commited driver to out corner a Boxter driven in anger.

Where we found the 111R has a huge advantage is back roads, the Boxters nanny aids kept it from putting power down.

The 111R is better looking and more fun to drive and you will have to search hard to find a Boxter driver that is willing to drive the car especially against the nutters in a Lotus

L888DER

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 5th June 2007
quotequote all
No point in getting into an arguement as i fully agree everyone should have a Lotus over a boxster however i own a boxster from an Elise. Work that one out. However i agree that the Boxster is the only compramise to the Elise.
BMW Z4 ? NO Honda S2000 NO TVR T350 ? was a maybe however too lumpy on services and realibility. Noble M12 ? now theres a thought........