Discussion
Nine years of java (about 2/3 of that web) and a year of c#. I wouldn't say there's that much in it to be honest.
If pressed I'd say that I prefer Java simply because if one implementation of something (be that your mvc framework or ajax implementation) is not to your taste there's always others to look at whereas that's not always true in .net.
.net is probably easier to pick up as it's all in one box whereas with java you have to glue lots of stuff together which can be a bit discouraging but ultimately makes it more powerful.
Deployment with java can be a bit of a pain until you've worked the process out but you have the flexibility of deploying to any number of application servers on any (more or less) platform whereas with microsoft you're tied in to their stuff.
I'm sure others would disagree
If pressed I'd say that I prefer Java simply because if one implementation of something (be that your mvc framework or ajax implementation) is not to your taste there's always others to look at whereas that's not always true in .net.
.net is probably easier to pick up as it's all in one box whereas with java you have to glue lots of stuff together which can be a bit discouraging but ultimately makes it more powerful.
Deployment with java can be a bit of a pain until you've worked the process out but you have the flexibility of deploying to any number of application servers on any (more or less) platform whereas with microsoft you're tied in to their stuff.
I'm sure others would disagree

This is basically what I am looking for. We run SQL Server as our data tier and are looking to replace an aging Coldfusion server with something a little more powerful.
.NET and Java have both been raised as likely replacements but, as you say, they are so similar it's untrue. Mainly what I am looking for is the opinion of anyone who has done both and opinions on the good bits and bad bits.
.NET is obviously tempting due to it's shiny pre-packaged nature (and the SQL 2005 stuff), but Java feels more powerful, and you are not bound to any one way of doing things.
.NET and Java have both been raised as likely replacements but, as you say, they are so similar it's untrue. Mainly what I am looking for is the opinion of anyone who has done both and opinions on the good bits and bad bits.
.NET is obviously tempting due to it's shiny pre-packaged nature (and the SQL 2005 stuff), but Java feels more powerful, and you are not bound to any one way of doing things.
I'd say the main problem you've got is not choosing one over the other but getting to grips with either from a standing start to get to a commercial solution. Have you got any team members with experience of either or are you planning on bring new people in?
In all honesty the difference between the two will largely come down to personal preference unless you already have requirements for server architecture for example which could easily make the decision for you.
BTW, I got java talking to SQL Server 2005 using the hibernate persistence layer in a matter of hours so you don't need .net to use that database.
In all honesty the difference between the two will largely come down to personal preference unless you already have requirements for server architecture for example which could easily make the decision for you.
BTW, I got java talking to SQL Server 2005 using the hibernate persistence layer in a matter of hours so you don't need .net to use that database.
Edited by dern on Wednesday 6th June 10:17
beakr said:
Unfortunately, the team seem fairly well split - which makes my decision even harder.
Sounds easy then... either way it's a cv builder for half the team 
Give them two weeks for two teams to build a prototype for each side and see which one makes the most headway and choose that one.
Also, are there any environment constraints? If your team is string with Linux, then .NET is probably a no no.
We use .NET c# here and does everything we need. There is even some open source code you can use as additional libraries http://csharp-source.net/.
AJAX.NET is also brilliant and takes ASP.NET to the next level IMHO. Open source too! http://ajax.asp.net/
We use .NET c# here and does everything we need. There is even some open source code you can use as additional libraries http://csharp-source.net/.
AJAX.NET is also brilliant and takes ASP.NET to the next level IMHO. Open source too! http://ajax.asp.net/
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


