111R depreciation
Author
Discussion

CIS121

Original Poster:

1,273 posts

244 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
The previous ranges of Elise seem to depreciate more than I'd expect for such a car, but I suspect like the MG, this is because they have that great K series Rover engine designed in the 80s and that pops head gaskets every few years.

With a Toyota engine is the 111R and a good whack of power is the 111R expected to depreciate in a slower manner?

I'm looking to get a 111R as a second car but couldn't stomach the normal Elise depreciation. 111R used prices look to have depreciated very little so far which is promising.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
gaskets, they are designed to wear.

yota engine, they go pop too.

every car has its problems, if I was you, and you havnt owned one before, id get a 996/911, that will hold its value more than almost any other car, just buy a warranty (porsche warrant their cars up to 9 years old or 125k miles direct from porsche) for 825 quid and dont worry about anything going wrong as it will be fixed.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Cino said:
Bit random recommending a 911 (costing twice as much as a 111R new) on a Lotus forum to someone who clearly wants an Elise...
my 996 was my first car, loved it to bits and lost 500 pounds in almost 2 years in depreciation, ive just bought a S1 thats why im here.

obviously you know your pork so I dont need to tell you the 997 being the current model and the 996 (as recommended by me) being the previous, which can be had used at around the same sort of money.

both different cars, both great cars, if depreciation is a worry, the pork will hold its value more, that was my point wink

Cino

177 posts

236 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Bit random recommending a 911 (costing twice as much as a 111R new) on a Lotus forum to someone who clearly wants an Elise...

I think you're right about prices of Rover-engined cars dropping now that the Toyota models are well onto the used market. I was keeping my eye on 111R prices for quite some time before I bought mine, and I was a bit fed up about how little the prices seemed to come down (as a buyer). The cheapest examples now are 2004 '04' cars, which seem to be about £19000 for a milage of around 30k (with touring pack, there are not many about without it). Obviously newer and/or lower milage examples or cars with AC or other extras will be more. I've also noticed that some colours are much easier to get hold of than others; I especially wanted a black one but had to wait ages to find one at the right price. In that time I saw loads of red and yellow cars, although these are the standard paint options which may explain why there are more about. Other colours also cost more from new, so may be slightly more used. I personally would recommend buying from a Lotus Approved dealer for extra piece of mind, but that's an individual thing.

Go for it, you won't regret it. I tried various other cars (including Porsches) but nothing else in that price bracket gives you the same looks or driving experience, truly makes everything else seem dull and flabby...

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
cant understand how I quoted your post but its above your post?

odd

Cino

177 posts

236 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Dunno ... maybe it passed through the Bermuda Triangle.

Fair enough, although the kind of 996 available for £21k or so would be probably a 98 model, probably with highish miles, which would get you an 54 111R with lowish miles. Not denying for a second that the 911 is a fantastic car, just that it is very different from what the poster was after...

In the end, it's all down to personal taste - Porsches are quality cars, just not for me.

21TonyK

13,409 posts

240 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Oh GOD! I can't be bothered to read this. I thought I'd left the "depreciation" posts behind when I got shot of my M3!

Whatever anyone says, I bet an Elise loses less than other cars of similar performance. EOS!


Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
Cars depreciate most in the first handful of years eg 111R 32k new 17/8k secondhand for an 2004 one. Older cars depreciate at a slower rate, so technically you're better off with a K series.

An S1 Exige is an amazingly low depreciation model as some of those are up at 20k and still being sold.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Wednesday 6th June 2007
quotequote all
As said, if you can't stomach an Elise's depreciation, there's very little out there of a similar age that won't satisfy you.

Also, the engine makes little difference. 90% of the equation is the chassis - 111Rs will be worth more because they cost more when new. On average an '04 R is £2K more than an '04 111S but then it cost £4K more new (bearing in mind that mostly all of them have the Touring pack, which cost £2K in '04). The precedent is S1s, where a 111S doesn't command a huge amount more than a 118bhp car - condition means more.

Edited by kevin ritson on Wednesday 6th June 21:48