Is it 100% certain if ?
Discussion
boobles said:
There is oil in my coolant bottle, then the head gasket is on its way out? Just had my bottle replaced due to the old one looking rather sorry for itself & there was rather alot of oil on the bottom & with mayo on the cap.
Well, its not a good start. Not had HGF on a K series yet, but had it go on a 4-AGE Yota engine a while back and there was oil in that early on, yet the HG held out for another 4-5K miles...........I wouldn't say it was a good sign to be honest..........
boobles said:
There is oil in my coolant bottle, then the head gasket is on its way out? Just had my bottle replaced due to the old one looking rather sorry for itself & there was rather alot of oil on the bottom & with mayo on the cap.
There is definitely water getting into the oil - mayo and oil getting into the water. Yes, the head gasket is gone. Join the club - that makes you number 4 on this forum in about 10 days. Don't drive the car - the bearings may not be getting adequate lubrication with the mayo blocking channels etc. Also, you can soften the head.
the head gasket went in our freelander about 6 weeks ago, its the same engine BTW.
cost of that was about 600 pound too at a local 4x4 specialist and they said they also skim the head whilst they are at it as sometimes the head can go slightly off shape and the new gasket fails shortly after replacing.
i was thinking about this last night and I recon it would be a great time to have the head worked on, gassflowed polished etc and also have some new rings put on your pistons, that should give you a little bit of noticable compression.
cost of that was about 600 pound too at a local 4x4 specialist and they said they also skim the head whilst they are at it as sometimes the head can go slightly off shape and the new gasket fails shortly after replacing.
i was thinking about this last night and I recon it would be a great time to have the head worked on, gassflowed polished etc and also have some new rings put on your pistons, that should give you a little bit of noticable compression.
This is not my advise but that of the man who fixed mine....
"As long as you allow it to warm up correctly, ie <3000revs for first 10mins, then it should be fine."
As your car is an S1, it may have had the early "plastic" locating dowels on the head which were a shite design. When you have it replaced they will no doubt use the newer type metal dowels and upgraded gasket which shoud help prevent it happening again.
Get an AA warranty (£65 if you are a member) and they will pay the first £475 if it goes again! I used them without issue. And you get 5 claims in a year!!
"As long as you allow it to warm up correctly, ie <3000revs for first 10mins, then it should be fine."
As your car is an S1, it may have had the early "plastic" locating dowels on the head which were a shite design. When you have it replaced they will no doubt use the newer type metal dowels and upgraded gasket which shoud help prevent it happening again.
Get an AA warranty (£65 if you are a member) and they will pay the first £475 if it goes again! I used them without issue. And you get 5 claims in a year!!
boobles said:
Im going to get it sorted very soon, but the thought of it possibly happening again in a years time or so makes me very nervous of keeping it for much longer considering the amount of miles im doing. ( approx 13k annually).
stop trying to justify a change of car itchy feet 
Shnozz said:
boobles said:
Im going to get it sorted very soon, but the thought of it possibly happening again in a years time or so makes me very nervous of keeping it for much longer considering the amount of miles im doing. ( approx 13k annually).
stop trying to justify a change of car itchy feet 
I've know several mates with S3's and a large bill from a blown turbo 
You dont need to justify a new motor, if you feel like a change, go for it! The chance of a repeat HGF is hardly reason to swap the car in when its only £500 - £1k to mend and a second hand engine can be picked up for £350 or thereabouts so stop trying to tell yourself its a good reason

You dont need to justify a new motor, if you feel like a change, go for it! The chance of a repeat HGF is hardly reason to swap the car in when its only £500 - £1k to mend and a second hand engine can be picked up for £350 or thereabouts so stop trying to tell yourself its a good reason

i had exactly the same experience when my HGF went, i felt let down by the car, and lost my cofidance in it. When it was fixed i drove it like a f4nny for quite a while before regaining the confidance that it wouldn't just blow again next i gave it a boot full.
if you get it fixed i can't say weather it'll go again, but this should be a little comforting.....
my elise went bang (HGF) with 20k on the clock that was 4 years ago now heading toward 60k and absolutly no trouble since (probably just bloody jinxed it tho).
Fixed in sailsbury - funnily it couldn't have happened at a better time, cam belt was up for a change anyway, so i sort of 'lost' the cost of labour for that in the HGF repair!!
sorry to hear the crapy news, get it fixed and drive it hard.
if you get it fixed i can't say weather it'll go again, but this should be a little comforting.....
my elise went bang (HGF) with 20k on the clock that was 4 years ago now heading toward 60k and absolutly no trouble since (probably just bloody jinxed it tho).
Fixed in sailsbury - funnily it couldn't have happened at a better time, cam belt was up for a change anyway, so i sort of 'lost' the cost of labour for that in the HGF repair!!
sorry to hear the crapy news, get it fixed and drive it hard.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





Thats it. Voodooo doll of Janitors car being made as we speak!