Anyone had an Audi Conversion?
Anyone had an Audi Conversion?
Author
Discussion

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
My 160 was seriously damaged on Sunday and I have been given a (hairdressers) TT Convertible in the interim (150 HP )by an Insurance vulture.

I was ready to dislike the Audi, but I must say that the lightly turbocharged lump is a peach! scuttle shake and image are major drawbacks though.

Are these the engines that can be converted to fit an Elise? - I know that the Honda conv. costs approx £10K, anyone know how much for the Audi installation and who has experience of fitting these?

21TonyK

13,408 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
http://www.auto-teknix.co.uk/Audi.html

Plenty of others around on Google as well that make interesting reading.

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
http://www.auto-teknix.co.uk/Audi.html

Plenty of others around on Google as well that make interesting reading.
Jezf (seloc AGAIN) has one of Bernards Audi conversions in his S1 - he's in Hove. Awesomely fast!

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
rfoster said:
21TonyK said:
http://www.auto-teknix.co.uk/Audi.html

Plenty of others around on Google as well that make interesting reading.
Jezf (seloc AGAIN) has one of Bernards Audi conversions in his S1 - he's in Hove. Awesomely fast!
Looks alot better than a Honda lump and those output figures are bordering on scary - It looks ideal!

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Better to get the 225bhp lump - the internals are strengthened and the turbo is bigger. Can be easily chipped to 265ish...

cej

961 posts

253 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Don't get me wrong ,this is not to put the Audi down. But I honestly can't see why you're so impressed by it compared to the Honda k20 ? confused

I've tuned a couple of cars with K20 engines and just some weeks ago dynoed one with just exhaust and Honda Kpro to 228hp. naturally aspirated 2.0L . And the Audi puts down 225 with a turbo ? WTF confused

And before you say that it's because of the low end torque,please have a look at a dyno of a Honda k20 first wink

Also did a race car with some very mild cams and ITB+ exhaust = 248hp ,mild tune,I could probably have found another 10hp or so if we had the dyno time.

Get the Honda, more reliable and I'll bet it'll be cheaper in the long run. thumbup

if you get tired of it (which I doubt..a lot) then put on a supercharger and get 300hp+ smile

Poltergeist_666

90 posts

236 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
The Honda in mine never ceases to amaze - & to my mind, it's a hard act to beat. The supercharger gives bags of torque and it's delivery is so progressive. As has been said many times before, it makes the Elise the car it should have been from the start.

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
cej said:
Don't get me wrong ,this is not to put the Audi down. But I honestly can't see why you're so impressed by it compared to the Honda k20 ? confused

I've tuned a couple of cars with K20 engines and just some weeks ago dynoed one with just exhaust and Honda Kpro to 228hp. naturally aspirated 2.0L . And the Audi puts down 225 with a turbo ? WTF confused

And before you say that it's because of the low end torque,please have a look at a dyno of a Honda k20 first wink

Also did a race car with some very mild cams and ITB+ exhaust = 248hp ,mild tune,I could probably have found another 10hp or so if we had the dyno time.

cej, always been a sucker for a turbo - I have never really got on with superchargers although I know that most prefer the more progressive delivery.I must say that the Honda engine is awesome - I believe that they make more engines than the next 2 engine makers added together and so their R&D must be hard to beat!
Maybe I will check out a trackday with attendees of both engines.

Get the Honda, more reliable and I'll bet it'll be cheaper in the long run. thumbup

if you get tired of it (which I doubt..a lot) then put on a supercharger and get 300hp+ smile

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
cej said:
Don't get me wrong ,this is not to put the Audi down. But I honestly can't see why you're so impressed by it compared to the Honda k20 ? confused

I've tuned a couple of cars with K20 engines and just some weeks ago dynoed one with just exhaust and Honda Kpro to 228hp. naturally aspirated 2.0L . And the Audi puts down 225 with a turbo ? WTF confused

And before you say that it's because of the low end torque,please have a look at a dyno of a Honda k20 first wink

Also did a race car with some very mild cams and ITB+ exhaust = 248hp ,mild tune,I could probably have found another 10hp or so if we had the dyno time.

Get the Honda, more reliable and I'll bet it'll be cheaper in the long run. thumbup

if you get tired of it (which I doubt..a lot) then put on a supercharger and get 300hp+ smile
Whoops-
cej, always been a sucker for a turbo - I have never really got on with superchargers although I know that most prefer the more progressive delivery.I must say that the Honda engine is awesome - I believe that they make more engines than the next 2 engine makers added together and so their R&D must be hard to beat!
Maybe I will check out a trackday with attendees of both engines.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
I think the main fact is a high reving screaming engine suits track driving and I think is more enjoyable than a low reving engine.......

cej

961 posts

253 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
smile That's OK. We each prefer different things. Personally I want my engines to breath on their own ,naturally aspirated all the way for me thumbup


boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
So you were given a TT as a courtesy car?
That is a fantastic car to be given whilst yours is being repaired!

cej

961 posts

253 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Poltergeist_666 said:
The Honda in mine never ceases to amaze - & to my mind, it's a hard act to beat. The supercharger gives bags of torque and it's delivery is so progressive. As has been said many times before, it makes the Elise the car it should have been from the start.
If I had your car I'm not sure I'd survive for long biggrin But,I'd die with a big smile on my face that's for sure wink Awesome thumbup

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Bernards Audi conversions are borderline insane, huge amounts of torque and massive tuning possibility with the stock engine.

The Honda conversions are also superbly quick. Mine (NA and running 199bhp at the hubs, ~230 at the fly) on the A272 last night is well quick enough for any UK road and more. The SC'd cars go beyond that to silly-quick.

Both are superb packages, expertly executed. To my mind the Audi is a great road/GT package, less suited to track work BUT very capable. The revvy nature of the Honda (both NA and SC) is more my cuppa.

In a lottery-winners world I'd have one of each... an Audi'd S2 Elise and an SC Honda'd S1 Exige.

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
No, but worryingly enough (very worrying) I feel I’m being strangely converted back to Audi…can't stop thinking of taking a closer look at a new TT (Coupe not Roadster though). Absolutely no idea why either?!?! Yes I know I'd be a girly hairdressing woofter, but something still draws me frown

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
Out of interest, what are the comparative wet weights for the Audi and Honda engines (or total the conversion weights)? If my engine ever goes bang in a big way I'll probably put something else in there but to me, preserving the handling balance would be more important than straight line performance.

Are there any other options? VW say their 1.4 TSi lump is good for 200bhp in reliable tune, is it significantly lighter than the 1.8 (or is it a cast iron block to cope with being blown)?

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
Out of interest, what are the comparative wet weights for the Audi and Honda engines (or total the conversion weights)?
The honda conversion adds 15-20kg in total. Engine is probably nearly 30kg heavier, but a lot of bits are lighter: Manifold (also much shorter as it exits the rear of the engine rather than the front), engine mounts, flywheel - saves 2.5kg. Gearbox is apparently lighter than the PG1. The exact weight depends on the spec of the original car. A VVC engine weighs 6kg more than a regular K series.

Audi adds nearer 40kg aparently. However, it makes a lot of power and torque (though the torque at the wheels figure is not all that different to the honda because of the close ratios and short gearing of the honda gearbox)

The other end of the spectrum would be a race prepped k series - lightened flywheel + clutch assembly, lightweight engine mounts, aluminium pully, lighter alternator, manifold etc - this could save up to 25 kg over a regular k series with all its ancillaries. The k series is somewhat limited by currently available gearbox options. Having a high revving engine with a very short final drive does effectively amplify the torque at the wheels.

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
boobles said:
So you were given a TT as a courtesy car?
That is a fantastic car to be given whilst yours is being repaired!
Pretty good, but how many Elise drivers would have thought of a TT and then gone for an Elise? - It won't be getting me up early this sunday!

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
Janitor said:
No, but worryingly enough (very worrying) I feel I’m being strangely converted back to Audi…can't stop thinking of taking a closer look at a new TT (Coupe not Roadster though). Absolutely no idea why either?!?! Yes I know I'd be a girly hairdressing woofter, but something still draws me frown
The (old shape) Audi TT that I have been loaned is very well put together.It just lacks a bit of character!

Tin Hat

Original Poster:

1,430 posts

240 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
Bernards Audi conversions are borderline insane, huge amounts of torque and massive tuning possibility with the stock engine.

The Honda conversions are also superbly quick. Mine (NA and running 199bhp at the hubs, ~230 at the fly) on the A272 last night is well quick enough for any UK road and more. The SC'd cars go beyond that to silly-quick.

Both are superb packages, expertly executed. To my mind the Audi is a great road/GT package, less suited to track work BUT very capable. The revvy nature of the Honda (both NA and SC) is more my cuppa.

In a lottery-winners world I'd have one of each... an Audi'd S2 Elise and an SC Honda'd S1 Exige.
The guy on SELOC says his S1 (Audi engined) is pushing 307 bhp - He has offered to take me out for a spin (what a gent)I will have to do it just for the experience!