Need help on a new laptop should i start Mac pro'ing it up?
Need help on a new laptop should i start Mac pro'ing it up?
Author
Discussion

CooperS

Original Poster:

4,580 posts

250 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
Well as the title suggests I need some advice on a new laptop, my Vaio is starting to act its age after 4 years of abuse at uni....

What im looking for the laptop to do is basically the everyday tasks but I do want some thing that can handle good photo editing programs (getting a Digi SLR soon biggrin) and then the occasional game use (CS, Battlefield XXXX etc).

I'm not up for another 17" screen beastie so nothing to huge. So a 15" screen would be better for moving it around etc.

Now mates have warned me off Vista and so most gaming laptops such as Dell’s offering and their sister company AlienWare and gently persuaded me in the direction of the Apple Mac Pro's. Which im unsure of? Are they much better than the Microsoft offering in handling, smoothness and look? Also if it is better, should I wait till the new Leopard OS comes out in October or should I buy now and upgrade at the time of launch (also would I find that if I wait Apple will upgrade the spec of the range of the pro’s? other than just the OS)

I've got a budget of £1300 (due to Camera and software purchases next month smile) and although at first glance that puts me out of what’s on offer in the Apple range except the 2.2 GHz Apple I also get 15% student discount biggrin so im in reach of the 2.4 GHz (bit of stretching needed but not huge).

My question is would I be disappointed if I don’t get the higher spec 2.4GHz machine?

The only differences which matters are the differences in processor and graphic card? On the 2.2GHz the Graphics card is a NVIDIA GeForce 8600M GT graphics with 128MB SDRAM apposed to the higher spec NVIDIA Geforce 256mb.

Would I find that some games wont run on the weaker machine or would I be fine for the games detailed above.

Anyway that’s a lot of questions for now hope you can help me out.

Cheers

Tom

oh is there anything else i should know about these which i havent already asked smile

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 13th June 2007
quotequote all
I would go for the one with 256MB RAM personally. I know the 8xxx series are the current eye blisteringly quick units, but 128MB of texture memory just sounds... like a lot. I'm sure either of them will be bloody fast though.

Are you going to BootCamp or hunt for OS X native games?

CooperS

Original Poster:

4,580 posts

250 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Are you going to BootCamp or hunt for OS X native games?
LOL excuse me... could you explain? I presume one is to be loaded through XP or Vista and the other are games are produced just for Mac users...?

In which case not to sure biggrin

Would you say going Mac is a better decsion than going microsoft again? I've been on a few Mac forums (just browsing) and the level of info scares me and the level of discussion is a tad higher than what i need.

Also someone said the mac pro's come with HD drives! is this true?

cjs

11,722 posts

282 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
There are not so many games available to run on Mac OSX. You can also run Windows on new Intel Macs so you could run Windows based games. To run Windows you need to set up a separate Partition and use a free Application called 'Bootcamp', this allows you to switch between operating systems. I have it and it works well!

Don't understand you question re HD's. Do you mean do MBP's come with external HD's? If so no, they have standard internal HD's.

Edited by cjs on Thursday 14th June 09:11

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
CooperS said:
Also someone said the mac pro's come with HD drives! is this true?
If you mean HD-DVD drives, then I don't think they do.

I bought a MacBook Pro back in February, and the only niggle I've got with it is that the built-in wireless isn't as good as in the three-year-old Vaio that it replaced.

I use Bootcamp and the beta 1.3 version has almost everything working that you'd want - external monitor support is still a bit patchy.

Mind you I'd also recommend Vista on the basis of using it every day with no problems, so what do I know... smile

Leithen

14,164 posts

298 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
Too soon to tell about Leopard - even when it breaks cover in October, it will no doubt be a couple of major updates away from the stability Tiger currently has - my advice, don't bother waiting, the upgrade will be circa £89 and better to install in 08.

The new LED screen on the 15" is meant to be the dogs testicles - debate whether glossy or matte is better rages on - only way for you to be sure is to hoof it down to an Apple store and choose yourself.

I'd go for the 2.4 - It ought to last many years of abuse.....

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
The only way to decide whether you like the Apple hardware and software is to get your hands on it. At an Apple Store you can spend some time playing, and getting over the initial WTFs (where's right-click? where's Launch? etc.). Most OSX users love it, but it has to be your decision. I've said before that once you try it properly, you'll either "get it" or you won't.

Some pointers, though:
- Through a system called BootCamp, a Mac can run Windows natively (you restart to swap), and so can run pretty much any Windows programmes & games.
- In Windows mode, the Mac hardware is as fast (perhaps a fraction faster) than a PC with the same spec (chip speed, disk, graphics card).
- The MacBook Pros have just been speed-bumped. However (and this needs to be checked - I'm losing track of Intel chips) Intel recently announced a super-duper chip for laptops. I THINK this was a pre-announcement (available 2008?), so the latest MBP does not feature it - inevitably the MBP will be one of the first to take it. But I may be wrong on this - perhaps someone better up-to-speed can correct?
- On Monday, Apple confirmed that they were getting back into the games market. Several announcements and commitments including EA Games and id Software including Battlefield 2142. Worth watching.

On Leopard:
- Don't wait, unless it fits your plans
- Releases are normally pretty good, but it's probably better to wait a month or so for the dust to settle
- It will be £89 - one version only (despite Stve Jobs' "announcement&quotwink
- It is showing significant speed improvements in 64-bit native
- The final version of BootCamp should resolve all final issues, and appears to open new options on accessibility between the two platforms (not clear what they are yet, but Jobs was clearly hinting at something)

One final tip. When speccing your machine, remember to include any extra software and hardware you need. It can add up. As you will be running BootCamp, you have several options:
- You will need a legal copy of Windows (XP or Vista) to install
and depending on how much hassle restarting will be to you, you could:
- Buy the Mac version of a program (e.g. MS Office)
- Buy the Mac equivalent (e.g. Final Cut over Premiere)
- Install your existing PC programmes in the Windows partition, though of course they are less accessible.
- Start with option 3, and gradually migrate back to the Mac-platform as budget allows and/or newer versions of the programmes are released.

Hope That Helps

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
Some comments on HiRich's post. Marked with >


HiRich said:
The only way to decide whether you like the Apple hardware and software is to get your hands on it. At an Apple Store you can spend some time playing, and getting over the initial WTFs (where's right-click? where's Launch? etc.). Most OSX users love it, but it has to be your decision. I've said before that once you try it properly, you'll either "get it" or you won't.

Some pointers, though:
- Through a system called BootCamp, a Mac can run Windows natively (you restart to swap), and so can run pretty much any Windows programmes & games.

>When Leopard comes bootcamp will be seemless to the extent that instead of restrting you machine, you would sleep OSX and bring up a fully functional Windows machine. This will then hibernate when you want to go back to OSX.

- In Windows mode, the Mac hardware is as fast (perhaps a fraction faster) than a PC with the same spec (chip speed, disk, graphics card).

- The MacBook Pros have just been speed-bumped. However (and this needs to be checked - I'm losing track of Intel chips) Intel recently announced a super-duper chip for laptops. I THINK this was a pre-announcement (available 2008?), so the latest MBP does not feature it - inevitably the MBP will be one of the first to take it. But I may be wrong on this - perhaps someone better up-to-speed can correct?

Not just a speed bump but also a chipset upgrade to Intels latest offering see http://arstechnica.com/reviews/hardware/macbook-pr... but check this is also applicable to the 15". I'm sure it is.

- On Monday, Apple confirmed that they were getting back into the games market. Several announcements and commitments including EA Games and id Software including Battlefield 2142. Worth watching.

To an extent. The EA games will run under a kind of emulator called Cider so they are unlikely to perform as if they were in windows. This makes the boot camp news even better because Apple is beefing up the bootcamp drivers and games will run fine on a windows booted boot camp MacBookPro.

On Leopard:
- Don't wait, unless it fits your plans

>If you buy nowish you may even get a discount version of leopard or entirely free. Worth asking and the apple store (real or online) if you'll get a voucher for this).

- Releases are normally pretty good, but it's probably better to wait a month or so for the dust to settle
- It will be £89 - one version only (despite Stve Jobs' "announcement&quotwink

. you will be able to get a single 'residence' 5 user license interpret that as you wish with a laptop!

- It is showing significant speed improvements in 64-bit native
- The final version of BootCamp should resolve all final issues, and appears to open new options on accessibility between the two platforms (not clear what they are yet, but Jobs was clearly hinting at something)

One final tip. When speccing your machine, remember to include any extra software and hardware you need. It can add up. As you will be running BootCamp, you have several options:
- You will need a legal copy of Windows (XP or Vista) to install
and depending on how much hassle restarting will be to you, you could:
- Buy the Mac version of a program (e.g. MS Office)
- Buy the Mac equivalent (e.g. Final Cut over Premiere)
- Install your existing PC programmes in the Windows partition, though of course they are less accessible.
- Start with option 3, and gradually migrate back to the Mac-platform as budget allows and/or newer versions of the programmes are released.

Hope That Helps
Edited by Olf on Thursday 14th June 17:32

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
CooperS said:
Would you say going Mac is a better decsion than going microsoft again? I've been on a few Mac forums (just browsing) and the level of info scares me and the level of discussion is a tad higher than what i need.
Personally, OS X has it's own share of niggles and 'eh?' moments same as any other OS. However, it's pretty much immune to spyware/malware in general and nobody has written an effective virus for OS X (a few proof of concepts exist but nothing more). Not having all the hassle of that (just look at all the threads that appear here and turn out to be malware) is a pretty good reason IMHO.

That and you can get an OS X version of Office so talking to the rest of the world is no big issue smile
In some respects dual booting can be quite good once you get used to it, it allows you to keep OS X as a 'work' environment and Windows for entertainment.

Personally, I wouldn't trust Transgaming's Cider any more than I'd trust Cedega (their Linux effort), it was horrible and quickly fell behind the curve; still I'll wait and see with a hopeful expression on that one smile