How can you tell if your shocks need changing?? ( S1 Konis )
How can you tell if your shocks need changing?? ( S1 Konis )
Author
Discussion

jondude

Original Poster:

2,441 posts

248 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
I am tempted to upgrade to S2 suspension but am worried I may spend the £700 or so and not feel like I have got £700s worth of betterment.

My S1 is 1998, but has only done 30,000 miles on roads, no tracking. Car has sailed through MOTs without concern.

Is there any way I can check how worn the shocks are??

They look very easy to replace DIY, must say....

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Even if they were brand new the different (better) design of the S2s will make a difference. I understand its an easy replacement, just need a GEO if you're adjusting the ride height.

If in doubt join a run and get a ride in one with S2 suspension.

jondude

Original Poster:

2,441 posts

248 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Thanks - good idea about taking a ride in a car which has the S2 suspension. That would indeed clear it for me.

Stu Hill

147 posts

247 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
You can tell if the shocks need changing as they will be leaking. If you can see an oil leak around the base of the shock, normally with loads of dirt stuck to it then it is on it's way out.
The S2 (Bilsteins) set up is a lot stiffer. To be fair you'd probably notice the a complete transformation if you installed four new Konis. But seeing as this costs about the same as the Bilsteins + you get four new springs plus a quieter ride. It seems daft not to go for the S2 set up.
For the year or so that I've been on both Pistonheads and Seloc, nobody has every compared a completely newly sprung car with Konis against the Bilsteins. Everybody says that the Bilsteins are better, but any new suspension will always be better that life expired stuff.
Comment peoples, and give me a reason why the Bilsteins are better than the Konis (apart from noise)

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
jondude said:
Thanks - good idea about taking a ride in a car which has the S2 suspension. That would indeed clear it for me.
The SELOC forum have quite a few Essex people on and a few events. If you're not a memeber already might be worth signing up over there.

Zebede29

322 posts

254 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Stu Hill said:
You can tell if the shocks need changing as they will be leaking. If you can see an oil leak around the base of the shock, normally with loads of dirt stuck to it then it is on it's way out.
The S2 (Bilsteins) set up is a lot stiffer. To be fair you'd probably notice the a complete transformation if you installed four new Konis. But seeing as this costs about the same as the Bilsteins + you get four new springs plus a quieter ride. It seems daft not to go for the S2 set up.
For the year or so that I've been on both Pistonheads and Seloc, nobody has every compared a completely newly sprung car with Konis against the Bilsteins. Everybody says that the Bilsteins are better, but any new suspension will always be better that life expired stuff.
Comment peoples, and give me a reason why the Bilsteins are better than the Konis (apart from noise)
I've had my car back a week now after getting the full Bilstein dampers/eibach shocks upgrade plus a brake re-furb. Set me back £1014 inc VAT including fitting, geo and fixing a duff speaker (i know, its an S1, why bother with sounds etc etc but I couldn't cope with mono sound from the passenger side alone LOL) and I have to say there's a HUGE difference.

In my fairly novice opinion, the suspension upgrade has made a huge difference to the car as follows:

PRO's:
- vastly improved handling balance
- sharper steering response
- considerably less body roll
- more grip (in the dry at least, not tried in the wet)
- almost totally-quiet ride

CON's:
- extremely firm ride
- much more "jiggly" on sharply bumpy roads/B or C roads
- makes my CD player jolt now, didn't before!

Overall I'm pleased, although it is firmer than I expected it to be. This will of course help at the 'Ring in July so no worries biggrin

I'm in Lincolnshire if you need to try my car BTW