Wondering why my MBP can't use more than 2Gb RAM+videocard Q
Wondering why my MBP can't use more than 2Gb RAM+videocard Q
Author
Discussion

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
As the title - I'm about to buy a second bank of memory to take it up to the full 2Gb and wondered why it can't go any higher... Will this ever change, or is it a function of the hardware?

Also, how good is Ati Radeon X1600 256Mb in the grand scheme of things these days? Can that be upgraded if ever required?

Just idle wondering... Cheers.

~PHIL

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
It is largely a limit imposed by the motherboard chipset. This PC's motherboard will take 4GB but because of the extra load imposed by having 4 sticks installed, it runs at a slightly lower speed. The PC architecture also requires a chunk of memory to be effectively hidden so that it may be able to 'see' the video card memory. Hence, more than 2GB isn't really worth having for most people.

No idea about the video card, I tend to use Nvidia/GeForce based units. Any card that is a plug-in can be upgraded in the future, any motherboard that has integrated graphics should be avoided anyway.


eyebeebe

3,875 posts

264 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Zad said:
No idea about the video card, I tend to use Nvidia/GeForce based units. Any card that is a plug-in can be upgraded in the future, any motherboard that has integrated graphics should be avoided anyway.
I disagree. There is nothing wrong with integrated graphics chipsets, if you are doing office work. You only need a discreet chipset if you are playing games, doing heavy 3D graphics or want to run Vista with Aero?

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
eyebeebe said:
Zad said:
No idea about the video card, I tend to use Nvidia/GeForce based units. Any card that is a plug-in can be upgraded in the future, any motherboard that has integrated graphics should be avoided anyway.
I disagree. There is nothing wrong with integrated graphics chipsets, if you are doing office work. You only need a discreet chipset if you are playing games, doing heavy 3D graphics or want to run Vista with Aero?
I partly disagree. There is nothing wrong with a well implemented IGP solution. It'll get most things done and can run some older games happily (Half-Life, Unreal Tournament type age). However, most IGP's tend to be found in the cheaper end of the spectrum and quite often aren't all that stable in terms of driver support.

Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor. 64bit will allow you to slap something silly like a petrabyte of RAM in to something, but a) you can't get SO-DIMMS above 1GB and b) no motherboard, 64bit CPU or not has enough sockets to fit anywhere close to that. Also, look at it this way, 2GB of RAM is actually quite a lot in the grand scheme of things, I have 2GB in my laptop and generally hover around the 400MB used mark, if you need more you're looking at a server.

The X1600 is a bit pants really, sorry. It's very much the entry level of things, graphics hardware having continued to accelerate. No, you can't upgrade it...

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
Well at least you're honest! wink

That's ok (re: the Graphics card), i wasn't expecting anything exceptionally mental as i don't play games, but i do mess around with photos and i wondered how much the graphics card helps/hinders in that respect...


ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
Buffalo said:
Well at least you're honest! wink

That's ok (re: the Graphics card), i wasn't expecting anything exceptionally mental as i don't play games, but i do mess around with photos and i wondered how much the graphics card helps/hinders in that respect...
Depends. If you're thrashing something like Photoshop to within an inch of it's life then a big beefy graphics card can help (PS will use OpenGL commands to render certain plug-ins and such to speed it along). If you're just tweaking the odd snap, crop here, bevel edge there type stuff... no. It's all 2D work and the card's just sat drinking coffee with it's feet up. Buggers are lazy like that. smile

In all seriousness, the answer to "Can I upgrade my laptops graphics card?" is 99.99% of the time a resounding "No." Yes, if your laptop is built with an MXM slot inside you can open it up and swap the card, they're rather hard to find, expensive as hell when you do and there is no guarantee your laptop will fire up afterwards due to oddities in laptop BIOS's (they're exceptionally proprietary) and or the VDS connector (I think it's called that, I'm working from memory... but anyway VDS is akin to ultra-mini DVI and there were 3 maybe 4 different versions of it last time I looked depending on who's panel you wanted to use).

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
I'm not sure about this whole onboard graphics thing..... I have onboard ATI video, which I upgraded because I wanted DVI. I just disabled the old video hardware in the BIOS. I guess it won't be the same for everybody, but if you have an AGP slot and onboard video, I doubt you wouldn't be able to use the slot instead.

If you can go for DVI, I'd personally recommend that as a route to a decent flat panel display. If not now in the future. I got a whole pile of hardware that I'm not likely to use, but OpenGL and DirectX compatibility is certainly worth having, and I only paid £35.

I cant help with PCI Express cos I have no knowledge other than, get it if you can afford it.

Edit.....

I just looked up that video board, and I'm not entirely sure why people are making it out to be bad. Looks quite nice to me...... Are you sure you have the slot to put it in?

Edited by dilbert on Sunday 17th June 02:33

m12_nathan

5,138 posts

290 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.

eyebeebe

3,875 posts

264 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
dilbert said:
I'm not sure about this whole onboard graphics thing..... I have onboard ATI video, which I upgraded because I wanted DVI. I just disabled the old video hardware in the BIOS. I guess it won't be the same for everybody, but if you have an AGP slot and onboard video, I doubt you wouldn't be able to use the slot instead.

If you can go for DVI, I'd personally recommend that as a route to a decent flat panel display. If not now in the future. I got a whole pile of hardware that I'm not likely to use, but OpenGL and DirectX compatibility is certainly worth having, and I only paid £35.

I cant help with PCI Express cos I have no knowledge other than, get it if you can afford it.

Edit.....

I just looked up that video board, and I'm not entirely sure why people are making it out to be bad. Looks quite nice to me...... Are you sure you have the slot to put it in?

Edited by dilbert on Sunday 17th June 02:33
MBP = MacBook Pro. It's a laptop not a desktop so a whole different ball game.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile
2 2GB SODIMMs would do it, but you can't get them yet. The MBP has a 64 bit porcessor and OS, so it can take much more memory and if you could get 16GB SODIMMs, it sould be able to take them.

As for 32 bit OSs, the theoretical limit is 4GB, but Windows will only address about 3.75GB.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
Zod said:
ThePassenger said:
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile
2 2GB SODIMMs would do it, but you can't get them yet. The MBP has a 64 bit porcessor and OS, so it can take much more memory and if you could get 16GB SODIMMs, it should be able to take them.
Maybe. I don't know much about the EFI thing they've brought out to replace BIOS. It might require a flash to stop it spazing when it reads the SPD's, you also might bump in to chipset limitations. But yeah, the theory is sound assuming that the chipset can and that a hypothetical update to the 'bios' exists. Personally I'm not actually sure it has a 64bit processor. If it's an old MBP then it'll have a Core Solo or Core Duo, which was strictly 32bit in their mobile incarnations, if it's a slightly newer generation with a Core 2 it 'might' be 64bit capable, having said that, I have a Core 2 Duo lappy (which supposedly has EMT64 capabilities) and the 64bit OS I tried out on it (Ubuntu AMD64/EMT64) freaked out left right and Chelsea, I couldn't honestly tell you if OS X is running in 64 or 32bit mode on a modern MBP; don't have one to play with hehe

Zod said:
As for 32 bit OSs, the theoretical limit is 4GB, but Windows will only address about 3.75GB.
Which is odd. I seem to remember an article on NT4 when it first appeared on the horizon that said it had the ability to address something in the terabyte range (by virtue of 32bit addressing or some such); I'm probably getting it muddled in my old brain and it was talking about total addressable memory space (RAM+swap) and not pure physical RAM.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
eyebeebe said:
dilbert said:
I'm not sure about this whole onboard graphics thing..... I have onboard ATI video, which I upgraded because I wanted DVI. I just disabled the old video hardware in the BIOS. I guess it won't be the same for everybody, but if you have an AGP slot and onboard video, I doubt you wouldn't be able to use the slot instead.

If you can go for DVI, I'd personally recommend that as a route to a decent flat panel display. If not now in the future. I got a whole pile of hardware that I'm not likely to use, but OpenGL and DirectX compatibility is certainly worth having, and I only paid £35.

I cant help with PCI Express cos I have no knowledge other than, get it if you can afford it.

Edit.....

I just looked up that video board, and I'm not entirely sure why people are making it out to be bad. Looks quite nice to me...... Are you sure you have the slot to put it in?

Edited by dilbert on Sunday 17th June 02:33
MBP = MacBook Pro. It's a laptop not a desktop so a whole different ball game.
AHA......

In that case surely one wouldn't have the slot to put it in?

m12_nathan

5,138 posts

290 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile
Where did I say that you could fit more that 2GB in a MBP? I was simply pointing out that your statement "basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor" is not correct. The fact that you then go on to say "not really" whilst talking about machines with 3.5GB of RAM is just genius.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile
Where did I say that you could fit more that 2GB in a MBP? I was simply pointing out that your statement "basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor" is not correct. The fact that you then go on to say "not really" whilst talking about machines with 3.5GB of RAM is just genius.
Indeed, and what can you discern from that? The most stable and thus the limit for anyone with only a passing interest and the one imposed by a great many manufacturers is 2GB. Example, in the other room is an AMD64, it is running in 64bit mode. Maximum supported RAM? 2GB. Why? Chipset limitation. Further proof my laptop, 2G max (Chipset again), most of the limitations are chipset based, most people don't really see a difference between the chipset and the processor and the 'machine'. So how do you sum up that information for someone who really doesn't want several paragraphs giving intimate details and generally a long winded explanation? "Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor." Sums it up nicely I think, factually wrong, yes, but technically accurate.

Sorry, I've had people moan for giving complete answers and now you're moaning because I gave a short one, make your minds up folks.

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
Zod said:
ThePassenger said:
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile
2 2GB SODIMMs would do it, but you can't get them yet. The MBP has a 64 bit porcessor and OS, so it can take much more memory and if you could get 16GB SODIMMs, it sould be able to take them.

As for 32 bit OSs, the theoretical limit is 4GB, but Windows will only address about 3.75GB.
The apple webpage sells 2Gb sticks that will fit... How come Apple give a limit for the MBP then, if you say it could go higher (not necessarily that there is any point in it? (it is the core duo 1 model, not the later revised chipset).

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
Buffalo said:
Zod said:
ThePassenger said:
m12_nathan said:
ThePassenger said:
Basically, 2GB is the limit for a 32bit processor
Wrong.
Not really. Most home type machines seem to hit issues around the 3.5 mark. There was a thread here not long ago about someone who had shoved the full 4GB in to his board and both the BIOS and Windows were adament it was 3.75GB (after some tinkering). True, the theoretical maximum is as equally insane as a pure 64bit system... something like 4 terrabytes.

Of course if you know how he can shoehorn 4GB in to a MBP with only 2 slots, be my guest. smile
2 2GB SODIMMs would do it, but you can't get them yet. The MBP has a 64 bit porcessor and OS, so it can take much more memory and if you could get 16GB SODIMMs, it sould be able to take them.

As for 32 bit OSs, the theoretical limit is 4GB, but Windows will only address about 3.75GB.
The apple webpage sells 2Gb sticks that will fit... How come Apple give a limit for the MBP then, if you say it could go higher (not necessarily that there is any point in it? (it is the core duo 1 model, not the later revised chipset).
Chipset and 'BIOS' (not that the Mac's have an actual BIOS, it's EFI but it does pretty much the same thing). If you get hold of a DIMM you'll see several large chips, that's the actual RAM. You'll also see a small 8pin or so chip buried somewhere, often out of the way. That's the SPD; it basically tells the 'bios' everything about that stick of RAM (capacity, timings, FSB speed, bad blocks, etc). The bios can only accept certain answers and the chipset can only work with so much memory (often less than the maximum theoretical amount).

However you also have the annoyance that is you can fit pretty much any amount of DIMMS (assuming physical sockets) up to the limit imposed by the hardware. So, yes, you can buy a 2GB SO-DIMM and fit it and it will work. Fit a second and all manner of oddities happen, like the video card vanishing or the machine simply not booting (more likely that one).

Apple didn't really set any limit, Intel did in their design of the bits of hardware (it's their CPU & chipsets in the MBP's, Imac's and indeed the big desktops).

m12_nathan

5,138 posts

290 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Sums it up nicely I think, factually wrong, yes, but technically accurate.
Factually wrong and technically wrong. I have a 32bit machine with more than 2GB RAM, as do many other people the world over so it is clearly not a limitation of 32 bit processors.

Have you considered becoming an MP? Your inability to admit when you were wrong would be a great asset in that world.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
Zod said:
As for 32 bit OSs, the theoretical limit is 4GB, but Windows will only address about 3.75GB.
[smartarse]4GB is only the limit in a flat address-space. More complex addressing schemes allow more than 4GB to be addressed.[/smartarse]

siztenboots

96 posts

248 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
As hinted to earlier, PAE allows access to swapped memory maps to go beyond 4GB. But typically in a earlier P4 intel board 2GB is a chipset limit, or around 3.2GB since a large area is reserved for the Windows kernel and graphics cards IO. Again it varies a lot due to the variety of 32/64bit hybrid/AMD64 chips out there.

At least with the AMD64 the DDR memory is a lot cheaper should you decide to max it out.