Who owns a domain name?
Author
Discussion

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,099 posts

296 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
This is getting messy. I have administrative rights to a clients' domain name, let us call it 'B*****' (their freelance PR chap who registered it originally transferred it to me when he lost the contract). I host their site and manage the web and e-mail forwarding. All fine.

But now the MD has changed and says some of his e-mails are getting lost. I don't think it's my end as nobody else has been complaining, but that's what he says and he wants the company that manages another website of his to do the e-mail instead.

So he mails me: 'I have decided to use the company who host my (other) web site for the B***** site. They are able to set up direct email accounts for us. firstly can I have FTP access to the B***** site. I need to know the domain name details.'

He thinks, and he may be ritgh, I don't know, that his company owns the domain name. He also thinks that the e-mails can be got to him without forwarding and that this other company can somehow do it - whereas my view (with albeit limited knowledge) is that it needs a dedicated server/IT package that will cost £3K.

I'm not interested in the e-mail forwarding - it's only admin without profit - but to allow someone else to do it I think I have to pass the domain name to them. That means they can build and host the new website, which is work I DO want and need.

I can't really give him FTP access to the site as it's in a directory of my own, and that would give him access to all my websites.

I think he wants to take the whole thing away from me, which is rather unfair as I've done nothing wrong and have always made any changes quickly and cheaply. No doubt the rival supplier is filling his head with aspersions and half-truths to make themselves look better than me and I don't have the full tecchy info to debate it.

What can I do to try to retain the work please?

tuffer

9,023 posts

298 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
www.virtualnames.co.uk I pay about £20 a year.

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
What can I do to try to retain the work please?
If I've understood the problem correctly just get the MX record changed. That will redirect all mail to A.N. Other server while leaving the domain where it is with no need for FTP access etc.

ETA:
Try to schedule any changes to business DNS records on a Friday to allow changes to propagate around all the name servers over the weekend yes

Edited by The Griffalo on Tuesday 19th June 10:07

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,099 posts

296 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
The Griffalo said:
stuff
YHM!

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Mail forwarding is totally different to website management. If he's asking you for FTP access to the website it's sod all to do with the email, eh?

Only reason he could want FTP access is to download the website source so it can be modified by someone else.

So. Griffalo is dead right that you could get the MX record changed and mail will automatically whoosh off to whatever mail server the MD wants it to go to. Nowt to do with you from then on.

But it doesn't sound like that's the issue. If the MD owns the domain name he's entitled to have its DNS entries point to wherever he likes and you ought to co-operate with him...including handing over technical management of the DNS business.

If *you* own the domain and are simply "renting" it out then its a different matter.

There isn't a technology solution here. You need a commercial solution with the MD. Go talk to him. Find out what he actually wants. Decide how much to charge him for your help and then do the business. The help may be to hand over to some new firm....but at least you'll get some cash out of it. The email excuse is technically weak...so I don't believe it. Therefore there must be a relationship problem you need to sort out to your best advantage.

Good luck!

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,099 posts

296 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
You're right Don - he wants the outfit who run the website for his other company to do it all. Pity he doesn't have the guts to say it, but uses a weak excuse instead.

Anyway, I'll present him with some options which include moving the mail to his other webpeople but keeping the BL webwork with me. At present his site is hosted within my own (I know it's not proper but that's how it evolved), so if I give him FTP access he also has access to my own sites and those of other clients - so it's not an option. If he's determined to have it, I'll have to move to a professional hosting set-up and he can pay the bill for the hosting and my time in moving everything over.

As for the domain name, I was talking to the Registrant today and apparently he's in for a cut of some money, so he doesn't want to rock the boat.

I'll advise the new MD that the simplest thing to do is move the e-mail (which of course addresses the 'problem') and leave the Registrant and the website where it is. I'll also send him a link to the Nominet site which will confuse him even more and help persuade him that overturning the applecart is more trouble than it's worth smile