Discussion
I expect this has been done to death, however I am after a bit of advice.
My old PC at home is knackered. It is about 6 years old and whilst it still works, there is something wrong with the graphics card as pictures appear really dark on the screen and it also keeps freezing.
Whilst my work involves quite a bit of computer use, I know very little about them.
So, if I am buying a new PC for home what should I go for? I do not want to spend too much, it needs to cope with the kids homework, photo storage etc. Oh and it must be totally suitable for being on PH!
Would I be mad to consider a mac? All I know about them is that they look good and don't involve Microsoft. Can everything from my present computer be transferred to a mac? Or am I being stupid and should I just buy something from Dell?
Any advice gratefully received.
J
My old PC at home is knackered. It is about 6 years old and whilst it still works, there is something wrong with the graphics card as pictures appear really dark on the screen and it also keeps freezing.
Whilst my work involves quite a bit of computer use, I know very little about them.
So, if I am buying a new PC for home what should I go for? I do not want to spend too much, it needs to cope with the kids homework, photo storage etc. Oh and it must be totally suitable for being on PH!
Would I be mad to consider a mac? All I know about them is that they look good and don't involve Microsoft. Can everything from my present computer be transferred to a mac? Or am I being stupid and should I just buy something from Dell?
Any advice gratefully received.
J
JulesV said:
Would I be mad to consider a mac? All I know about them is that they look good and don't involve Microsoft. Can everything from my present computer be transferred to a mac? Or am I being stupid and should I just buy something from Dell?
Mac's aren't perfect but on the whole I would say my Mac here at home requires much less in the way of intervention/maintenence than a typical Windows box.My suggestion would be to have a look on the Apple website but approach it with a healthy dose of cynicism, also if possible get yourself down an Apple Store, they'll let you piss about all day long and you'll soon get a feel for if you think you could get along with one.
So far as transferring stuff across, pictures and movies should be fine, if you've got a lot of Office Documents you won't get very far with the software that comes with a Mac so you'd be looking at either Microsoft Office for Mac, or one of the free office suites like NeoOffice/OpenOffice.
Go for it. I moved over to a Mac just over 2 years ago, mainly because the pc laptops that I had previously had only on average lasted 12 months.
Our oldest is a powerbookg4 and our newest an ibook g4. We haven't really missed windows, indeed we love the fact that a crash is almost non existent and the only time we need to re-boot is when the router appears to play silly devils.
Our oldest is a powerbookg4 and our newest an ibook g4. We haven't really missed windows, indeed we love the fact that a crash is almost non existent and the only time we need to re-boot is when the router appears to play silly devils.
JulesV said:
it needs to cope with the kids homework, photo storage etc.
For most things for most people, either will work perfectly well, it's the 'kids homework' that I'd perhaps have concerns with. Worth making sure there are Mac versions of the software they'll be using at school - last time I had anything much to do with education software it was pretty heavily biased towards PCs.jamieboy said:
JulesV said:
it needs to cope with the kids homework, photo storage etc.
For most things for most people, either will work perfectly well, it's the 'kids homework' that I'd perhaps have concerns with. Worth making sure there are Mac versions of the software they'll be using at school - last time I had anything much to do with education software it was pretty heavily biased towards PCs.
Is the premium for the Mac worth it? PC's are considerably cheaper than Macs, and much easier to upgrade. Blue Meanie said:
jamieboy said:
JulesV said:
it needs to cope with the kids homework, photo storage etc.
For most things for most people, either will work perfectly well, it's the 'kids homework' that I'd perhaps have concerns with. Worth making sure there are Mac versions of the software they'll be using at school - last time I had anything much to do with education software it was pretty heavily biased towards PCs.
Is the premium for the Mac worth it? PC's are considerably cheaper than Macs, and much easier to upgrade. I think the move to a Mac is less risky now than it was. At least all the modern Macs are intel run now. If you don't like the Mac OS, then it will run Windows just as happily, IE Natively. So nothing to lose?
P,
PJR said:
So nothing to lose?
Money. Like for like, performance for performance, Macs are very overpriced compared to PCs. And seeing how quickly computers, both PCs and Macs alike, become obsolete, I'd rather spend on the lower side of the spectrum.And if you or your kids intend to play games, then the PC is the only sensible choice.
-DeaDLocK- said:
PJR said:
So nothing to lose?
Money. Like for like, performance for performance, Macs are very overpriced compared to PCs. And seeing how quickly computers, both PCs and Macs alike, become obsolete, I'd rather spend on the lower side of the spectrum.Plus you've got the whole iLife package to consider, it's not a time limited demo (a la Dell) and actually... it's not that bad for quickie video edits and stuff. But more importantly, premium price, premium customer support. If you want the same from Dell, you'll have to pay extra for the business class warranty usually.
-DeaDLocK- said:
And if you or your kids intend to play games, then the PC is the only sensible choice.
If you're getting an out and out games machine than either the MBP or a Rock machine would be the way forward, both come with a mobile 8000 series in them (and that just has to kick so much arse you're eyes will bleed from over excitement... or something... meh). But yeah, bog standard PC turf is games. -DeaDLocK- said:
PJR said:
So nothing to lose?
Money. Like for like, performance for performance, Macs are very overpriced compared to PCs. And seeing how quickly computers, both PCs and Macs alike, become obsolete, I'd rather spend on the lower side of the spectrum.And if you or your kids intend to play games, then the PC is the only sensible choice.
Firstly, at the time of buying my iMac (last December), you could not buy an equivalent (performance-wise) Dell for less money, and even then I couldn't spec some features on the Dell (FireWire 800, specifically).
Secondly, the Wii, XBox 360 or PS3 all represent better gaming solutions than a desktop computer for just about everything other than FPSes. Consider the hassle of drivers/OS updates/viruses/spyware versus "bung disc in console, play game".
First iMac lasted me six years or so but did start to show its age with new software. If it wasn't for a video board going it would still be here. The emac has replaced it and whilst not as cheap as many PC's at the time it suits my needs. Probably get a pro next. In six years time maybe.
Thanks for the help so far. It will not really be used for games as we have a PS2. I am a bit concerned about the kids doing homework on a mac as I don't know whether the schools systems are compatible. I am looking into this.
The kids spend half their lives on MSN Messenger which will not I presume work on a mac. Also I gather that macs do not pick up viruses.
Seems to be pros and cons and have to admit I am still unsure.
Any ideas on what spec I should go for and the relative costs of both a mac and a PC?
I do realise I could research this myself and have done to a degree. However it is much more reassuring to have advice from those who know what they are talking about!
J
The kids spend half their lives on MSN Messenger which will not I presume work on a mac. Also I gather that macs do not pick up viruses.
Seems to be pros and cons and have to admit I am still unsure.
Any ideas on what spec I should go for and the relative costs of both a mac and a PC?
I do realise I could research this myself and have done to a degree. However it is much more reassuring to have advice from those who know what they are talking about!
J
JulesV said:
Thanks for the help so far. It will not really be used for games as we have a PS2. I am a bit concerned about the kids doing homework on a mac as I don't know whether the schools systems are compatible. I am looking into this.
The kids spend half their lives on MSN Messenger which will not I presume work on a mac. Also I gather that macs do not pick up viruses.
Seems to be pros and cons and have to admit I am still unsure.
Any ideas on what spec I should go for and the relative costs of both a mac and a PC?
I do realise I could research this myself and have done to a degree. However it is much more reassuring to have advice from those who know what they are talking about!
J
Well the only real software you kids are likely to use at school will be MS office right? Thats available on the Mac and works very nicely.The kids spend half their lives on MSN Messenger which will not I presume work on a mac. Also I gather that macs do not pick up viruses.
Seems to be pros and cons and have to admit I am still unsure.
Any ideas on what spec I should go for and the relative costs of both a mac and a PC?
I do realise I could research this myself and have done to a degree. However it is much more reassuring to have advice from those who know what they are talking about!
J
MSN Messenger works on the Mac as does skype etc.
Cost comparisons made here by people are aslo a bit misleading. If you buy a mac, keep all the packaging in the loft and ebay it when you're done with it. I sold my G4 powerbook after three years of daily use, and including a free sizable dent, for 800 quid, i.e. about 40% of the original purchase price... try doing that with a PC, that pays back any premium you pay.
P.s. Sounds like your desktop choices are:
iMac 17"
1GB memory
160GB hard drive1
8x DL SuperDrive
ATI Radeon X1600 graphics
Ready to ship: 24hrs
Free Shipping
£799.00
(£680.00 ex VAT)
or
iMac 20"
1GB memory
250GB hard drive1
8x DL SuperDrive
ATI Radeon X1600 graphics
Ready to ship: 24hrs
Free Shipping
£999.00
(£850.21 ex VAT)
iMac 17"
1GB memory
160GB hard drive1
8x DL SuperDrive
ATI Radeon X1600 graphics
Ready to ship: 24hrs
Free Shipping
£799.00
(£680.00 ex VAT)
or
iMac 20"
1GB memory
250GB hard drive1
8x DL SuperDrive
ATI Radeon X1600 graphics
Ready to ship: 24hrs
Free Shipping
£999.00
(£850.21 ex VAT)
If I wanted a good machine with the basics of software - wordprocessor, photo library etc; then I would go mac
if you want to do a lot more like play games etc then a pc is better as its catered with a far greater library of software.
I dont care to pick which is better as I use a mac and pc, but if I had to move to one computer then I would pick a pc for the ability to easily upgrade cheaply and its very easy to get hold of software..
if you want to do a lot more like play games etc then a pc is better as its catered with a far greater library of software.
I dont care to pick which is better as I use a mac and pc, but if I had to move to one computer then I would pick a pc for the ability to easily upgrade cheaply and its very easy to get hold of software..
-DeaDLocK- said:
PJR said:
So nothing to lose?
Money. Like for like, performance for performance, Macs are very overpriced compared to PCs. And seeing how quickly computers, both PCs and Macs alike, become obsolete, I'd rather spend on the lower side of the spectrum.And if you or your kids intend to play games, then the PC is the only sensible choice.
As for games, PC ones or otherwise. Again, as I said previously, modern Intel Macs will run all PC games and other software as well as a PC can. Running PC software on Macs is no longer an issue.
At the end of the day. Its like buying a car. You can buy a cheap one, or you could buy an expensive one. They do the same job, just in slightly different ways. But isn't it nice to have the choice and variety these days? Without that, things would be very boring indeed.
P,
The half decent resale value is because most people just go and buy a new computer, as they are cheap, or actually upgrade, as there are so many options out there. If you need a new soundcard, you go get one... More memory, go get some, better hard drive? Go get one... Video card? Go get one, and chuck it in...
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




