Online backup Services
Discussion
With well over 40GB of data to backup, the process of tediously backing up every fortnight to DVD's is wearing thin and now that I've just had my internet service un-capped with 8Mbps download and 1Mbps upload, I figured the time is right to try out one of these online backup services.
I've just signed up to Mozy (http://www.mozy.com), which seems very reasonable at $4.95 per month so unlimited data uploads and up to 4 full restores every month, however I'm in a trial mode right now until I find the right service so any other suggestions would be worth trying.
Keep in mind I have the following to backup:
- Photos (Most important) - 35GB and growing constantly
- My Documents (Second most important but easy to backup on DVD) - 6GB
- Outlook PST (Not so important now since I now use Gmail with my own domain) - 1GB
I think that's about it for now, so 40GB with another 20-30GB for expansion is needed. I need a low price (otherwise I'll just get another hard disk) and the backup software has to be very good. Also web access to my files would be a BIG bonus which Mozy does provide.
Any other suggestions?
Ta!
BB
I've just signed up to Mozy (http://www.mozy.com), which seems very reasonable at $4.95 per month so unlimited data uploads and up to 4 full restores every month, however I'm in a trial mode right now until I find the right service so any other suggestions would be worth trying.
Keep in mind I have the following to backup:
- Photos (Most important) - 35GB and growing constantly
- My Documents (Second most important but easy to backup on DVD) - 6GB
- Outlook PST (Not so important now since I now use Gmail with my own domain) - 1GB
I think that's about it for now, so 40GB with another 20-30GB for expansion is needed. I need a low price (otherwise I'll just get another hard disk) and the backup software has to be very good. Also web access to my files would be a BIG bonus which Mozy does provide.
Any other suggestions?
Ta!
BB
Are you doing full backups of all your data? I would have thought that with 35Gb of photos, you would only be adding a few hundred meg a week and the rest would be static so would only need to be backed up once? Incremental backup software could significantly reduce your backup needs.
Also, you could put something like ORB on your pc and access it from anywhere.
Also, you could put something like ORB on your pc and access it from anywhere.
Edited by Tycho on Tuesday 3rd July 11:04
Tycho said:
Are you doing full backups of all your data? I would have thought that with 35Gb of photos, you would only be adding a few hundred meg a week and the rest would be static so would only need to be backed up once? Incremental backup software could significantly reduce your backup needs.
Also, you could put something like ORB on your pc and access it from anywhere.
Mozy is incremental so like you said, the initial backup will take about 24 hours (just a guess with good network traffic), but the rest is incremental so it shouldn't take much there-after.Also, you could put something like ORB on your pc and access it from anywhere.
Edited by Tycho on Tuesday 3rd July 11:04
I think in fact, most of the other services I found were incremental too. I also found a service called Carbonite but I found a very baised comparison table on the Mozy website which screams out that Mozy is better but like I said....it's baised!
The other reason I like an online backup solution is simply because it's remote and stored safely on a server miles and miles away from me, meaning if my house burns down (all forbid), or any other disaster happens, I still have everything safe and sound.
beanbag said:
Well....just started using Mozy. It estimates 1 week and 2 days to complete my backup set!! Let's just hope my hard disks don't die before this!!! 


Sorry but online backup for 40gb's worth of data is just plain silly, do you have enough bandwidth included in your BB package to upload the whole lot?
Get an external HDD, its far and away the best option

You could then leave it hooked up and use a VPN or similar to connect to it over the net.
Edited by MarfGTxx on Tuesday 3rd July 18:10
MarfGTxx said:
beanbag said:
Well....just started using Mozy. It estimates 1 week and 2 days to complete my backup set!! Let's just hope my hard disks don't die before this!!! 


Sorry but online backup for 40gb's worth of data is just plain silly, do you have enough bandwidth included in your BB package to upload the whole lot?
Get an external HDD, its far and away the best option

Also means in the event of a failure you're looking 3-4 days to download the data again!
I'll echo, External HDD and a good RAID array!
J
JamieBeeston said:
MarfGTxx said:
beanbag said:
Well....just started using Mozy. It estimates 1 week and 2 days to complete my backup set!! Let's just hope my hard disks don't die before this!!! 


Sorry but online backup for 40gb's worth of data is just plain silly, do you have enough bandwidth included in your BB package to upload the whole lot?
Get an external HDD, its far and away the best option

Also means in the event of a failure you're looking 3-4 days to download the data again!
I'll echo, External HDD and a good RAID array!
J

I think it'll take actually a lot less than 1 week, but I've set it at a max upload of 512Kbps to conserve my normal internet usage so we'll have to wait and see.
If I have to restore the backup, it shouldn't take too long at 8Mbps....let's just hope we don't have to restore it!

Erm. 1Mbps, 100KB/s give or take.
DVD-Writer, 5MB/s (or faster), 5,000KB/s give or take.
Fleabay yourself a tape drive and SCSI controller (I'm assuming desktop here), fit it, watch it swallow your whole backup set in one gulp at 20MB/s (20,000KB/s give or take). I think a 40/80 unit can be had for £50 - £60 second hand. Slap in a head cleaning tape and let it get on with it.
My gut feeling is that these on-line services are a bit dubious. Someone selling a huge span set in chunks to people or some such. I'm assuming some of them are as stated on the box though.
DVD-Writer, 5MB/s (or faster), 5,000KB/s give or take.
Fleabay yourself a tape drive and SCSI controller (I'm assuming desktop here), fit it, watch it swallow your whole backup set in one gulp at 20MB/s (20,000KB/s give or take). I think a 40/80 unit can be had for £50 - £60 second hand. Slap in a head cleaning tape and let it get on with it.
My gut feeling is that these on-line services are a bit dubious. Someone selling a huge span set in chunks to people or some such. I'm assuming some of them are as stated on the box though.
I back up 120gb with Mozy and it's running fine. Only problem so far is if you back up a removeable drive, and then remove and reattach it, it'll get backed up all over again. Takes a while to get it all uploaded but fine after that. Should take a few days to restore but i've got nothing really urgent on there that i couldn't just download by itself first.
SneakyNeil said:
Doesn't Roadsweeper do this, or am I getting confused with someone else?
You're quite right, we do online backup. Thanks for remembering us Neil! I spotted this thread early on and was going to post some calculations for the project upload time but thought it might be seen as a conflict of interest.
The fact is, even with a real 1Mb/s upload speed 40GB is an enormous amount of data. We cannot (and don't try to) compete with Mozy on price but in my opinion we take them to the cleaners and then beat them about the head and body with a big stick on features, service and support and I believe that is critical for something as important as data backup. However, we concentrate on businesses where downtime equals money - i.e. disaster recovery - rather than self-managing home users so it's horses for courses as with anything.
For what it's worth, for a business user with this requirement we would simply courier a rugged External Hard Disk Drive (EHDD) to them, perform a local seed backup, get it sent back and upload it directly onto our server. Subsequent backups would then be differential only, which with backup sets comprised mainly of photos, etc. is not big deal regardless of the intial size. The same principle goes for a data restore. The substantial time involved in downloading tens of gigabytes over even a reasonably fast connection is just not tenable for many businesses.
Personally, I think Mozy is OK for this, the OP will just have to be patient with the upload and do it bit by bit during the evening. A local EHDD backup is very useful (and I do this myself as you can get a 1TB EHDD for less tham £200 now) but it doesn't cover you against theft of your kit or fire, etc. so online backup does have some real benefits, hence why I use my own service to backup my really precious data, 80% of which is home photos and videos. However, since it's my company it's free and even Mozy can't beat that.

ThePassenger said:
Erm. 1Mbps, 100KB/s give or take.
DVD-Writer, 5MB/s (or faster), 5,000KB/s give or take.
Fleabay yourself a tape drive and SCSI controller (I'm assuming desktop here), fit it, watch it swallow your whole backup set in one gulp at 20MB/s (20,000KB/s give or take). I think a 40/80 unit can be had for £50 - £60 second hand. Slap in a head cleaning tape and let it get on with it.
My gut feeling is that these on-line services are a bit dubious. Someone selling a huge span set in chunks to people or some such. I'm assuming some of them are as stated on the box though.
A good rule of thumb is to listen to this lady when it comes to IT stuff! DVD-Writer, 5MB/s (or faster), 5,000KB/s give or take.
Fleabay yourself a tape drive and SCSI controller (I'm assuming desktop here), fit it, watch it swallow your whole backup set in one gulp at 20MB/s (20,000KB/s give or take). I think a 40/80 unit can be had for £50 - £60 second hand. Slap in a head cleaning tape and let it get on with it.
My gut feeling is that these on-line services are a bit dubious. Someone selling a huge span set in chunks to people or some such. I'm assuming some of them are as stated on the box though.

Many online backup providers are a bit of a joke. We even know of 'competitors' with PCs sat in their house or datacentres outside the UK (with all the risks and legal ramifications that entails) as the backup destination. If you're paying a significant sum for your backup look for a company with a UK-based datacentre, replication to another site (ideally) and good Service Level Agreements and support. If you're paying next to nothing (as with Mozy) enjoy the low price but be aware of the risks.
HTH
roadie
agent006 said:
I back up 120gb with Mozy and it's running fine. Only problem so far is if you back up a removeable drive, and then remove and reattach it, it'll get backed up all over again. Takes a while to get it all uploaded but fine after that. Should take a few days to restore but i've got nothing really urgent on there that i couldn't just download by itself first.
I think this is the critical difference for a home user: timescales aren't critical and things like the external hard drive being reconnected and tripping the system up aren't the end of the world. In this case, Mozy is not a bad choice IMO.In case anyone's interested in what we class as Enterpise backup, take a look at our online backup website which is brand spanking new (went live on Monday).
For the geeks amongst you (*coThePassnegerugh*
) check out the AJAX partial post-back on the pricing page (but not in FF because it's not quite right in that yet!
)ThePassenger said:
Erm. 1Mbps, 100KB/s give or take.
DVD-Writer, 5MB/s (or faster), 5,000KB/s give or take.
Fleabay yourself a tape drive and SCSI controller (I'm assuming desktop here), fit it, watch it swallow your whole backup set in one gulp at 20MB/s (20,000KB/s give or take). I think a 40/80 unit can be had for £50 - £60 second hand. Slap in a head cleaning tape and let it get on with it.
My gut feeling is that these on-line services are a bit dubious. Someone selling a huge span set in chunks to people or some such. I'm assuming some of them are as stated on the box though.
Hang on....I got that wrong...I'm uploading at 460KB/s so that's actually 4Mbps upload.....DVD-Writer, 5MB/s (or faster), 5,000KB/s give or take.
Fleabay yourself a tape drive and SCSI controller (I'm assuming desktop here), fit it, watch it swallow your whole backup set in one gulp at 20MB/s (20,000KB/s give or take). I think a 40/80 unit can be had for £50 - £60 second hand. Slap in a head cleaning tape and let it get on with it.
My gut feeling is that these on-line services are a bit dubious. Someone selling a huge span set in chunks to people or some such. I'm assuming some of them are as stated on the box though.

Edited by beanbag on Tuesday 3rd July 23:08
beanbag said:
460Kb/s = 57.5KB/sSubtle difference
At that rate the time to upload the remaining data is roughly 5.25 days. As Jamie said that will kill (or at least hinder) your web browsing for a week.
Edited by theboss on Tuesday 3rd July 23:24
theboss said:
beanbag said:
460Kb/s = 57.5KB/sSubtle difference
At that rate the time to upload the remaining data is roughly 5.25 days. As Jamie said that will kill (or at least hinder) your web browsing for a week.
Edited by theboss on Tuesday 3rd July 23:24
Edited by ThePassenger on Tuesday 3rd July 23:40
I wouldn't trust any third party with my private data, even if it is encrypted.
External hard drives are ok temporarily, but you're just moving the problem elsewhere. Those drives are no more sturdy than internal hard drives.
RAID is best value for the pound, but then you need to make sure you have enough spares. No point in having a RAID5/6 array go tits up in 5 years only to find you can't get an exact disk replacement.
I use a combination and in multiples; DVD backups, RAID5 array, encrypted remote storage (on servers of my own). No single solution covers everything.
External hard drives are ok temporarily, but you're just moving the problem elsewhere. Those drives are no more sturdy than internal hard drives.
RAID is best value for the pound, but then you need to make sure you have enough spares. No point in having a RAID5/6 array go tits up in 5 years only to find you can't get an exact disk replacement.
I use a combination and in multiples; DVD backups, RAID5 array, encrypted remote storage (on servers of my own). No single solution covers everything.
Hmmmm.....I'd better explain my reasons for going for an online backup. I'm not interested in a local backup and I'm just looking for experiences on different online solutions:
1. Local backup hardware is expensive. USB external drives are not exactly a "safe" place to keep data and home NAS solutions are expensive. (~£250 for 500GB).
2. To have a reliable local backup solution, it's necessary to have a RAID array set up as mirroring. (I think RAID 1, but this might be striping). Anyhow this is not important. What's my concern is that this costs even more pushing the price up to around £350-£400. Now we're in a new laptop price range or a new lens for my camera!
4. Online backups are cheap. (At least they are from Mozy). $4.95 per months is a bargain or £30 per year for peace of mind.
5. A local backup, is as it's called...local. Meaning that if a disaster were to happen (and they do), I would loose all my data regardless if it's backed up or not.
6. The only safe way is to have the data off-site, but to be honest I don't fancy doing a backup and bringing the hardware to my office every day. Online backups are no where near your home and are usually in bomb proof data-center bunkers, meaning, my data is safe!
7. Local backs are slow at first, but they are quick thereafter since the backup is incremental. On top of this it's a daily backup without any effort on your part. My computer is on 24 hours a day and once the main backup is done, it'll do it's backup in the early hours of the morning when I'm fast asleep, so I won't notice any drop in my net connection!
8. I'm not concerned about data privacy. Everything is encrypted using a totally random 256 character passphrase chosen by myself and any bank details are kept encrypted locally on my hard disk anyway. If you could break this, I'll give you a million dollars. On top of that, the majority of my data is pictures. I don't keep dodgy pics on my PC, so I'm not concerned about what is stored in the data center (even though it's all encrypted anyway).
1. Local backup hardware is expensive. USB external drives are not exactly a "safe" place to keep data and home NAS solutions are expensive. (~£250 for 500GB).
2. To have a reliable local backup solution, it's necessary to have a RAID array set up as mirroring. (I think RAID 1, but this might be striping). Anyhow this is not important. What's my concern is that this costs even more pushing the price up to around £350-£400. Now we're in a new laptop price range or a new lens for my camera!
4. Online backups are cheap. (At least they are from Mozy). $4.95 per months is a bargain or £30 per year for peace of mind.
5. A local backup, is as it's called...local. Meaning that if a disaster were to happen (and they do), I would loose all my data regardless if it's backed up or not.
6. The only safe way is to have the data off-site, but to be honest I don't fancy doing a backup and bringing the hardware to my office every day. Online backups are no where near your home and are usually in bomb proof data-center bunkers, meaning, my data is safe!
7. Local backs are slow at first, but they are quick thereafter since the backup is incremental. On top of this it's a daily backup without any effort on your part. My computer is on 24 hours a day and once the main backup is done, it'll do it's backup in the early hours of the morning when I'm fast asleep, so I won't notice any drop in my net connection!
8. I'm not concerned about data privacy. Everything is encrypted using a totally random 256 character passphrase chosen by myself and any bank details are kept encrypted locally on my hard disk anyway. If you could break this, I'll give you a million dollars. On top of that, the majority of my data is pictures. I don't keep dodgy pics on my PC, so I'm not concerned about what is stored in the data center (even though it's all encrypted anyway).
beanbag said:
8. I'm not concerned about data privacy. Everything is encrypted using a totally random 256 character passphrase chosen by myself and any bank details are kept encrypted locally on my hard disk anyway.
Storing your bank details remotely is a bad idea, even if they are encrypted. No encryption is 100% unbreakable, I just couldn't sleep at night
I don't even write them down.The problem isn't just data sensitivity though, what if they're compromised and they lose everything? Don't put all your eggs in one basket when it comes to backups.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


