Advice
Author
Discussion

mollymai

Original Poster:

68 posts

232 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Are there many people out there that have owned an S2 Exige and an S2 Elise 111r or even you experts out there who can give me advice on choosing between the two machines as I'm useless with cars and bits just love driving and looking at them. I am not into modifications so I would just be looking at a standard spec for each or again perhaps you guys can advise. I appreciate that I need to go and test drive the two but my nearest dealer is about 70 miles away and I want to do so homework first. Also I keep finding conflicting information, does the roof to the Exige come off and if so is a soft top supplied or you have to purcahse it separately?

Thanks

subaqua

892 posts

243 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Standard spec on the exige is slightly better than the 111R, slighly beefier suspension and runs on sticky (read as soft) tyres (195 section from rather than 175 on the liz) which means its a little less understeery. Other than that the exige comes with front splitter/rear spoiler which provides (some) downforce but always weighs (a shade) more. Turns out to mean a cigarette paper between the two in terms of track speed in the hands of a mere mortal AFAIK.

Roof on the exige can be relaced with the elise soft top, but its something you will have to ask the dealer to do for you (and it wont be cheap), rather than a factory fit upgrade - either way, there are a number of differing opinions on the look of the exige with roof removed, not all of which will be complimentary.

Lotus position the elise as the everyday sports car, and the exige as a more hardcore track biased car, but to be honest, its probably more marketing spin than substance.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
subbie's notes are well made, can't disagree with them. What cars have you had before, and what will you be using the Lotus for? Road only, any track use? How important is cost? How many miles a year do you reckon you'll do?

mollymai

Original Poster:

68 posts

232 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
subbie's notes are well made, can't disagree with them. What cars have you had before, and what will you be using the Lotus for? Road only, any track use? How important is cost? How many miles a year do you reckon you'll do?
Currently I am bouncing around in an Impreza Sti but in the past I have owned an S1 111s and an S2 111s. The car will be used everyday for commuting and not kept in a garage. I won't be using the car on a track. Cost needs to be up to £30k maximum and I will probably do about 8000 miles a year maximum.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
I would say a 111R, but it all depends if you want a convertible or not.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
mollymai said:
S Works said:
subbie's notes are well made, can't disagree with them. What cars have you had before, and what will you be using the Lotus for? Road only, any track use? How important is cost? How many miles a year do you reckon you'll do?
Currently I am bouncing around in an Impreza Sti but in the past I have owned an S1 111s and an S2 111s. The car will be used everyday for commuting and not kept in a garage. I won't be using the car on a track. Cost needs to be up to £30k maximum and I will probably do about 8000 miles a year maximum.
The Elise then. You'll get pissed off with the harsher ride of the Exige, and the bills for tyres. Talk to Janitor, the man has a superb 111R for sale at the moment.