HGF Or Not?
Author
Discussion

boobles

Original Poster:

15,251 posts

246 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Is it possible that my car may not have had HGF but instead a "Porous" head?
This has been suggested by somebody & i thought id ask the question.
I paid out for the HGF to be repaired but now im wondering if ive paid out for something that didnt need fixing! The only symptoms i had on my S1 was oil in my coolant bottle & thats it, no other symptoms what so ever & i was told that the HG was in very early stages of failing.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Porous heads usually cause the coolant system to become pressurised with exhaust gases rather than cause oil to end up in the coolant. Yes, you had HGF, they fixed it. Sorted. op worrying and drive the car. Fitting a PRT (pressure relief thermostat will help to prevent future HGF)

boobles

Original Poster:

15,251 posts

246 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
I only wanted to ask because it was suggested that maybe they had got it wrong.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
This kind of thing is notoriously, nay impossible, to diagnose on an internet forum. The only way you'd possibly know for sure is if you'd have taken it to several respected specialists, had them whip the head off and test it, and then compare notes. Sorry dude, but shangers is right. Just get on with enjoying your P&J. If it goes again, send it straight back to the place who did the original fix and talk it through. Meantime, keep that AA P&L warranty up to date.

FWIW I had 2 K-series Elises, did a total of about 18,000 miles of spirited driving in both, and neither suffered any HGF symptoms or failures.

boobles

Original Poster:

15,251 posts

246 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
I think you guys are missing the point here & without me sounding pedantic, im not concerned about it all im saying is that somebody suggested that it wasnt HGF, but a "porous" head. I only really put a thread on here to see if anyone had heard of this happening before because i know i havnt but this guy who mentioned it has far more knowledge when it comes to engines than i ever will have & this is the only reason why i thought id get it checked out on here. Thanks for your reply's as you have set my mind at rest & appreciate all the help you guys can give. Of for a drive in a minuite to clock up yet more miles of pure fun.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Before saying we are missing the point, why don't you re-read what I posted, which is a brief opinion on why I do not think your problem is due to head porosity. Yes, there have been issues with head porosity on k-series engines, but the porosity allows the passage of small amounts of gas, not oil. You symptoms were entirely consistent with HGF, not porosity.

As the problem seems to have been sorted, stop worrying and second guessing the repair that has been done. If it was porosity, you would need a new head.

boobles

Original Poster:

15,251 posts

246 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Im kinda hoping that the person who was convinced that it isnt HGF owns up & writes on here. He knows who he is. rolleyes I was never in any doubt that what my car suffered was HGF, but he was convinced otherwise as he has the same symptoms as what i had but only on a different car.

Edited by boobles on Wednesday 4th July 19:44

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Suffice to say that porous heads are usually soft as well and that predisposes to HGF. He may have had porosity and HGF.

boobles

Original Poster:

15,251 posts

246 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
I have to admit that i know sod all about engines & apperciate all the advice given, & hope that he does read this & take note because i wouldnt want him to carry on driving the car if it is HGF & ends up costing a fortune due to miss diagnosis.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Call me a hard-nosed bastard if you will, but what the hell do you care? It's not your car.

boobles

Original Poster:

15,251 posts

246 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Hes a mate & i dont want to see him have a huge bill like i did. Hence the question being asked.