Time to become creative - Mac buying questions
Time to become creative - Mac buying questions
Author
Discussion

ehasler

Original Poster:

8,579 posts

314 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
My PC has died (again), so I've got the perfect excuse to do what I've been wanting to do for a while now, and move to the dark side! woohoo

I've decided on a Mac Pro, but have a few questions...

Are discounts available, or will I have to pay full retail?

I'd like to replace the original system disk with a couple of mirrored WD Raptor drives - is this straightforward to do?

I'm not really au fait with what's going on in the Mac world, so are there any releases (hard or software) due soon that would make it worth holding off for a month or two?

Is it worth going for the Quad core CPUs over the Dual core? I'll mainly be doing Photoshop type stuff.

I can save a 2-300 quid by going to Crucial for extra memory, however have heard that there have been issues with overheating on non-Mac memory - is 3rd party memory OK now?

That's it for now I think!

Edited by ehasler on Thursday 5th July 10:49

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
If you buy from Apple there are no discounts available. Unless you are a student. If you buy from a reseller there are unlikely to be discounts of the base price but they may well give you a discount on upgrades/additional items.

There is a major OS release coming in October. If you buy now you will not get any discount on this. You will have to pay the around £100 to upgrade.

I'd also say that the Mac Pros are likely to get some sort of hardware bump soonish. They have not been upgraded (apart from the 8-core version being made available) since launch around a year ago. The graphics cards in particular are looking pretty poor these days.

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
I wouldn't replace the original HDD, but add the Raptors to the unit.
You can do HW RAID or SW RAID - the former requires a PCI-E daughterboard as the Mac doesn't do HW based RAID on its logic board (motherboard).
The alternative is to use Disk Utility (inc in the OS) or SoftRAID to do the SW RAID method, but RAID5 isn't an option - 1 and 0 are it.

nrayner

3,058 posts

313 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
I'm in a similar position - am waiting patiently for a Mac Pro refresh (intel has new chipset due in August I think which is suitable).

To get discount apple sometimes has refurbished on the web site, also apple stores sometimes have returns.


ehasler

Original Poster:

8,579 posts

314 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
nrayner said:
To get discount apple sometimes has refurbished on the web site, also apple stores sometimes have returns.
thumbup Good call! Just seen my ideal spec on the refurb site, so have ordered one biggrin

Now I just need to buy some black clothes hehe

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Memory:
I've never heard of memory problems from Crucial. Macs are certainly sensitive to the quality of the RAM boards inserted, but Crucial is always the default safe option - always recommended by the magazines.
On the off chance that you are planning to use the huge RAM with riser boards, it might be worth checking the form.

Drives & RAID
As already suggested, the tower can take four disks, so add rather than replace. There should be a guide in the box, but to get ahead of the game check Apple Support ( here looks a good start) so you are buying the right sort of disks. Should be about as easy as you'd hope.
Be aware the Leopard includes Time Machine as a very simple backup/look back in time system. It will also work on remote disks (e.g. a USB disk plugged into an Airport station) so that might open up other options.
I can't really help with RAID, other than what PJ S has said.

Leopard
Is the next OS, due October. Fully 64 bit, it should give a very useful speed improvement on your new machine, especially PShop type stuff (according to the demonstration). That's on top of the new features.
Just so you know, there are no upgrade paths (except for the few who buy a new machine in the very last days of Tiger). You just buy the one set of disks - none of that Home SuperStandard, Non-Media Edition rubbish. I think it will be £79.
Installation should be a doddle:
- Confirm your data backup (just in case, as ever)
- Insert disk
- Choose Upgrade option.
- It works out what to do, carries over all settings.
- Wander back occasionally to put another disk in or something.
- Start working - everyhting shuld still work, no typing in a password that isn't recognised, etc.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
HiRich said:
I've never heard of memory problems from Crucial. Macs are certainly sensitive to the quality of the RAM boards inserted, but Crucial is always the default safe option - always recommended by the magazines.
I bought a 1GB module from Crucial to add to the standard 1GB in my MacBook Pro, and it started to hang solid intermittently in both OSX and Vista - swapped the modules to the other slots and it's been absolutely fine since.

Not sure exactly, but it suggests some sort of hardware timing issue that I've no inclination to investigate any further. smile

ehasler

Original Poster:

8,579 posts

314 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
PJ S said:
I wouldn't replace the original HDD, but add the Raptors to the unit.
You can do HW RAID or SW RAID - the former requires a PCI-E daughterboard as the Mac doesn't do HW based RAID on its logic board (motherboard).
The alternative is to use Disk Utility (inc in the OS) or SoftRAID to do the SW RAID method, but RAID5 isn't an option - 1 and 0 are it.
I'd like to replace the system disk with a Raptor get a performance boost, and also want to use 2 of them in a RAID 1 configuration for backup. Then I'll have 2 more Raptors in RAID 0 for data (backed up to an external HDD)

Has anyone replaced the system disk - is it as easy as adding the new disk, copying everything over then physically swapping the drives? Or will it be easier to just put the new drive in and re-install the OS from scratch?

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
A few things to note:

1) The Raptor is fast, but a RAID-0 Array of two cheap 7200rpm drives is much faster, and costs less http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/03/12/cheap_raid_...

2) You could use Carbon Copy Cloner or Super Duper to clone the original boot disk to the new boot disk

3) Unless you add a RAID card you will be using OSX software RAID. This is probably not the highest performing solution!

ehasler

Original Poster:

8,579 posts

314 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
robbieduncan said:
A few things to note:

1) The Raptor is fast, but a RAID-0 Array of two cheap 7200rpm drives is much faster, and costs less http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/03/12/cheap_raid_...

2) You could use Carbon Copy Cloner or Super Duper to clone the original boot disk to the new boot disk

3) Unless you add a RAID card you will be using OSX software RAID. This is probably not the highest performing solution!
A RAID-0 array of 2 Raptors is faster still biggrin I don't want to go RAID-0 for the system drive though - I've made that mistake before!!

I'll see how I get on with the software RAID, and will look into hardware options later.

Ta for the pointer to Carbon Copy Cloner and Super Duper - will look into these.


PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
Add another decent drive (Samsung say) and use it and the original for RAID1
Slap in your Raptors for RAID0 work - Audio/Video/Graphics

You can partition off the Mirrored drives so that the OS is not copied, but this will result in the second drive with the same size unused - 60GB should be sufficient.

If you're going to all that length, I'd just run the Install from scratch again, once you've partitioned the drive and set the others for their RAID modes.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
ehasler said:
robbieduncan said:
A few things to note:

1) The Raptor is fast, but a RAID-0 Array of two cheap 7200rpm drives is much faster, and costs less http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/03/12/cheap_raid_...

2) You could use Carbon Copy Cloner or Super Duper to clone the original boot disk to the new boot disk

3) Unless you add a RAID card you will be using OSX software RAID. This is probably not the highest performing solution!
A RAID-0 array of 2 Raptors is faster still biggrin I don't want to go RAID-0 for the system drive though - I've made that mistake before!!

I'll see how I get on with the software RAID, and will look into hardware options later.

Ta for the pointer to Carbon Copy Cloner and Super Duper - will look into these.
I use a RAID-0 of Raptors as the boot drive on my G5 Quad nuts

And Carbon Copy Cloner to regularly back the Suicide Raid up smile

nrayner

3,058 posts

313 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
ehasler said:
thumbup Good call! Just seen my ideal spec on the refurb site, so have ordered one biggrin
thumbup Nice one