Dumb Q about software upgrades on Mac
Dumb Q about software upgrades on Mac
Author
Discussion

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
I'm quite religious when it comes to software upgrades on the Mac and usually let it download the upgrades useful to me as soon as it works out there is a new version...

However, if i keep upgrading at around 50Mb a time, won't my hard drive eventually fill up..? What happens to the old upgrade after the new one - is there anyway of keeping an eye on how much drive space is being used by these upgrades?

If i wiped the hard drive and started from scratch, the computer would download the latest upgrades, would this cut down on the cumulative drive space the upgrades previously took, or would it still need to download all of the previous upgrades anyway?

Cheers ~PHIL

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
A 50Mb update does not take 50Mb of disk space.

The way that Apple updates work is that if you need to update a file the update contains the whole file, not just the changes. This is simpler and more likely to work properly which is why they do it.

So if we take an example. Let's say Apple want to update the iTunes executable. This is a very large (probably around 50Mb) binary file. A bug file will probably have an executable file that is about the same size as the current one. So whist you have to download 50Mb you will end up using a few more or less Kb at worst after the update.

Now some updates contain new files, or significantly larger files, but this is quite rare.

So in short: don't worry about it: you're probably not using much space at all.

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Ah ok, thanks...

The other thing, is that i am assuming that the computer deals with the upgrades? I have never had to "open" anything after a download (the occasional restart) so therefore i am guessing it deals with 'stitching' of the required upgrades...(?)

Cheers ~PHIL

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
The "old" software is overwritten - so aside (as said above) from any additional data, you'll have the same amount of space as previously.
It's not like a library where you have multiple copies of the same book, with differing revisions - each book when superseded, is simply dumped in the incinerator.
Some of those new books might have more pages than the previous revision had, and will take up a little more shelf room, but you only have the one copy to pick up and read.

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Buffalo said:
Ah ok, thanks...

The other thing, is that i am assuming that the computer deals with the upgrades? I have never had to "open" anything after a download (the occasional restart) so therefore i am guessing it deals with 'stitching' of the required upgrades...(?)

Cheers ~PHIL
Yep Software Update deals with all of it. Occasionally it might need your help, for example closing iTunes so it can copy the new version on top of the old, but in general it just does what is needed without bothering you...

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Actually OS X *does* keep records of what's been updated via Software Update.

Look in /Library/Receipts!

However the files within aren't the full packages as downloaded from the update servers - my Receipts folder (on a Quad G5 that started with an upgrade to Tiger and then updated all the way) is only 200 MB in size. It's used so SU can determine what upgrades are required by the system.

Each 'package' in the Receipts folder contains a BOM (bill of materials) which lists the contents of the original update package, plus a diff of what's changed, and an alias to the original package (which is deleted, so the alias doesn't go anywhere... that's why you're not losing vast amounts of disk space).

HTH.

PJR

2,616 posts

243 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Do you not have much HD space? If thats an issue, externals are extremely cheap these days. Like £100 or less for a 500gb drive.
But as has been said.. OS updates don't eat into hd space that much..

P,

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Hmm - jsut checked my receipts folder; lots there but just 197Mb in size so not so bad. Will keep eye on it in future to see if it gets any larger.

As for total HD space, i have a MBP1 so i think it is 100Gb. Big, but not that big these days... My music is about 30Gb, my photos around 15Gb, and my documents probably less than a Gb so i was trying to work out where the rest of it went...

Cheers ~PHIL

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Buffalo said:
Hmm - jsut checked my receipts folder; lots there but just 197Mb in size so not so bad. Will keep eye on it in future to see if it gets any larger.

As for total HD space, i have a MBP1 so i think it is 100Gb. Big, but not that big these days... My music is about 30Gb, my photos around 15Gb, and my documents probably less than a Gb so i was trying to work out where the rest of it went...

Cheers ~PHIL
What software do you have installed? Both GarageBand and iMovie, when installed with all options, eat gigabytes.

Be warned that no unix operating system likes running out of disk space on the boot volume (well no OSes like that TBH) so it's wise to always have a couple of gig free.

If you think something's up or there's a runaway log file or other large files you don't need, then use Get Info in the Finder on each folder in the root of your filesystem, it will take a while as it counts each file in all the folders within the folder you're asking about, but it will highlight the biggest - you can then recurse into this.

FWIW iPhoto keeps revisions of photos. If your pics are big DSLR raw files or very big jpegs and you edit them, the old version is kept on disk.

Oh yeah, and if you want to put a bigger HD *inside* your MBP, take it to an apple shop or an authorised reseller. I have totally dismantled two MBP rev.A machines, firstly to try to sort the heatpipe issue, and secondly to fix the absolutely shite Matshita optical drive in mine. They are a right pain in the arse to dismantle, and HD replacement is *not* for the faint hearted...

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
Buffalo said:
FWIW iPhoto keeps revisions of photos. If your pics are big DSLR raw files or very big jpegs and you edit them, the old version is kept on disk.
It keeps Original and Modified version only (so 2 total). It does this in case you totally mess up an edit and want to go back to the start. Aperture is much cleverer in this respect: It only keeps the original file and just records the "recipe" of the changes made to apply when needed.

jmorgan

36,010 posts

315 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Not sure is this is any help but came across this a while ago. probably recommended in a mag or something.
whatsize

Find it handy to check my disk quickly once in a while as I am on an emac (small disk) and to see if there is anything needing shifting to the external HD.

PJR

2,616 posts

243 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
There are utilities around that can help you save rather a lot of disk space on a Mac. Although its not impossible to do it manually yourself either. What they do is basically junk all the surplus language kits and excess printer drivers which you just wont use.
You also have options to omit this stuff when installing the OS (custom install). Which is the best time to do it really (this is what I do). And you can always install the stuff again later, just incase you need it at some other time.

And yes, junk apps you don't use, and their associated files. Apps like garageband takes up a lot of room, as it generally has a ton of audio files with it. Obviously you need to delete the app and the associated files separately, as they are in different places. So for example, the garageband files should be found in the "HD > Library > Application Support > Garageband" folder. Probably a similar deal with other apps, such as iMovie and the like too.
X11 is not installed by default, but if for some reason it is installed and you don't use it, then you can scrap that too to save on a fair chunk of HD space.

P,

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
robbieduncan said:
cyberface said:
FWIW iPhoto keeps revisions of photos. If your pics are big DSLR raw files or very big jpegs and you edit them, the old version is kept on disk.
It keeps Original and Modified version only (so 2 total). It does this in case you totally mess up an edit and want to go back to the start. Aperture is much cleverer in this respect: It only keeps the original file and just records the "recipe" of the changes made to apply when needed.
True-tastic.

However if the OP is using Aperture, I'd advise that the OP learns a lot more about OS X first. With a photo collection of 15 GB it's unlikely he's using RAW files on a modern SLR anyway... but Aperture is a pro app (as you're obviously aware) and it doesn't sound like he's using it...

Personally wouldn't want to use Aperture on a MBP without a decent big external drive (not helped by the fact that the MBP rev A only has FW400) - the screen is good (though not as good as the immediately previous G4 powerbook which I had) and you can bolt on a big screen, but laptop HDs and RAW files with multiple edits do not a happy combo make.

Tell me if I'm wrong though - I'm not a pro photog (just a Nikon D50 for fun) and my Mac use is more to do with Unix and hacking than content creation... smile

Getting quotes right on PH is getting damn complicated...

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Actually I am using Aperture... But I am not very good at it! hehe Most of the photos we have are from my girlfriends point and shoot (i had film SLR before) and i only have around 9 or so Gb of RAW DSLR shots in Aperture waiting for me to process and ship off to some form of external storage (haven't decided which way to go) as i have only had my DSLR about two months. Of course i have to learn Aperture so this is slow - you can tell that i haven't quite grasped all of this technology, but that i am trying! rolleyeshehe

The reason i have the MBP is that i could salary sacrifice it, but i couldn't for a desktop. I'm still gutted by the roll-out of the MBP2 so soon after i bought my MBP, given that i waited a fair time before buying to make sure some bugs were ironed out etc and did my homework, but obviously missed the forthcoming MBP2 specs :sigh...: Still best not think like that now...

I'll probably get rid of iMovie and Garageband as i do not use these apps.

Cheers smile

Buffalo

Original Poster:

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
PJR said:
TApps like garageband takes up a lot of room, as it generally has a ton of audio files with it. Obviously you need to delete the app and the associated files separately, as they are in different places. So for example, the garageband files should be found in the "HD > Library > Application Support > Garageband" folder. Probably a similar deal with other apps, such as iMovie and the like too.
X11 is not installed by default, but if for some reason it is installed and you don't use it, then you can scrap that too to save on a fair chunk of HD space.

P,
Is there no "uninstall" option? Or do i just move the app to trash from finder and then go hunting for associated files..?

What is X11..?

Cheers... ~PHIL

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Don't worry about X11 - if you don't know what it is, it's not important.
As for the Apps - typically ones dropped into the Apps folder are "Trash and Empty", but others that require an Admin password will have an uninstaller which you can run instead.
The easiest way to find any remnants - .plist files, App support, etc is to use Spotlight (Command Spacebar by defualt) and type in the App or software company to find them.
Highlight the resultant files you want to remove and Control click or Right Click and selcet Reveal In Finder.
Delete and empty - job done.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Equally don't worry about the old MBP vs the new MBP. The processor difference in your case is not really significant - the main issue being that the new one can take 3 GB of RAM and the old one maxes at 2 GB RAM.

If you went for the 256 MB video RAM upgrade for the graphics card in the rev A MBP you have, then it may be quicker in Aperture, especially if you use an external screen.

The MBPs can drive the 30" panels you know hehe