Assessing personal injury claim - Kemp & Kemp?
Assessing personal injury claim - Kemp & Kemp?
Author
Discussion

Steve_T

Original Poster:

6,356 posts

303 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
My wife had an accident at a venue some time ago, where a folding chair collapsed under her, causing the frame surrounding it to scrape up her back, leaving a deep abrasion several inches long. This caused her discomfort over several following weeks and she's now left with a permanent scar.

I've discussed the matter with a friend who told me Kemp & Kemp would most likely be what would be used to determine an appropriate settlement. I'm now at a stage where I need to either write to the venue in question to propose an amount for her compensation, or engage a solicitor to resolve the matter on her behalf. We've not had a lot of joy in finding a decent solicitor to date and I'm very tempted to take the matter on personally via County Court. Am I being foolish looking to take this on myself, or if not, how can I get access to Kemp & Kemp to determine an appropriate settlement?

Thanks,

Steve.

oldsoak

5,618 posts

233 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Steve_T said:
how can I get access to Kemp & Kemp to determine an appropriate settlement?

Thanks,

Steve.
http://www.infolaw.co.uk/pod/sm-kemp.htm

With a healthy bank balance...or get to know someone who already has the CD....



Edited by oldsoak on Friday 13th July 16:11

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Whilst taking it on yourself may seemingly be a quick way forward, I would advise against it.

Indeed, taking the matter to County Court as next course of action I would also advise against. The huge majority of these kind of claims are settled before court due to the fact that because of the costs involved the threat of going to court is a big bargaining tool. The venue will of course lose the case and be liable to pay for the court costs, their solicitors costs and your solicitors costs. Due to this fact they awould rather pay out more before court than risk the definate legal costs.

It may also be the case that the venue will not be picking up the cost of the compensation, it will be their insurers. Their insurers will no doubt use their own solicitors to argue the case and minimise what they pay out.


RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Hi, I have PMd you and can help. Details about me on my profile. I see some good and sensible advice on here so far. I can ensure the case is settled fairly for you, so give me a call, any time,

HTH

Richard

Edited by RichBurley on Friday 13th July 16:14

Steve_T

Original Poster:

6,356 posts

303 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Whilst taking it on yourself may seemingly be a quick way forward, I would advise against it.

Indeed, taking the matter to County Court as next course of action I would also advise against. The huge majority of these kind of claims are settled before court due to the fact that because of the costs involved the threat of going to court is a big bargaining tool. The venue will of course lose the case and be liable to pay for the court costs, their solicitors costs and your solicitors costs. Due to this fact they awould rather pay out more before court than risk the definate legal costs.

It may also be the case that the venue will not be picking up the cost of the compensation, it will be their insurers. Their insurers will no doubt use their own solicitors to argue the case and minimise what they pay out.
Regarding avoiding court, that's what I'd expect Justin.

The potted history goes as follows. Write to venue re the incident, they say they're passing the matter to their insurers, nothing happens, family matters intervene for a time, then write to the venue again some months later and this time the insurers reply. In the initial letter compensation was requested at a given level, soon after the incident. No response from the insurers. In the second letter to the venue, they were instructed that the previous settlement requested would no longer be acceptible because of the scaring. The insurers are now in correspondence with my wife and I. The insurers have requested a picture of the injury as it is now. I also have camcorder footage my wife was taking during the seat collapse at the event and of the injury immediately after it happened.

While the insurers are talking to me, it feels like the best way to continue communicating with them, however, I don't want to make a cock up through lack of knowledge/experience. On the flip side, if I employ a solicitor now and a settlement is reached out of court, where would I stand with the solicitors fees? Any ideas?

Thanks,

Steve.

Steve_T

Original Poster:

6,356 posts

303 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
RichBurley said:
Hi, I have PMd you and can help. Details about me on my profile. I see some good and sensible advice on here so far. I can ensure the case is settled fairly for you, so give me a call, any time,

HTH

Richard

Edited by RichBurley on Friday 13th July 16:14
Thanks Richard, I'll check my email when I get home (can't access it at work).

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Steve_T said:
JustinP1 said:
Whilst taking it on yourself may seemingly be a quick way forward, I would advise against it.

Indeed, taking the matter to County Court as next course of action I would also advise against. The huge majority of these kind of claims are settled before court due to the fact that because of the costs involved the threat of going to court is a big bargaining tool. The venue will of course lose the case and be liable to pay for the court costs, their solicitors costs and your solicitors costs. Due to this fact they awould rather pay out more before court than risk the definate legal costs.

It may also be the case that the venue will not be picking up the cost of the compensation, it will be their insurers. Their insurers will no doubt use their own solicitors to argue the case and minimise what they pay out.
Regarding avoiding court, that's what I'd expect Justin.

The potted history goes as follows. Write to venue re the incident, they say they're passing the matter to their insurers, nothing happens, family matters intervene for a time, then write to the venue again some months later and this time the insurers reply. In the initial letter compensation was requested at a given level, soon after the incident. No response from the insurers. In the second letter to the venue, they were instructed that the previous settlement requested would no longer be acceptible because of the scaring. The insurers are now in correspondence with my wife and I. The insurers have requested a picture of the injury as it is now. I also have camcorder footage my wife was taking during the seat collapse at the event and of the injury immediately after it happened.

While the insurers are talking to me, it feels like the best way to continue communicating with them, however, I don't want to make a cock up through lack of knowledge/experience. On the flip side, if I employ a solicitor now and a settlement is reached out of court, where would I stand with the solicitors fees? Any ideas?

Thanks,

Steve.
You have done well so far, but in these kind of situations 'the devil is in the detail' and this is what the professionals get paid for. For example, at a later date, that fact that you have made an offer of £X may be held against you as they may well indeed accept your previous offer.

Whether exactly they could do this in this scenario is not the issue, it is that as a 'flyweight' fighting against a heavyweight champ you do need to make sure that you do not worsen your situation. Solicitors are paid to take the ruthless and emotionless decisions so you dont have to!

It certainly should be the case that you can claim reasonable solicitors costs as well as all other out of pocket and contributary expenses in your claim, as after all if they hadnt made the issue arise you wouldnt have had the solicitors fees! After all this is an assessment of your 'loss' for which through their negligence they should cover. Your solicitor will probably be more ruthless about this than you and push the extra mile.

For example, if a new type of treatment comes around in a few years time which would eradicate the scarring, but costs £15,000 then such a settlement through a solicitor might have covered this and you would be a bit miffed if you had settled for £1500 with no 'comeback' a few years earlier!

I must say that for minor issues my basic degree level understanding might put you in the right direction, but I would certainly for an issue as serious as this to consult a professional with a wealth of practical experience in this particular field!

RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
oooh! The disclaimer is back! Goodie!

Back to the topic. I just PMd to say I can help, and gave someone valuation info. What I try to do is look after all the PistonHeaders as best as possible, so give me a call this evening, I'll give you seen free advice (I might league the Super League rugby on on the background, I have a vested interest as a Hull KR fan) and if I can take it from there for you, then I'll let you know all the options.

Rich

Steve_T

Original Poster:

6,356 posts

303 months

Friday 13th July 2007
quotequote all
Thanks very much gents, your help greatly appreciated. Richard, I will call you this evening.

Steve.

RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
I'm glad to have been of assistance in this situation. Matter resolved!

Speak soon,

You owe me a trip in your Tiv!

Rich

Edited by RichBurley on Thursday 20th March 11:16

Steve_T

Original Poster:

6,356 posts

303 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
Actually that's two matters resolved. biggrin If anyone asks for advice, I will not hesitate in recommending Burleys.

Steve.