Laptop (Tablet?) Recommendation
Laptop (Tablet?) Recommendation
Author
Discussion

JohnP68

Original Poster:

426 posts

313 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
Looking to buy a laptop. Will mainly be used by my other half, when she's away from home on her new degree course. I quite like the idea of having a laptop that we can use at home in any room, mainly to be able to browse the internet without being unsociable and going in a separate room to the rest of the family (got wireless internet and print server at home). Doesn't need to be particularly powerful, as unlikely to be playing games etc, will just be using Word of Excel most of the time.

I'm quite attracted to the idea of getting a laptop on which the screen can rotate so that it can be used in tablet and touchscreen format, eg for internet browsing, and used in normal laptop format when the keyboard is needed, eg when using Word. However, I've noticed that not many laptops are available in this format, so I wonder if there is a major drawback to them that I haven't thought about. Any views on this please? Also, anyone care to recommend a particular manufacturer or model please (no particular budget - will spend whatever is necessary to get the "right" one).

Thanks for any help.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
If you want a tablet then there are quite a lot of these on ebay. The popular ones are the HP/Compaq ones which are a few years old but should run xp ok. Can't offer any more advice over new tablets but Acer laptops get good write ups and I've got an HP laptop from John Lewis which is great.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Saturday 14th July 2007
quotequote all
I don't own a tablet. But a lot of reviews I see can be summed up as "It's a giant PDA" and "Works good, except for this really annoying bit".

Odd bod things like the handwriting thing working everywhere but the web browser, so you'd be able to surf PH but not reply to PH other than rotating it back round or using the on-screen keyboard.

Personally, I have them in the same 'giant expensive toy' as a PDA, but you might be difference.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
"Odd bod things like the handwriting thing working everywhere but the web browser"

Really ? Have been using a TabletPC now for 4 years, on my second convertible and I have just got a UMPC (small 7" tablet) and have not heard about that one. Works perfectly in Explorer, there were problems with Firefox et al, but the user community for these things is very much at the nerd end of the market, so that was fixed pretty quickly ! Doesn't now happen in Vista, as the TIP (Tablet Input Panel - the handwritingy input thing) is now reachable from the side of the screen (i.e. it doesn't rely on the application telling it to open, like it did in XP Tablet Edition. Journalists never really "get" Tablets anyway, they sit at desks mainly, and rely on 30 minutes use to form an opinion - usually "you can't type a 3000 word article without a keyboard, so it is crap".

Anyway, drawbacks ? Well, obviously there are some. But first, what are the drawbacks of a laptop ? Primarily it doesn't fit well on your lap ! On the sofa, in an airport, on one of the new trains where the seat in front slopes back so much you can prop a laptop up very well .... laptops don't balance on your knee very well.

"mainly to be able to browse the internet without being unsociable" ... is spot on, and exactly the reason I have my small Origami device. Sat on sofa, have a thought, grab UMPC and have a quick surf. Navigating the internet with a pen (or your finger) is very very natural, and so much more fun than a mouse. You can do it while lying on you back, or in bed too.

Sure, you can do that on a smartphone (with good eyesight) or your PMP or Nokia do an Internet Tablet thingy. What a tablet gives you on top of this (for a price, obviously) is that it IS a windows PC, it doesn't try to emulate one. Explorer is explorer. Word is word.

The trendy nerd term for imagining how you might use different form factor devices is "Usage Scenarios". Your usage defines what best device to get. If primarily you want to surf on the sofa, then the larger tablets might get a bit heavy (the trend now is stuff as much as possible into these devices, when originally they tried to keep them small). However, it does mean that they convert perfectly into "just a laptop" with no compromises.

Not all devices convert, you can get "slates" which have no keyboard. And now for the downside - no keyboard = major pain to type. People may tell you otherwise, and they are right in that handwriting recognition is pretty good (and it is even better in Vista, which allows you to train the recognition), but there is no way I would want to type all of this using anything other than a full keyboard. But for a bit of text, they are quite usuable. And it is worth thinking about actually how much typing you do whilst surfing, compared to clicking. The smaller UMPC/Origami devices (7" screen, very portable, but more like a game console in looks than a laptop - still a windows PC though) have other methods of input, such as a thumb operated screen keyboard, or mini keyboards built into the chassis.

I currently have a Toshiba M400 tablet. It is a very good laptop, pretty powerful, and has a built in DVD drive. Downsides is that it is quite heavy, and you get a bit of arm ache after a while. That power comes at a cost, and the fan is pretty noisy to keep it cool. Something common to many of the "power" tablets. The dual core chips get hot, no way round that. It uses an active digitiser which means it isn't a "touchscreen" as such. It only responds to a particular pen. This is great for accuracy, as it doesn't respond to your hand resting on it. I have just got a Samsung Q1 Ultra Origmai device too, for exactly the "sociability" reasons you outlined. It is small enough to be discrete, and is easy to hold in one hand. It is a passive digitiser. So you can prod with your finger. Easy. But can think your hand is the pen, so not as accurate. It isn't particuarly powerful however, can run word/excel quite happily. And with no keyboard, you don't want to write essays - you could get a USB keyboard, or even plug it into a monitor. That works quite well.

Before the M400 I had an M200, which was smaller and lighter and was actually a very portable device. I didn't get a choice in the replacement (dropped it !) as I would not have gone for the M400, not that it isn't very good, it is just a bit big. The battery life isn't brilliant, and I found myself not bothering to use it as a tablet. Which is a waste.

What I would have got instead, and which might suit, is a Fujitsu-Siemens Lifebook P1610. One of the smallest convertible tablets with a 8.6" screen. And comfortable to hold in one hand. Just under half the weight of my M400. Runs a passive digitiser, you you can prod with a finger.

Really depends on what you see yourselves doing with it. The main gotcha is that it is over £1200 ! Which would get you a laptop and a nice wifi phone and some change left over.

If you want to be able to work places without a flat surface, then tablets are worth it, without a doubt. But you can equally see why people who never have the requirement to update a document and send it whilst sitting on a cramped train would think it was a waste of money. All depends on your usage scenario.

The killer for me is this scenario - Busy day with client. Hotel bar, which has Wifi (or 3G access via phone), beer in one hand, tablet propped up on knee, checking out my favourite websites. Perfect !

tvrforever

3,196 posts

296 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
HP tablet (http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/us/en/en/WF25a/321957-321957-64295-304455-306995-1847962.html) user here would fully recommend!

I use it as a laptop about 70% of the time - and then a tablet for when reviewing & marking up documents (word, pdf, powerpoint etc) as the hand written comment stuff and ability to feestyle mark on documents makes it so so so much easier and faster for me.

Also often use Journal to take meeting notes etc as can be very effective.

groomi

9,331 posts

274 months

Sunday 15th July 2007
quotequote all
I've been using a Toshiba Portege M205 for about two years now. It seems to work pretty well. The reason I bought it was to replace taking a notepad into meetings with the belief that I could effectively write my notes directly into the diary entry for the meeting, so I'd never have to file the notes away. Never have quite worked out how to do that and anyway, it quickly became apparent that I still needed a folder to carry home all the papers everyone else would give to me at the meetings.

The best bit about it for me is being able to draw directly onto pictures. So for example, when on-site I can take a photo of a room on my mobile, bluetooth it across to the Tablet PC, then sketch real-time ideas over the top of the photo while talking with my client. The results are pretty rough but the clients lap up the high-tech bit. smile

All in all, the theory appeals to me but the practice seems a bit pointless. For your use I'd recommend getting the smallest, lightest normal laptop you can find.

HTH smile