Discussion
Am going to pick up a new computer as my current one (which is 6years old now) just cant hack it any more 
I am doing a bit of research and have a few questions with regards to graphics, as they have come on quite a bit from my 128mb Nvidia 5200!
How good is the:
nVidia 8800GTX with 768mb?
and what is a:
Physics PCI card?
I was always under the impression AGP was the way to go...
thanks very much!
Aconfusedbloke

I am doing a bit of research and have a few questions with regards to graphics, as they have come on quite a bit from my 128mb Nvidia 5200!
How good is the:
nVidia 8800GTX with 768mb?
and what is a:
Physics PCI card?
I was always under the impression AGP was the way to go...
thanks very much!
Aconfusedbloke
Really excellent graphics card. Depending on what you are doing however, as to whether it is overkill. It supports the new(ish) DirectX 10 for gaming, and these are only recently coming out in any numbers.
PCI is BACK ! PCI Express replaced AGP replaced PCI.
A physics card basically determines what happens when stuff blows up and some other tedious stuff about things knocking into one another, but mainly stuff blowing up ! Not what it looks like (that is the GPUs job) but where it goes and what happens when it runs into to other things. So it models the physics.
Ultimately they will let game designers model so many more things that are moveable, or can interact with other things - drop that barrel on that chair etc. But mostly it is to allow more zombie organs to splatter the scenery
PCI is BACK ! PCI Express replaced AGP replaced PCI.
A physics card basically determines what happens when stuff blows up and some other tedious stuff about things knocking into one another, but mainly stuff blowing up ! Not what it looks like (that is the GPUs job) but where it goes and what happens when it runs into to other things. So it models the physics.
Ultimately they will let game designers model so many more things that are moveable, or can interact with other things - drop that barrel on that chair etc. But mostly it is to allow more zombie organs to splatter the scenery

AdamT said:
Am going to pick up a new computer as my current one (which is 6years old now) just cant hack it any more 
I am doing a bit of research and have a few questions with regards to graphics, as they have come on quite a bit from my 128mb Nvidia 5200!
How good is the:
nVidia 8800GTX with 768mb?
and what is a:
Physics PCI card?
I was always under the impression AGP was the way to go...
thanks very much!
Aconfusedbloke
When I specced my current PC (Intel Extreme Quad core & 8800 GTX), I very nearly bought the Physics PCI card, but was told it's just not worth it, I was told that with a modern set up with the best parts, the Physics card would be a waste, get a Creative Extrme XFi soundcard for the spare PCI slot instead.
I am doing a bit of research and have a few questions with regards to graphics, as they have come on quite a bit from my 128mb Nvidia 5200!
How good is the:
nVidia 8800GTX with 768mb?
and what is a:
Physics PCI card?
I was always under the impression AGP was the way to go...
thanks very much!
Aconfusedbloke
Edited by chris watton on Monday 16th July 16:25
the 8800GTX card rocks, I actually have two of them in my system. One thing to be aware of tho is that these cards are huge, if you're going to spec a new system make sure that your new case is going to be able to handle the card as well as other devices (normally it will be close to where your hdd's will be).
The Agiea cards are, atm just pure hype, there isn't too much that runs in conjunction with the PhysX card and it's not worth it for the moment. There is actually talk of Nvidia bringing out PhysX cards of their own, working in line with SLI which could be interesting.
One thing to be careful of if you decide to get a SB sound card and want to run SLI and or Vista, there are a number of issues with running NV SLI and SB xfi cards atm and Vista has thrown out the support for native SB cards, you would need to load a new bit of software from SB to get the card to work correctly.
The Agiea cards are, atm just pure hype, there isn't too much that runs in conjunction with the PhysX card and it's not worth it for the moment. There is actually talk of Nvidia bringing out PhysX cards of their own, working in line with SLI which could be interesting.
One thing to be careful of if you decide to get a SB sound card and want to run SLI and or Vista, there are a number of issues with running NV SLI and SB xfi cards atm and Vista has thrown out the support for native SB cards, you would need to load a new bit of software from SB to get the card to work correctly.
8800GTX - Fantastic Card
Physics Card - Waste of money - only works with a handful of games, and modern games are just using multiple CPU cores rather than suppoerting these physics cards.
Re: X-Fi and Vista, it's not that MS has removed the X-Fi support from Vista, they have removed hardware support for DirectSound, which means EVERY sound card/ chip has NO hardware support for games anymore.
The exception is new games which use openAL instead/ as well as DirectSound, as the X-Fi cards accellerates openAL calls under Vista.
The Creative Alchemy drivers for vista while not perfect allow DirectSound calls to be redirected to openAL calls, which the X-Fi cards can then use, thus giving users back the hardware accelleration MS took away, as well as EAX effects.

Physics Card - Waste of money - only works with a handful of games, and modern games are just using multiple CPU cores rather than suppoerting these physics cards.
Re: X-Fi and Vista, it's not that MS has removed the X-Fi support from Vista, they have removed hardware support for DirectSound, which means EVERY sound card/ chip has NO hardware support for games anymore.
The exception is new games which use openAL instead/ as well as DirectSound, as the X-Fi cards accellerates openAL calls under Vista.
The Creative Alchemy drivers for vista while not perfect allow DirectSound calls to be redirected to openAL calls, which the X-Fi cards can then use, thus giving users back the hardware accelleration MS took away, as well as EAX effects.

Simon. said:
the 8800GTX card rocks, I actually have two of them in my system. One thing to be aware of tho is that these cards are huge, if you're going to spec a new system make sure that your new case is going to be able to handle the card as well as other devices (normally it will be close to where your hdd's will be).
The Agiea cards are, atm just pure hype, there isn't too much that runs in conjunction with the PhysX card and it's not worth it for the moment. There is actually talk of Nvidia bringing out PhysX cards of their own, working in line with SLI which could be interesting.
One thing to be careful of if you decide to get a SB sound card and want to run SLI and or Vista, there are a number of issues with running NV SLI and SB xfi cards atm and Vista has thrown out the support for native SB cards, you would need to load a new bit of software from SB to get the card to work correctly.
I have twin 8800GTX cards and an X-Fi. I get a lot of crashes in Vista, but I put those down to heat, as my cards idle (yes idle) at 80 degrees unless I turn up the fans to 100%.The Agiea cards are, atm just pure hype, there isn't too much that runs in conjunction with the PhysX card and it's not worth it for the moment. There is actually talk of Nvidia bringing out PhysX cards of their own, working in line with SLI which could be interesting.
One thing to be careful of if you decide to get a SB sound card and want to run SLI and or Vista, there are a number of issues with running NV SLI and SB xfi cards atm and Vista has thrown out the support for native SB cards, you would need to load a new bit of software from SB to get the card to work correctly.
For this reason, I'm in the middle of a major job switching to watercooling.
What is the SLI + X-Fi issue?
AdamT said:
Re: The PCI card, it may be useless now, but in 2 years time it might be really useful...
You know how fast things move in PC land?Remember these cards were designed a couple of years ago now, they have been on sale for over a year, they don't even utilise the PCI-express bus, being old PCI.
AFAIK Agiea (or whatever they are called) are making money from there middleware SDK not from licensing the hardware.
I would say even now 2 cores of a quad core Core2Quad could probably calculate more than a physicsX card.
In the comming years we have 8 core CPU's comming and many games don't even use dual cores yet (to a decent degree). More developers are starting to make use of multi-core CPU's (as they become the norm) which are very good for physics proccessing, and a lot more common.
Then you have the whole GPGPU thing in the comming years whereby nVidia and AMD plan to start pushing Physics API's that canculate physics on 2nd or 3rd GPU's. The latest GPU's are a perfect match for physics calculations and again a lot more common then Physics Add in cards.
Even if physicX cards do get support it will NEED a new hardware revision to be much more powerful then the existing cards to have any point, so the current ones are... useless, pointless and worthless.
IMHO.
Does anyone have a list of all the supported games for the PhysicX?
I remember that one of the launch games (GRAW maybe) actually slowed down with the card

although the number of paticales/ objects may have been increased?
Zod said:
I have twin 8800GTX cards and an X-Fi. I get a lot of crashes in Vista, but I put those down to heat, as my cards idle (yes idle) at 80 degrees unless I turn up the fans to 100%.
For this reason, I'm in the middle of a major job switching to watercooling.
What is the SLI + X-Fi issue?
Have a look over at the slizone forums (Nvidia based) for some info on SLI and X-Fi.For this reason, I'm in the middle of a major job switching to watercooling.
What is the SLI + X-Fi issue?
Your idle temps are worrying to say the least, my cards idle at 55-60 and never go much above 70c under load, admittedly I am running at 80% fan speed.
One thing a lot of people don't appreciate is in case circulation (or lack of), on my old case running 7900 GTX's I would have idle temps in the 60-70s, the underload temps going 80+ occasionally (even saw it creep over 100c once before). When I built a new system I spent time making sure that not only were the cards\gpu sorted for cooling but also the case. Make sure your case has plenty of exhaust fans as well as intake, also make sure that ribbons cables etc aren't causing issues by blocking air flow.
As for Vista and SLI.. man, I have to admit you're brave, I have Vista Ultimate sat in a spare drive in my PC, I occasionally switch it over, update drivers etc and run it, but I have to say that performance wise I get much better from XP than Vista, that goes for iq as well as fps. Vista will get there but it's still not there yet.
Mr_Yogi said:
AdamT said:
Re: The PCI card, it may be useless now, but in 2 years time it might be really useful...
You know how fast things move in PC land?Remember these cards were designed a couple of years ago now, they have been on sale for over a year, they don't even utilise the PCI-express bus, being old PCI.
AFAIK Agiea (or whatever they are called) are making money from there middleware SDK not from licensing the hardware.
I would say even now 2 cores of a quad core Core2Quad could probably calculate more than a physicsX card.
In the comming years we have 8 core CPU's comming and many games don't even use dual cores yet (to a decent degree). More developers are starting to make use of multi-core CPU's (as they become the norm) which are very good for physics proccessing, and a lot more common.
Then you have the whole GPGPU thing in the comming years whereby nVidia and AMD plan to start pushing Physics API's that canculate physics on 2nd or 3rd GPU's. The latest GPU's are a perfect match for physics calculations and again a lot more common then Physics Add in cards.
Even if physicX cards do get support it will NEED a new hardware revision to be much more powerful then the existing cards to have any point, so the current ones are... useless, pointless and worthless.
IMHO.
Does anyone have a list of all the supported games for the PhysicX?
I remember that one of the launch games (GRAW maybe) actually slowed down with the card

although the number of paticales/ objects may have been increased?
adam
As above... the PPU's are a waste of time, especially as GPU's become ever-more programmable and general purpose in their instruction set. Yes, the PhysX hardware solutions are very fast but the read/write speeds to these cards is abysmal and it's preferable to run the physics simulations on on seperate CPU's (or CPU cores) or even on the GPU (for cosmetic only physics).
Depending on budget and end requirements the new G92 series from nVidia is looking mighty tasty. Having said that they are a while away yet, will be very expensive and also overkill for most things (at least initially).
Depending on budget and end requirements the new G92 series from nVidia is looking mighty tasty. Having said that they are a while away yet, will be very expensive and also overkill for most things (at least initially).
AdamT said:
nVidia 8800GTX with 768mb?
As other have said, they rock! I have one in the PC I bought last month.AdamT said:
Physics PCI card?
You're buying a Dell and I claim my £5. 
Dell seem to be pushing this at the moment (my new PC is also a Dell, BTW) but after some very brief research at the time I came to much the same conclusion as everyone else here - it's under-supported and of questionable use anyway.
Save your money.
First of all, I echo everyone else's comments concerning your hardware choice. 8800GTX = good. Physics card = bad. Just be aware that not all 8800GTX's are made equal - some are overclocked from the factory, so make sure you know exactly what you are getting.
I had the latter issue on my new system - which has SLI, 4Gb RAM and runs Vista x64 - but I seem to have solved it by reverting to an earlier Creative driver.
[k]
Zod said:
What is the SLI + X-Fi issue?
From personal experience, I can say that the X-Fi doesn't play nicely with certain hardware configurations, the most common of which appears to be SLI systems, and those with 4Gb RAM. The issue manifests itself as pops and crackles in the audio feed, or constant loud static as soon as the Windows audio engine fires up during boot. It seems to be more prevalent in Vista.I had the latter issue on my new system - which has SLI, 4Gb RAM and runs Vista x64 - but I seem to have solved it by reverting to an earlier Creative driver.
[k]
Edited by [k]arl on Tuesday 17th July 17:38
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


