Source Control
Author
Discussion

gopher

Original Poster:

5,160 posts

290 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
Hoping that there will be a few people on here with knowledge of source control.

We need a source control system that can be used by a distributed team (7 home workers in the UK, team in New York and another team in Yarmounth Nova Scotia), although the vast amount of sharing will be by the UK based people.

I'd like to hear your thoughts, good or bad, on the systems you use and if you recommend any system the reasons why.

Willing to consider open source or otherwise, cheap or expensive. It will be hosted on a third party box.

Cheers

Paul

nrayner

3,058 posts

313 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
Subversion. yes

It free.
It's Reliable.
It's Fast
Lots of other people use it so lots of help/papers/best practice around.
It's not bloated, but has all the tools you need.
If you want, it has integration with most IDEs, but not always for free (normally cheap). Haven't used that here though as the explorer integration via tortoise is damn good.

I've just implemented it here, it's really nice to use (free tool, tortoise, makes it a doddle).
Server set up is easy (based on Apache, but not that hard to pick up esp if you use other internet servers).
Uses a merge model, but you can also use in exclusive checkout mode (but you won't once you've tried the merge model).
Works across HTTP so few firewall type issues, and really nice across diverse locations on the interwebnet.

Feel free to PM me if you have more detailed questions.

trooperiziz

9,457 posts

283 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
nrayner said:
Subversion. yes

It free.
It's Reliable.
It's Fast
Lots of other people use it so lots of help/papers/best practice around.
It's not bloated, but has all the tools you need.
If you want, it has integration with most IDEs, but not always for free (normally cheap). Haven't used that here though as the explorer integration via tortoise is damn good.

I've just implemented it here, it's really nice to use (free tool, tortoise, makes it a doddle).
Server set up is easy (based on Apache, but not that hard to pick up esp if you use other internet servers).
Uses a merge model, but you can also use in exclusive checkout mode (but you won't once you've tried the merge model).
Works across HTTP so few firewall type issues, and really nice across diverse locations on the interwebnet.

Feel free to PM me if you have more detailed questions.
What he said.

GHW

1,294 posts

252 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
trooperiziz said:
nrayner said:
Subversion. yes
What he said.
yes

roadsweeper

3,790 posts

305 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
I haven't used Subversion so can't comment on that. However, I have used Visual SourceSafe (about 4yrs ago) and it was awful - difficult to use from the WAN and it corrupted the database one day for no obvious reason. After that, we switched to Vault (I think it was called) which looks very similar to SourceSafe but was HTTP based so much better for WAN use and much more reliable.

HTH,

roadie.

jimothy

5,151 posts

268 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
GHW said:
trooperiziz said:
nrayner said:
Subversion. yes
What he said.
yes
yes

Dogs danglies.

roadsweeper said:
I haven't used Subversion so can't comment on that. However, I have used Visual SourceSafe (about 4yrs ago) and it was awful
VSS is so bad even the Visual Studio 2003/2005 developers at MS wrote their own one rather than use it.

rebelstar

1,146 posts

275 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
Subversion again. I've seen tortoise but I've been using it from the command line with relative ease.

Currently using it for a couple of small (4-man) projects with developers in both the UK and the US. I needed to add some stuff to the repository while I was in California, no problems. We're even putting our documentation in there. (Gasp - developers and documentation!)

minimac

8,021 posts

234 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
nrayner said:
Subversion. yes

It free.
It's Reliable.
It's Fast
Lots of other people use it so lots of help/papers/best practice around.
It's not bloated, but has all the tools you need.
If you want, it has integration with most IDEs, but not always for free (normally cheap). Haven't used that here though as the explorer integration via tortoise is damn good.

I've just implemented it here, it's really nice to use (free tool, tortoise, makes it a doddle).
Server set up is easy (based on Apache, but not that hard to pick up esp if you use other internet servers).
Uses a merge model, but you can also use in exclusive checkout mode (but you won't once you've tried the merge model).
Works across HTTP so few firewall type issues, and really nice across diverse locations on the interwebnet.

Feel free to PM me if you have more detailed questions.
Words straight out my mouth. Good stuff smile

gopher

Original Poster:

5,160 posts

290 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
I've certainly been taken with what I have read about Subversion,it's good to get a response from people that have used it in the real world, but it was certainly towards the top of the list anyway.

Has anyone any experience of VS Team System?

Thanks for the replies so far, much appreciated.

Paul

nrayner

3,058 posts

313 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
Team System

Can't say I've actually used it but....

1. It COSTS (Capitals deliberate - ouch numbers to cover 40 developers)
2. It's version 1.

Not something I'd put my crown jewels (as in code !) inside.


roadsweeper

3,790 posts

305 months

Thursday 19th July 2007
quotequote all
Nobody seems to have mentioned good old CVS unless I've missed it? That's a very well developed source control system but it was command line only when I used it for a Java project for De Beers a few years ago so not as convenient as other systems in that regard.

Given what I've read on this topic, I'd probably go for Subversion if I were the OP. smile

hab1966

1,126 posts

243 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
Nrayner, sent you a PM as Im also interested in this.

jimothy

5,151 posts

268 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
rebelstar said:
Subversion again. I've seen tortoise but I've been using it from the command line with relative ease.

Currently using it for a couple of small (4-man) projects with developers in both the UK and the US. I needed to add some stuff to the repository while I was in California, no problems. We're even putting our documentation in there. (Gasp - developers and documentation!)
Tortoise is suberb, and Ankh if you want VS integration.

SlidingSideways

1,345 posts

263 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
roadsweeper said:
Nobody seems to have mentioned good old CVS unless I've missed it? That's a very well developed source control system but it was command line only when I used it for a Java project for De Beers a few years ago so not as convenient as other systems in that regard.

Given what I've read on this topic, I'd probably go for Subversion if I were the OP. smile
We're using CVS at the moment, and as soon as I get the chance, we're moving to Subversion.

CVS has moved on a bit since command line only. It's integration into IDE's is probably more advanced than Subversions (ie. It's standard in Eclipse, but there are a set of 3rd party Subversion plugins to choose from) and Tortoise also do a CVS/Explorer application.

However, despite Tortoise being very cool and easy to use, does anyone else fine it cripples your machine when browsing through source folders?

SLacKer

2,622 posts

238 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
Have used an opensource product FreeVCS for years. Rock solid 3 tier.

Now dealt with by Project JEDI http://jedivcs.sourceforge.net/

Use it integrated with DELPHI

minimac

8,021 posts

234 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
gopher said:
I've certainly been taken with what I have read about Subversion,it's good to get a response from people that have used it in the real world, but it was certainly towards the top of the list anyway.

Has anyone any experience of VS Team System?

Thanks for the replies so far, much appreciated.

Paul
Avoid VSTS/F!

Subversion with TortoiseSVN, utterly fantastic.

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Friday 20th July 2007
quotequote all
Anybody using Bugzilla/CVS NT? Haven't had an excuse to use it in anger but it looks like quite a cute combination.