Information for potential Elise/Exige owner please.
Discussion
Hey all!
I'm going travelling in a couple of months and when I get back, I will have hit 21 so will be looking for a more powerful (but not ridiculous!) car. At the top of my list lies an Exige, but depending on insurance costs/running costs/reliability and most importantly my height, I am also thinking about Elise's.
Firstly, which car will have the most headroom out of an S1 Elise, S2 Elise, S1 Exige and S2 Exige?
Obviously this is the most important factor to me, as there's no point in buying a car that I don't fit in. I'm 6ft4 and have quite long legs but I've heard that once you're actually in, you still have quite a bit of room, the hard part is just actually getting in it?
Also, what's the deal with the old Rover based engines VS. the Toyota's? I'm guessing the Rover's more likely to have head gasket problems etc. rather than the Japanese engine. Which Elise's have the Toyota Engine and do all Exige's have it?
Finally, any information about insurance, running costs, reliability on all models etc. would be greatly appreciated.
Originally I did want a Cerbera but I don't think at my age any insurance company will touch me! Plus the horror stories have sort of put me off.
Thanks a lot.
I'm going travelling in a couple of months and when I get back, I will have hit 21 so will be looking for a more powerful (but not ridiculous!) car. At the top of my list lies an Exige, but depending on insurance costs/running costs/reliability and most importantly my height, I am also thinking about Elise's.
Firstly, which car will have the most headroom out of an S1 Elise, S2 Elise, S1 Exige and S2 Exige?
Obviously this is the most important factor to me, as there's no point in buying a car that I don't fit in. I'm 6ft4 and have quite long legs but I've heard that once you're actually in, you still have quite a bit of room, the hard part is just actually getting in it?
Also, what's the deal with the old Rover based engines VS. the Toyota's? I'm guessing the Rover's more likely to have head gasket problems etc. rather than the Japanese engine. Which Elise's have the Toyota Engine and do all Exige's have it?
Finally, any information about insurance, running costs, reliability on all models etc. would be greatly appreciated.
Originally I did want a Cerbera but I don't think at my age any insurance company will touch me! Plus the horror stories have sort of put me off.
Thanks a lot.
The S1 has slightly more headroom because the seats are set half an inch lower but I suppose you can rectify that by fitting S1 seats to an S2. I'm 6' and have very long legs and don't have the seat all the way back (largely because I wouldn't be able to reach the steering wheel if I did). The S2 is slightly easier to get into because the sills are lower.
I think the engines are as follows:
Standard car = K-series
S1 135R = K-series
111 = K-series VVC
111S = K-series VVC
Sport160/Sport190 = K-series VHPD
S1 Exige = K-series VHPD
S2 Exige = Toyota (some of them super charged)
S2 111R = Toyota
S2 R = Toyota
S2 S = Toyota
S2 Sport Racer = Toyota
The K-series is a pretty good engine apart from the head gasket problem, especially in VVC guise. The Toyota is manic and high reving but doesn't have a great deal of torque. If you can afford either, then try both - I greatly preferred the VVC K-series.
If you intend to work on the car yourself, the K-series is better because it's a simpler engine.
Anything K-series (not VHPD) will return 38mpg in mixed driving unless you're pushing on (which you will be). I believe the 111R returns more like 30 under normal driving conditions from what I've heard. Insurance will probably be cheaper on a K-series engined car but it's possible that an S2 Exige will be cheaper because it's a coupe. I can't see why servicing costs would be significantly different for the different engines but I don't know.
If you're 21, insurance will be pretty steep. I'm 27 with 5 years NCB and I pay 600 quid a year. If you have full (4 years) no claims discount in your name, you'll probably be looking at 1000-1500 a year. If you have no NCD then you could be looking at well over 2000. I found elephant to be pretty cheap - get some quotes.
I think the engines are as follows:
Standard car = K-series
S1 135R = K-series
111 = K-series VVC
111S = K-series VVC
Sport160/Sport190 = K-series VHPD
S1 Exige = K-series VHPD
S2 Exige = Toyota (some of them super charged)
S2 111R = Toyota
S2 R = Toyota
S2 S = Toyota
S2 Sport Racer = Toyota
The K-series is a pretty good engine apart from the head gasket problem, especially in VVC guise. The Toyota is manic and high reving but doesn't have a great deal of torque. If you can afford either, then try both - I greatly preferred the VVC K-series.
If you intend to work on the car yourself, the K-series is better because it's a simpler engine.
Anything K-series (not VHPD) will return 38mpg in mixed driving unless you're pushing on (which you will be). I believe the 111R returns more like 30 under normal driving conditions from what I've heard. Insurance will probably be cheaper on a K-series engined car but it's possible that an S2 Exige will be cheaper because it's a coupe. I can't see why servicing costs would be significantly different for the different engines but I don't know.
If you're 21, insurance will be pretty steep. I'm 27 with 5 years NCB and I pay 600 quid a year. If you have full (4 years) no claims discount in your name, you'll probably be looking at 1000-1500 a year. If you have no NCD then you could be looking at well over 2000. I found elephant to be pretty cheap - get some quotes.
Thank you for the fast reply kambites!
I have a couple of questions, what is VVC and VHPD? I'm guessing they're more powerful versions of the K-Series but can you bring up a standard K-Series to the same power levels without too much work/expense?
Is the headgasket problem really that bad too? I've read plenty of horror stories but this is the internet and people don't tend to post threads with "my headgasket HASN'T gone".
Obviously from what you said an S1 K-Series Elise would make the most sense unless the insurance is much different on an Exige.
Do you get more or less headroom on the Exige because of the hard roof or is the exactly the same? I've somehow assumed that because you've got a roof, you would have lining, sound deadening? etc. in it thus making it lower than the Elise because it's just material? Or is the Exige roof higher to compensate for that?
I have the same problem in that my legs are quite long but my arms aren't that long, so in my current car I can't put the seat all the way or I won't be able to reach the steering wheel, even though my legs are very cramped up.
Also been told that if you're tall it's hard to get it into 5th because your knee ends up in the way?
And yeah, I am expecting to pay around £2,000 - £3,000 insurance wise. I would have thought because of the power the Exige would be a lot more to insure but you may be onto something with the soft-top/coupe thing, I'll check it out. I will have no no-claims bonus though unfortunately but I'll just have to take the shafting from the insurance co.
Thanks again for your reply!
I have a couple of questions, what is VVC and VHPD? I'm guessing they're more powerful versions of the K-Series but can you bring up a standard K-Series to the same power levels without too much work/expense?
Is the headgasket problem really that bad too? I've read plenty of horror stories but this is the internet and people don't tend to post threads with "my headgasket HASN'T gone".
Obviously from what you said an S1 K-Series Elise would make the most sense unless the insurance is much different on an Exige.
Do you get more or less headroom on the Exige because of the hard roof or is the exactly the same? I've somehow assumed that because you've got a roof, you would have lining, sound deadening? etc. in it thus making it lower than the Elise because it's just material? Or is the Exige roof higher to compensate for that?
I have the same problem in that my legs are quite long but my arms aren't that long, so in my current car I can't put the seat all the way or I won't be able to reach the steering wheel, even though my legs are very cramped up.
Also been told that if you're tall it's hard to get it into 5th because your knee ends up in the way?
And yeah, I am expecting to pay around £2,000 - £3,000 insurance wise. I would have thought because of the power the Exige would be a lot more to insure but you may be onto something with the soft-top/coupe thing, I'll check it out. I will have no no-claims bonus though unfortunately but I'll just have to take the shafting from the insurance co.
Thanks again for your reply!
There are quite a few Elise owners who are 6ft4, many of which opt for the detachable Momo steering wheel, which makes getting in a little bit easier! Might be an option, but to be honest with time and practice you will probably find your own method of getting in and out gracefully
As for running costs I would budget approximately £1000 per year for parts and maintainance.
Insurance is a bit of a lottery - Try www.confused.com and www.moneysupermarket.com to give you a rough idea ... Then try calling some specialist companies such as Adrian Flux and A-Plan to see what they can offer you. I'm 21 years old with one year's driving experience, one year's no claims bonus, a clean licence and I live in a nice area. Unfortunately the Exige was and still is an absolute no go for me ... It was difficult enough to get insured on a standard S1! Most insurance companies laughed at me down the phone. Elephant were rubbish - Quoted me £4700 for a fully comp policy. In the end I chose Kwik-Fit (Southern Rock), which was just over £2500
Hopefully next year it'll be a lot less - Worth it for the car though!
As for running costs I would budget approximately £1000 per year for parts and maintainance.Insurance is a bit of a lottery - Try www.confused.com and www.moneysupermarket.com to give you a rough idea ... Then try calling some specialist companies such as Adrian Flux and A-Plan to see what they can offer you. I'm 21 years old with one year's driving experience, one year's no claims bonus, a clean licence and I live in a nice area. Unfortunately the Exige was and still is an absolute no go for me ... It was difficult enough to get insured on a standard S1! Most insurance companies laughed at me down the phone. Elephant were rubbish - Quoted me £4700 for a fully comp policy. In the end I chose Kwik-Fit (Southern Rock), which was just over £2500
Hopefully next year it'll be a lot less - Worth it for the car though!Ah! I was the same ... Many of my friends tried to persuade me not to purchase the car due to the K-Series engine and it's habit of destroying head gaskets! It's not entirely true. The K-Series does go through head gaskets more than other engines might, but it doesn't happen as often as most people believe. However to cover yourself you can purchase an AA Parts & Warranty policy for about £69, which covers you for any failures or work that needs doing for up to £500. Lots of people on here have opted down this route, which reminds me, I need to do the same sometime!
It is a bit of a job getting into 5th anyway, no matter how long your legs are!
It is a bit of a job getting into 5th anyway, no matter how long your legs are!
Read the Buyers Guide sticky at the top of the forum - that will give you all the pointers you need. At 21 the one thing you can be certain of is that you'll get shafted for insurance. Expect to pay a lot (more than a grand), unless you're very, very fortunate and win the postcode lottery.
[quote=kambites]
I think the engines are as follows:
Standard car = K-series
S1 135R = K-series
111 = K-series VVC
111S = K-series VVC
Sport160/Sport190 = K-series VHPD
S1 Exige = K-series VHPD
S2 Exige = Toyota (some of them super charged)
S2 111R = Toyota
S2 R = Toyota
S2 S = Toyota
S2 Sport Racer = Toyota
quote]
That's not quite right...
For S1's you have:-
S1 111 - 118hp K-series
S1 Sport 135 - K-series with some head work etc to produce approx 135hp
S1 111S - VVC K-series producting approx 143ish hp
S1 Sport 160 - k-series with lumpy cams etc ... in SVA form approx 160hp and in WVTA form approx 150hp as standard
S1 Sport 190 - VHPD K-series producing anywhere between 165hp and 195hp depending on at what stage on a Friday afternoon the engine was built.
S1 Exige 177 - VHPD K-series producing approx 177hp
S1 Exige 190 - VHPD K-series with grenade pin pulled out
340R - Bastard child of S1 & S2 with a VHPD engine as above
For S2's you have:-
S2 111 - 118hp K-series
S2 135 Sport - K-series with some head work etc to produce approx 135hp
S2 135R - as above but with sportier suspension etc
S2 111S - VVC K-series with approx 155hp
S2 190 Sport - VHPD K-series
S2 111R - Toyota engined jobby with 190ish hp (not to up on gheyer S2's)
S2 S - Toyota engine jobby with less hp (not to up on gheyer S2's)
S2 Exige - Toyota engine jobby with 190ish hp
S2 Exige 240 Cup (+ other variants) - guess the power!
S2 Exige 220S - Toyota engine with supercharger producing approx 220hp
there's probably more... but I'm bored now
I think the engines are as follows:
Standard car = K-series
S1 135R = K-series
111 = K-series VVC
111S = K-series VVC
Sport160/Sport190 = K-series VHPD
S1 Exige = K-series VHPD
S2 Exige = Toyota (some of them super charged)
S2 111R = Toyota
S2 R = Toyota
S2 S = Toyota
S2 Sport Racer = Toyota
quote]
That's not quite right...
For S1's you have:-
S1 111 - 118hp K-series
S1 Sport 135 - K-series with some head work etc to produce approx 135hp
S1 111S - VVC K-series producting approx 143ish hp
S1 Sport 160 - k-series with lumpy cams etc ... in SVA form approx 160hp and in WVTA form approx 150hp as standard
S1 Sport 190 - VHPD K-series producing anywhere between 165hp and 195hp depending on at what stage on a Friday afternoon the engine was built.
S1 Exige 177 - VHPD K-series producing approx 177hp
S1 Exige 190 - VHPD K-series with grenade pin pulled out
340R - Bastard child of S1 & S2 with a VHPD engine as above
For S2's you have:-
S2 111 - 118hp K-series
S2 135 Sport - K-series with some head work etc to produce approx 135hp
S2 135R - as above but with sportier suspension etc
S2 111S - VVC K-series with approx 155hp
S2 190 Sport - VHPD K-series
S2 111R - Toyota engined jobby with 190ish hp (not to up on gheyer S2's)
S2 S - Toyota engine jobby with less hp (not to up on gheyer S2's)
S2 Exige - Toyota engine jobby with 190ish hp
S2 Exige 240 Cup (+ other variants) - guess the power!
S2 Exige 220S - Toyota engine with supercharger producing approx 220hp
there's probably more... but I'm bored now
Thanks again for the replies!
So from what I gather, if you're tall then once you're actually sat inside the car you have plenty of headroom etc.
It's just GETTING IN, which is the task? That's fine
Looks like it's likely to be an S1 K-Series Elise for me then, as I think anything over 3k insurance wise would be silly. I'm already paying over £1,500 for a Focus.
I'm sure I'll be asking more questions nearer the time. Thanks for all your help!
So from what I gather, if you're tall then once you're actually sat inside the car you have plenty of headroom etc.
It's just GETTING IN, which is the task? That's fine

Looks like it's likely to be an S1 K-Series Elise for me then, as I think anything over 3k insurance wise would be silly. I'm already paying over £1,500 for a Focus.
I'm sure I'll be asking more questions nearer the time. Thanks for all your help!
I don't think it matters how tall you are - Getting in and out for the first time is a mission for anyone!
It's one of the things I enjoy about Elise ownership, watching my friends struggle out of the passenger side, falling onto the pavement in style ... Go to your local dealership and arrange a test drive or just ask if you can sit in one, as you're concerned because of your height.
How long have you been driving for and how many NCB do you have?
It's one of the things I enjoy about Elise ownership, watching my friends struggle out of the passenger side, falling onto the pavement in style ... Go to your local dealership and arrange a test drive or just ask if you can sit in one, as you're concerned because of your height.How long have you been driving for and how many NCB do you have?
Edited by Ikemi on Thursday 26th July 09:41
Pillow Torque said:
I've been driving since I was 17 so it'll be 4 years when I'm actually looking for an Elise to buy.
I did have 2 years NCB but unfortunately lost it a few months ago. I won't be getting another one as I'm traveling for a year and won't have a car.
Why not insure an old car at your parents address as cheap as possible and get a years no claims under your belt whilst you travel.I did have 2 years NCB but unfortunately lost it a few months ago. I won't be getting another one as I'm traveling for a year and won't have a car.
siwil1 said:
Pillow Torque said:
I've been driving since I was 17 so it'll be 4 years when I'm actually looking for an Elise to buy.
I did have 2 years NCB but unfortunately lost it a few months ago. I won't be getting another one as I'm traveling for a year and won't have a car.
Why not insure an old car at your parents address as cheap as possible and get a years no claims under your belt whilst you travel.I did have 2 years NCB but unfortunately lost it a few months ago. I won't be getting another one as I'm traveling for a year and won't have a car.
It's an idea I've thought about though. Do you need TAX/MOT to have insurance, or can I just SORN an old scrapper and insure it?
The S2 111 was the VVC engine. It was the same as the 111S without the added luxuries. The 120bhp K-series engined car was just called the S2.
VHPD = very high performance derivative. Highly stressed version of the K-series with wild cams, etc.
VVC = variable valve control. Rover's continuously variable valve timing.
VHPD = very high performance derivative. Highly stressed version of the K-series with wild cams, etc.
VVC = variable valve control. Rover's continuously variable valve timing.
Edited by kambites on Thursday 26th July 11:07
Thanks mate, I think that's exactly what I will do. I've read about the headgasket thing on an Elise FAQ's page, and there are easy ways to find out of it's on it's way out and ways to keep it from blowing head gaskets.
Do you have a basic S1 or S2?
Anybody know all the figures for the standard basic S1 Elise?
bhp, 0-60, top speed, fuel consumption, etc?
Do you have a basic S1 or S2?
Anybody know all the figures for the standard basic S1 Elise?
bhp, 0-60, top speed, fuel consumption, etc?
Pillow Torque said:
Thanks mate, I think that's exactly what I will do. I've read about the headgasket thing on an Elise FAQ's page, and there are easy ways to find out of it's on it's way out and ways to keep it from blowing head gaskets.
Do you have a basic S1 or S2?
Anybody know all the figures for the standard basic S1 Elise?
bhp, 0-60, top speed, fuel consumption, etc?
Look for a 'mayo-like' substance on the oil filler cap/dipstick, which would be a good indication the head gasket has gone. I believe you can upgrade to a range of different head gaskets that will prevent a future failure. As long as you allow 10 minutes for the engine to warm up, another 10 minutes for the oil to warm up and after a blast you cruise to let everything cool down, you should do your upmost to prevent a HGF!Do you have a basic S1 or S2?
Anybody know all the figures for the standard basic S1 Elise?
bhp, 0-60, top speed, fuel consumption, etc?
I have a standard S1 and usually achieve 40mpg, even with a heavy right foot! Nearly as economic as some diesels!
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


