Email being sent from web server but only some received
Email being sent from web server but only some received
Author
Discussion

jacobyte

Original Poster:

4,768 posts

273 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
We have a website which sends email confirmations when various actions are performed. All fairly simple stuff (using CDONTS to sendmail). It gets sent to 3 recipients.

However, 1 of the recipients is not receiving confirmation emails from 1 of the actions (they receive confirmations from all other actions).

- The email is clearly being sent, as the other recipients are receiving.
- They have set up our web server IP address in their "allowed" rules.
- They deny it's being caught in a spam filter.
- They say it's not being sent to them in the first place, but we can show that it is being sent, as the other ccs are receiving and the from, to, cc, are identical in all emails

Any ideas how we can find where the email is going missing?

hutchingsp

68,542 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
jacobyte said:
Any ideas how we can find where the email is going missing?
Ultimately the best way is to look at the SMTP logs on the sending and receiving servers.

There's no 100% reliable way apart from that.

sp60

524 posts

290 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
Does sound like a spam filter type problem.
Do any of the words contain possibly blockable words in them
(such as Essex and Shorpe!!)
This could help point the finger a bit harder.
As has been said though, if you can see it going, it's pretty difficult to trace any further unless they allow you access to their server logs.
You could get them to send you a copy of an email they have received, analyse the headers to see if that gives you any pointers. It will at least tell you the route the email follows before reaching your client.

judas

6,251 posts

290 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
Having the same issue myself. If we address the emails to us, they always arrive, but some clients never get them. But emails sent to the same address from Outlook get through. At first we thought it was due to spam filtering or server blacklisting, but it's now looking more like it's improper headers. Some email servers are very strict about accepting emails that don't conform to some RFC or other. Still not got to the bottom of it yet so any help from those in the know would be good biggrin

hutchingsp

68,542 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
judas said:
Having the same issue myself. If we address the emails to us, they always arrive, but some clients never get them. But emails sent to the same address from Outlook get through. At first we thought it was due to spam filtering or server blacklisting, but it's now looking more like it's improper headers. Some email servers are very strict about accepting emails that don't conform to some RFC or other. Still not got to the bottom of it yet so any help from those in the know would be good biggrin
The problem is that unless you have access to the logs you are simply guessing. I'm responsible for the mail server at work.

From my point of view I know 100% that our server conforms to RFCs and every best practice you care to think of, is on no RBLs etc. yet if one of our users calls me to say they've had an email refused/returned from a recipients email system as "Content Rejected" I can tell them absolutely nothing as to why because unless the refusing system gives me more info it could simply be because it's a Thursday and they block all servers starting with a "r" on Thursdays smile

I know that sounds flippant, but basically once you've got beyond the stuff you can control, like RDNS, HELO syntax etc. you're into stuff you can't control where the only way you'll know is if they check their logs and tell you what's in them.

judas

6,251 posts

290 months

Thursday 26th July 2007
quotequote all
This conclusion came about after working closely with one of our client's ISPs and was suggested by one of their server admins.

The RFC I was referring to was not server setup but email format/construction.

Edited by judas on Thursday 26th July 21:36