Solidworks users - little help please?!
Solidworks users - little help please?!
Author
Discussion

Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
I'm trying to get a collection of lofted surfaces to form a solid object and am having no luck. I've got them all to knit fine, but it just will NOT thicken?!

As a test I made a new part and roughly re-created the surfaces, and this knitted and thickened fine, but the "real" one just wont do it.

What are the key causes of thickening failing? Would help if it gave a little more info than "failed" in the what's wrong dialogue rolleyes

oh - SW '06 BTW and I am definitely an amature with it!

Frik

13,695 posts

274 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
It's been a while since I've used the 'works, but have you checked the quality of all the knitted edges? No strange tangency requests leading to coiled over corners and that sort of thing?

As a regular user of Pro/Engineer's failure console, I feel your pain.

egomeister

7,614 posts

294 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
Not a Solidworks user myself (I use Catia) but could it be that the geometry is too "tight" so that when you try to thicken the solid it trying to overlap itself?

Will the surface thicken in one direction but not the other (ie, it will work "outwards" but not "inwards&quotwink

Will the surface itself offset to the distance you want?

Bodo

12,626 posts

297 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
egomeister said:
Not a Solidworks user myself (I use Catia) but could it be that the geometry is too "tight" so that when you try to thicken the solid it trying to overlap itself?

Will the surface thicken in one direction but not the other (ie, it will work "outwards" but not "inwards&quotwink

Will the surface itself offset to the distance you want?
Wot he sad^^
Being a Pro/E user myself, I'd check if thicken works with a lower value, and then check in preview where it collides.

Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
as far as I can tell the knitted edges all look fine, there was one suspect area but I tried running a thicken with that one removed from the knit and still no joy.

as for the geometry being too tight - I think it's unlikely but in all honesty with SW from my experience to date that doesn't count for much! The part I'm trying to knit and thicken is the front clam on my car design (pic in profile) so the only major return was the "bumper" area. The image in my profile pic is actually thickened perfectly, but due to relocating the radiator I'm having a bit of a redesign - a bit curvier, less of return angle on the front dam (which I thought would aid thickening!!)

It wont thicken inward or outward, or at any thickness from 1mm to 100mm.

It will however offset perfectly... confused

Why didn't I do this work in clay again?!

Church of Noise

1,660 posts

268 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
It's been a bit since I've used SW as well, but here's a (possibly stupid) idea: have you tried alternative ways of creating your 3d part, such (adding) extrusion(s)?
When things weren't working for me, it was sometimes a better idea to just use a different approach then to find the cause biggrin

Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
part of my problem is being such a rank amature at it, I don't know the software well enough to come up with alternative solutions yet. I have absolutely no doubt whatsoever I'm not doing it the best way - but it's the only way I could come up with!

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
Davi, can I ask where you get your sculpting clay from? Ironically I'm mostly a 3D software person and would love a go at sculpting bodywork.



Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Sunday 29th July 2007
quotequote all
I used to get all my sculpting equipment from a company called Jacobsons, but I've never worked on a full car body in clay and think it would work out a touch pricey from them - they were more aimed at smaller volume.