Laptop Synchronisation Software?
Laptop Synchronisation Software?
Author
Discussion

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,586 posts

241 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
When we get our new file server one of the plans is document redirection via Group Policy to get peoples My Documents onto the servers.

Laptop users will want to take their documents (or a subset) with them.

Just after any input on what people are using. Seems you go from free (Offline Files/Synctoy) to commercial and tbh I don't have time to test everything so am hoping to be able to compile a shortlist.

TIA.

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
When we get our new file server one of the plans is document redirection via Group Policy to get peoples My Documents onto the servers.

Laptop users will want to take their documents (or a subset) with them.

Just after any input on what people are using. Seems you go from free (Offline Files/Synctoy) to commercial and tbh I don't have time to test everything so am hoping to be able to compile a shortlist.

TIA.
We run offline folders for "my documents" in conjunction with dfs and it works a treat, dfs enables us to use \\domain\businessunit\datashare rather than \\servername\datashare and if we need to add another server or migrate to a new server dfs name does not need changing. If your running windows 2003 sp2 then dfs gets much better.

Edited by David Godfrey on Monday 30th July 18:30

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
At Ford we used to use standard offline folders, worked as advertised.

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,586 posts

241 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
My only concern is that AFAIK it won't touch PST files - and we have rather a lot of them dotted around.

As for DFS, it's something I want to look at, not specifically for this tbh, but as a means of organizing the myriad of shares we have spread over our servers.

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
My only concern is that AFAIK it won't touch PST files - and we have rather a lot of them dotted around.

As for DFS, it's something I want to look at, not specifically for this tbh, but as a means of organizing the myriad of shares we have spread over our servers.
erm it can do .pst though we banned pst at the org level, there a nightmare tbh. I will see if I can find the link, but I'd strongly suggest anyone using .pst in a company environment get there head checked.

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
it's up to you if you do this and I will guarentee it will cause you no end of issues.

link here: http://support.microsoft.com/kb/252509

RESOLUTION
Microsoft does not recommend modifying the list of excluded files. See the "More Information" section for more details.
Back to the top

STATUS
This behavior is by design.
Back to the top

MORE INFORMATION
Certain file types are excluded by default as a means to prevent file conflicts and data loss. The mechanism that the Offline Files feature uses is Client-Side Caching (CSC). CSC can recognize when synchronization issues exist (for example, if the copy of a file on the server has been modified since the last synchronization). In such a case, you can select which version to use, but you cannot merge the contents.

There may also be another synchronization mechanism that is typically used for the file type. One such file type is .pst files. This type is included in the list to prevent conflicts with the built-in offline and synchronization features in Microsoft Outlook. The Offline Files feature uses a replacement method of synchronization, so there is no way to merge the two copies.

You can modify the list of excluded extensions by editing the appropriate Group Policy object (local, domain, organizational unit, and so on). For example, to remove the .pst extension from the list of excluded files, enable the following sample policy in Policy Editor:
Computer Configuration\Administrative Templates\Network\Offline Files\Files not cached
Then, type the following string in the Extensions box:
  • .slm;*.mdb;*.ldb;*.mdw;*.mde;*.db?
Log off, and then log back on. This replaces the default list, preserving all but the *.pst extension. You can use the same method for any of the other extensions. If you want to exclude all extensions, leave the list empty.

To edit the local policy, click Start, click Run, type gpedit.msc, and then click OK. To edit the domain policy, use Active Directory Users and Computers snap-in.

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,586 posts

241 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
David Godfrey said:
erm it can do .pst though we banned pst at the org level, there a nightmare tbh. I will see if I can find the link, but I'd strongly suggest anyone using .pst in a company environment get there head checked.
Just to clarify, mail is Exchange Server, PSTs are solely for archived email.

I'm not a fan of them by any means, but we have a lot of hoarders who simply want to keep everything they've ever received but probably never look at it and we're not the sort of size or have the sort of budget to endlessly expand the Exchange server or go to a centralized archiving system.

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
David Godfrey said:
erm it can do .pst though we banned pst at the org level, there a nightmare tbh. I will see if I can find the link, but I'd strongly suggest anyone using .pst in a company environment get there head checked.
Just to clarify, mail is Exchange Server, PSTs are solely for archived email.

I'm not a fan of them by any means, but we have a lot of hoarders who simply want to keep everything they've ever received but probably never look at it and we're not the sort of size or have the sort of budget to endlessly expand the Exchange server or go to a centralized archiving system.
ok, then I'll let you off hehe I have a few people trip over .pst files, there are data size limits for both the csc and then the .pst files. add them together and :urgh: the exception is running vista and oulook 2007 which work far better. (altough .pst still sucks allong with brick level backups smile )

malman

2,258 posts

290 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
I use the built in stuff and have an exception for mdb files just so my test databases in my docs get synced. Never had an issue with it an have it set to sync on login/logout


2Gb limit on pst files will bite someone garanteed and it doesn't fail gracefully either it just corrupts and the recovery can take a while and be a pain.

outlook 2007 has swapped to unicode pst/ost so goes beyond the 2Gb limit (doesn't need vista)

Edited by malman on Monday 30th July 22:41

David Godfrey

3,857 posts

255 months

Monday 30th July 2007
quotequote all
malman said:
outlook 2007 has swapped to unicode pst/ost so goes beyond the 2Gb limit (doesn't need vista)
yes, but windows xp offline folders have limits on csc, that vista does not smile so far the only good reason for deploying that over XP, well and bitlocker for security of laptop hdd's smile

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
We had used to use a batch file to back up pst files to the user directories rather than offline files. This enables the user to sync as normal over dial up or bb and only back up pst's when in the office. We just had to make sure that they saved the pst in a certain dir on their c drive.

malman

2,258 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st July 2007
quotequote all
David Godfrey said:
malman said:
outlook 2007 has swapped to unicode pst/ost so goes beyond the 2Gb limit (doesn't need vista)
yes, but windows xp offline folders have limits on csc, that vista does not smile so far the only good reason for deploying that over XP, well and bitlocker for security of laptop hdd's smile
isn't the 2Gb limit just on temporary offline files not "make this available offline" type files?

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Novell iFolder. It was very good before, version 3 onwards is ace - allows shared iFolders too if you have mobile users who collaborate with others. It will sync from anywhere that you can get on the internet (unlike offline files & folders), so great for users at home or roaming about on various networks. Does delta syncs so it doesn't need to send the whole file when something changes.

Clients available for Windows, Mac OSX, and various flavours of linux.

It went open source with version 3, so you can just download and run the server FOC. Builds are available for various linux servers, and there's instructions on that site for getting it working on Windows, using IIS as the webserver. Or it's included in (and most easily installed/managed on) Novell's Open Enterprise Server if you want something official and supported.

Connects to any LDAP source (inc Active Directory) to get users and authenticate them so you can drop it straight into a pure MS environment and have it working nicely.