Exige S - company car???????
Discussion
Hi guy's.... my first foray on the Lotus side of things.
I'm changing company and having to give up my company provided 07 BMW Z4 2.0. My new company does not have any interesting cars on the scheme AT ALL!! however do provide me with a healthy allowance and 11ppm + AMAP rebate from the tax man of the balance according to AMAP rates. I expect to do about 15,000 miles per anum, down from my current 27K per anum.
I've checked insurance and for around £1000 I can get the insurance sorted.
I've previously test driven the S2 111R and the Exige (NOT THE S) and I've found the performance a little lack-lustre. Taken a look at the boot which is OK (which I need to be lockable and covered). I've also looked at the Service intervals, and I have access to a great garage.
I like the Z4.. it's been great.. as a company provided car including all costs.. but I would not necessarily get one myself. I've always liked the Exige - In Bright Orange :-) and now possibly have an opportunity to get one.
Also if the company is providing cash I'd prefer to retain as much value in a car as possible and the Exige S seems to be a good residual car. So later on I can get the money back out.
Now my questions are...?
1. Is the Exige S, going to be noticeably more punchy than the standard Exige?
2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
I'm changing company and having to give up my company provided 07 BMW Z4 2.0. My new company does not have any interesting cars on the scheme AT ALL!! however do provide me with a healthy allowance and 11ppm + AMAP rebate from the tax man of the balance according to AMAP rates. I expect to do about 15,000 miles per anum, down from my current 27K per anum.
I've checked insurance and for around £1000 I can get the insurance sorted.
I've previously test driven the S2 111R and the Exige (NOT THE S) and I've found the performance a little lack-lustre. Taken a look at the boot which is OK (which I need to be lockable and covered). I've also looked at the Service intervals, and I have access to a great garage.
I like the Z4.. it's been great.. as a company provided car including all costs.. but I would not necessarily get one myself. I've always liked the Exige - In Bright Orange :-) and now possibly have an opportunity to get one.
Also if the company is providing cash I'd prefer to retain as much value in a car as possible and the Exige S seems to be a good residual car. So later on I can get the money back out.
Now my questions are...?
1. Is the Exige S, going to be noticeably more punchy than the standard Exige?
2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
Now then... 

cerealsurfer said:
1. Is the Exige S, going to be noticeably more punchy than the standard Exige?
Yes, the SC gives you a lot more torque in low and mid-range, the NA is very top-endy (unless you get the motorsport ECU remap). Better proposition IMHO.cerealsurfer said:
2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
Yeah and no. It's not a German tank, so don't expect that kind of build quality, however the newer cars are much better screwed together than previous iterations. Not perfect, but no kit-car nonsense either.cerealsurfer said:
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
Nope, they're great. Sure the ride's somewhat stiff, but not unuseably so. New ProBax seats are very comfortable too. Try one, you'll like it.cerealsurfer said:
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Not sure on that - have you checked it out on the Lotus website? It lists all the gubbins for each one on there, or someone like Boggy (who knows the spec list off-by-heart) will be along to concur or correct shortly!cerealsurfer said:
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
Probably not - you'll love it. Driven one yet? If not I'd suggest getting a back-to-back test drive booked with an Elise 111R, an NA Exige and an Exige S. Good comparison to base your decision on.One thing worth considering is at 16,000 miles p.a., you'll be changing tyres a lot - 5-6,000 miles from the rears as they are pretty much cut slicks with about 5 mm of tread and a soft compound. You can put on road-spec tyres but the recommended ones cost £££ and the alternative are appalling on track so you'd be better off with two sets of wheels if you plan to go on track.
kevin ritson said:
One thing worth considering is at 16,000 miles p.a., you'll be changing tyres a lot - 5-6,000 miles from the rears as they are pretty much cut slicks with about 5 mm of tread and a soft compound. You can put on road-spec tyres but the recommended ones cost £££ and the alternative are appalling on track so you'd be better off with two sets of wheels if you plan to go on track.
It's unlikeley that the car will see "much" track activity and having done a bunch of searches on this forum it seems that a swap to Toyo T1R's would be possible. I've had these tyres on a TVR Cerbera 4.5 lw and they really seemed to measure up.However - Does anyone use them on a regular basis? Id be interested to hear from anyone who does.
Mileage achieved/Wear Rate.
cerealsurfer said:
..........I've previously test driven the S2 111R and the Exige (NOT THE S) and I've found the performance a little lack-lustre.
You do have to thack them but even on low cam should piss all over your bimmer ?!!?In short S has much more midrange and continues right to the rev limiter. Bearings in the supercharger fail but otherwise fairly reliable, but it is never BM standard.
Do it

If you're happy to lose lots of steering feel and the handling that you've paid a premium over an Elise for then T1-Rs are fine. Personally for a non-track car the Elise makes much more sense annoying as it is that the supercharger isn't available. Unless of course you're prepared to go non-standard.
cerealsurfer said:
1. Is the Exige S, going to be noticeably more punchy than the standard Exige?
2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
I've driven most variant's of the Exige and found the 240R or Cup to be the best value, the only problem is with that is that at the moment Lotus don't sell a 240+ Bhp car as standard, (Their should be an upgrade package shortly).2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
I brought the Exige S as I found it noticeably quicker than the standard Exige, your not always waiting for the power to come in and even with the Ecu flash your still waiting for around 5500 rpm for the power to come in where's with the SC model it's throughout the rev rang making the Exige a much better road car even in traffic. It sound's by what you've said that you'd need sport's pack & touring pack's, do not buy an Exige without A/c you'll never sell it and it's a great upgrade see link's for full details.
http://www.grouplotus.com/car/car_tech_specs.php?i...
Boggy
kevin ritson said:
If you're happy to lose lots of steering feel and the handling that you've paid a premium over an Elise for then T1-Rs are fine. Personally for a non-track car the Elise makes much more sense annoying as it is that the supercharger isn't available. Unless of course you're prepared to go non-standard.
The car must ideally be "off the peg" and also I'd like to get a coupe. I have a Morgan Aero 8 for the days when a real roof down Hoon is needed. I could always try to get a second set of wheels from the dealer at purchase time and use them to swap onto the car when I'm looking at doing track days/driving weekends.I have a decent sized double garage and can I've been keen on getting a small Hoffman sizor lift for a while.....
At the end of the day, I like the look of the Exige and whilst T1R's may not be 100% performance it's gonna be better than the BM.
The Elise is not really a car for me... I think i'd go back to the BM before jumping into an Elise.
Boggy said:
cerealsurfer said:
1. Is the Exige S, going to be noticeably more punchy than the standard Exige?
2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
I've driven most variant's of the Exige and found the 240R or Cup to be the best value, the only problem is with that is that at the moment Lotus don't sell a 240+ Bhp car as standard, (Their should be an upgrade package shortly).2. Is the Exige going to be a constant tweak fest of having to sort out bugs, squeaks, leaks and niggles?
3. Whilst I’m going to have access to another car I’m going to be using this most of the time, I had a great time in the Z4 and could put up with the “M” suspension and road noise etc… am I going to find the Exige “S” just TOO Wearing?
4. I take it, to get Traction Control & Airbags (after all I’m going to be driving this all year) I’m going to need to get the Sport and Super Touring option packs!! Am I ever likely to find this “new used”?
Am I expecting too much from the Exige S??
I brought the Exige S as I found it noticeably quicker than the standard Exige, your not always waiting for the power to come in and even with the Ecu flash your still waiting for around 5500 rpm for the power to come in where's with the SC model it's throughout the rev rang making the Exige a much better road car even in traffic. It sound's by what you've said that you'd need sport's pack & touring pack's, do not buy an Exige without A/c you'll never sell it and it's a great upgrade see link's for full details.
http://www.grouplotus.com/car/car_tech_specs.php?i...
Boggy
On the tyre issue I agree with Kevin entirely. I have an Exige S and currently run it on T1R's. To be fair, they have served me extremely well during the recent very wet months but on a dry or slightly damp day they have removed most of the 'Exigeness' that justified the premium over the Elise in the first place.
As others have said, the answer is to have 2 sets of wheels/tyres. Putting up with the Toyo's occassionally is only going to make the switch back to dry tyres even more enjoyable.
As others have said, the answer is to have 2 sets of wheels/tyres. Putting up with the Toyo's occassionally is only going to make the switch back to dry tyres even more enjoyable.
emenel said:
On the tyre issue I agree with Kevin entirely. I have an Exige S and currently run it on T1R's. To be fair, they have served me extremely well during the recent very wet months but on a dry or slightly damp day they have removed most of the 'Exigeness' that justified the premium over the Elise in the first place.
As others have said, the answer is to have 2 sets of wheels/tyres. Putting up with the Toyo's occassionally is only going to make the switch back to dry tyres even more enjoyable.
Sounds like an extra set of wheel's & tyres is a must have then.As others have said, the answer is to have 2 sets of wheels/tyres. Putting up with the Toyo's occassionally is only going to make the switch back to dry tyres even more enjoyable.
Edited by cerealsurfer on Wednesday 1st August 10:33
phoebusphoibos said:
Hi
I'm driving an Exige S as a daily car. It is my third Lotus company car. If you like it, you desire it ? Go for it! Look it is like that with all beautifull things, perfection is not from this world. But this car is truly a super road car, perfectly suited for daily use.
So it is genuinely possible... I'd be interested to hear you driving profile..I'm driving an Exige S as a daily car. It is my third Lotus company car. If you like it, you desire it ? Go for it! Look it is like that with all beautifull things, perfection is not from this world. But this car is truly a super road car, perfectly suited for daily use.
Miles/Motorway/Summer/Winter General experience... had many problems... annual spend?
Sounds to me like the Exige S may well be suitable.. my only concearn now is approximating annual runing costs. As previously said I'm going to be driving somewhere around 15k Per Anum...
Tyres - 1 Set Yoko's 1 Set of Toyo's - Per Anum
Servicing - £500 every 9 months
Other fixing issues - ??
Insurance - £1000
Tax - £200
MPG - 30ish
Big Grin - Priceless
cerealsurfer said:
BTW.. ever tried getting golf clubs in the passengers seat? lol
They fit in an S1 Elise so even with fire extinguisher fitted should not be a problem in an Exige.. although make sure the zips are done up. hearing golf balls roll around the footwell as you're driving is very distracting Grinnders said:
cerealsurfer said:
BTW.. ever tried getting golf clubs in the passengers seat? lol
They fit in an S1 Elise so even with fire extinguisher fitted should not be a problem in an Exige.. although make sure the zips are done up. hearing golf balls roll around the footwell as you're driving is very distracting kevin ritson said:
If you're happy to lose lots of steering feel and the handling that you've paid a premium over an Elise for then T1-Rs are fine.
I completely disagree - with all due respect to Kevin, he's never driven (to my knowledge) a car with them on, either in the wet or dry, on road or on track. I have. You will not lose lots of steering feel and the handling will not be so massively compromised that the car is robbed of it's inherent strengths and qualities.kevin ritson said:
Personally for a non-track car the Elise makes much more sense annoying as it is that the supercharger isn't available. Unless of course you're prepared to go non-standard.
That however is a good point, well made, see below for my conclusion...cerealsurfer said:
kevin ritson said:
One thing worth considering is at 16,000 miles p.a., you'll be changing tyres a lot - 5-6,000 miles from the rears as they are pretty much cut slicks with about 5 mm of tread and a soft compound. You can put on road-spec tyres but the recommended ones cost £££ and the alternative are appalling on track so you'd be better off with two sets of wheels if you plan to go on track.
It's unlikeley that the car will see "much" track activity and having done a bunch of searches on this forum it seems that a swap to Toyo T1R's would be possible. I've had these tyres on a TVR Cerbera 4.5 lw and they really seemed to measure up.However - Does anyone use them on a regular basis? Id be interested to hear from anyone who does.
Mileage achieved/Wear Rate.
emenel said:
On the tyre issue I agree with Kevin entirely. I have an Exige S and currently run it on T1R's. To be fair, they have served me extremely well during the recent very wet months but on a dry or slightly damp day they have removed most of the 'Exigeness' that justified the premium over the Elise in the first place.
As others have said, the answer is to have 2 sets of wheels/tyres. Putting up with the Toyo's occassionally is only going to make the switch back to dry tyres even more enjoyable.
Right, an alternative viewpoint.As others have said, the answer is to have 2 sets of wheels/tyres. Putting up with the Toyo's occassionally is only going to make the switch back to dry tyres even more enjoyable.
I have a Honda'd S2 Elise which is used regularly on road and track. I've run it on R888's and T1R's over the past year, with some 12k miles, 4 airfield days and some 10+ trackdays (have lost count).
The 888's are a good tyre and can be used year round. At 16k road miles pa you'll probably do 2 sets a year which will set you back just over a grand. Do track days and that will diminish greatly. On wet roads they offer pretty astonishing grip for what they are, but take the piss and they'll spit you into a spin - the envelope of correction is much smaller. In standing water at speed they can be scary.
T1R's are a good tyre, just not suited to track work as they have somewhat softer sidewalls. On road they work well once worn in and when set to a pressure which offers a good compromise. They grip well in the dry, and work well in the wet. They are half the cost of the best alternative, Yoko AO39's (£750 a set). Steering feel at dead centre is a little heavier but you get used to it and it does not make the car undriveable. On track they heat up quickly and grip goes off the menu, it does make for a fun experience if you like sliding the car around though. I've learned a considerable amount about how the car handles on and around the limit of grip with these tyres and I count that as a very good thing (despite one somewhat expensive lesson learned due to my over-confidence). On the road you'd expect 10k miles per set easily. From the AO39's I suspect you'd manage 7.5-8k miles a set if you're not pushing too hard. Someone like Bogie or SimonK would be a better commentator on that as they use them regularly.
I've ended up with 2 sets of wheels and tyres and am currently undecided as to my next step. Ideally I'd like one set, with rubber that can compromise more thoroughly - unfortunately with the front wheel width that I have (and you will on an Exige), there are limits to choice which preclude that without greater expense (AO39's).
My choices? Get a set of 888's for the remainder of summer, keep my T1R fronts which are half worn, and get another set of rears come Autumn. Get a set of AO39's stomach the cost and be done with it (I'm only planning on a couple of trackdays for the remainder of the year), sell one of the sets of wheels maybe... the list goes on. Either way, it ain't cheap.
So, in a nutshell I return to Kevin's suggestion because frankly, for your intended use, you're better off with a nicely spec'd 111R with a hardtop and be able to run regular Elise wheels with the recommended Yoko Advan tyres.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff







