Battery conditioner needed - Halfords vs CTEK ?
Battery conditioner needed - Halfords vs CTEK ?
Author
Discussion

Jon_Bentley

Original Poster:

202 posts

235 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Im going to have to leave my car in the garage again for a while, and possibly more often than id like to. dont want the hassle of comming back to every time and not being able to open it / start it / alarm going off etc.

need some form of safe battery charger / conditioner (it will be in the garage so the solar one i nearly bought it out!)

looked in halfords and they do a semi hard wired conditioner that plugs into the wall for about £23

looking at some of the other threads that recommend the CTECK conditioners which seem to be about £50

can anyone tell me the difference / advantages between them and if it has to be the CTEK one, where i can get one cheap?

thanks
Jon

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I've always used Optimate chargers/conditioners. Never had a problem and have 2 of them now, one for car and one for bike. About £35 each.

jb12

138 posts

241 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I have been using a Halfords one and have had no problems with it. It charges the battery, then switches to maintenance mode. Comes with a connection lead, which you wire to the + terminal on the battery and earth. This allows you to easly connect and disconnect from the charger.




cardigankid

8,880 posts

243 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I see that you have got a nice 996.

Porsche do their own battery conditioner, which isn't expensive, and which plugs into the cigarette lighter. Why not use that?

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

lanesra10

314 posts

262 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Seemingly Lidl are doing these at the moment for under a £5

Time to hit Lidl guys, they're selling a rebadged CTEK charger for £2.99.
They've messed up, the 4.99 quoted for last year was a different charger, a
little one like a mobile phone charger that gave 2/6/12v options. Last year
this one was £9.99

I bought one, works perfectly, no gassing of battery when charged, spot on
voltage. So good I went back and bought another.

http://www.ctek.com/EN/MXS3600/white_background_rg...

Lidl: http://tinyurl.com/328afw

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
ctek is better than optimate I'm told. Uses a more advanced type of transformer or something like that - it is remarkably light for a transformer.

I've got one and no complaints so far...

dealmaker

2,215 posts

285 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I've tried them ALL and Optimate are the best by a LONG way.

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
My local Lidl aren't selling them weeping

Can you get them online anywhere?

cardigankid

8,880 posts

243 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
You're going to buy something at LIDL for £2.99 and plug it into your lovely 996? Are you insured for fire?

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
S'alright.... I want to plug one in my TVR wink

Jon_Bentley

Original Poster:

202 posts

235 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
but what about the halfords one?

the lidl one, if it is a rebadged CTEK charger might be an option, but like said, i cant see them for sale either?

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
Jon_Bentley said:
but what about the halfords one?
I've had a Halfords one for a few years and it does what it says on the tin.



jb12

138 posts

241 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
[quote=cardigankid]I see that you have got a nice 996.

Porsche do their own battery conditioner, which isn't expensive, and which plugs into the cigarette lighter. Why not use that?[/quote

It was handy at time, so I just went for it. It does the job why pay more for some thing that does the same job anyway.


Roop

6,018 posts

315 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
We did a lot of testing of various battery chargers for a project at work and the CTEK kicked the rest into touch. Yes, they are the most expensive, but they also have by far the lowest ripple in the output current. This might not mean much, but leave the others connected and the battery will dry out over time. The CTEK can be left on for years and years without issue.

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
Roop said:
We did a lot of testing of various battery chargers for a project at work and the CTEK kicked the rest into touch. Yes, they are the most expensive, but they also have by far the lowest ripple in the output current. This might not mean much, but leave the others connected and the battery will dry out over time. The CTEK can be left on for years and years without issue.
I've been using Optimate chargers/conditioners on my bikes/cars for the last 10 years. The bike is left for 6 months during the winter continuously connected. The battery never 'dried' out even over a period of more than 7 years. The bike had the original battery for the duration of these 7 years. During the summer, the bike was occassionally left for up to 6 weeks without use and not connected to a charger. The battery performed as new and started easily first time. The same with the car, the battery is now 3.5 years old and during the winter, it's left connected to the Optimate for up to 2 months at a time. Battery is still perfect.

I can't see how this experience can be 'kicked into touch'. If there are any other features then they are redundant since the whole point of the charger was to maintain a battery in peak condition over the period of several years, which the Optimate does. I'm sure there are other products that do the same but can't see the requirement for anything else.

Edited by Silver993tt on Thursday 2nd August 09:27

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
Optimate/Accumate - another thumbup

Roop

6,018 posts

315 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
I'm not knocking the Optimates, they are good units for sure. We tested many chargers across many different batteries and battery types under many conditions. We wanted the very best chargers we would get and the tests showed the CTEKs were better. Simple as. This doesn't make the Optimates bad though, just not as good.

It's worth noting some batteries, especially older ones and the unsealed / non-maintenance free ones are prone to drying out more than modern batteries. The CTEKs are smaller, lighter and more configurable too. I have a Multi XS 3600 and a Multi XS 25000. Both are excellent units. If you are just charging cars and bikes, the 3600 is more than adequate and a cracking little charger.

I have the need to charge gel and absorbent glass mat as well as sealed lead acid and maintenance free cells so the higher spec charger works well for me (The 3600 does all this). For example, if you have a golf cart, use the CTEK Multi XS 3600 to charge the battery and it'll more than likely getter better runtime and life from the battery than the supplied 'dumb' charger.

I do have an Optimate that I use occasionally, but to all intents and purposes it's a backup - nothing wrong with it though - a nice charger.

Silver993tt said:
Roop said:
We did a lot of testing of various battery chargers for a project at work and the CTEK kicked the rest into touch. Yes, they are the most expensive, but they also have by far the lowest ripple in the output current. This might not mean much, but leave the others connected and the battery will dry out over time. The CTEK can be left on for years and years without issue.
I've been using Optimate chargers/conditioners on my bikes/cars for the last 10 years. The bike is left for 6 months during the winter continuously connected. The battery never 'dried' out even over a period of more than 7 years. The bike had the original battery for the duration of these 7 years. During the summer, the bike was occassionally left for up to 6 weeks without use and not connected to a charger. The battery performed as new and started easily first time. The same with the car, the battery is now 3.5 years old and during the winter, it's left connected to the Optimate for up to 2 months at a time. Battery is still perfect.

I can't see how this experience can be 'kicked into touch'. If there are any other features then they are redundant since the whole point of the charger was to maintain a battery in peak condition over the period of several years, which the Optimate does. I'm sure there are other products that do the same but can't see the requirement for anything else.

Edited by Silver993tt on Thursday 2nd August 09:27

phelix

4,684 posts

280 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
What's a ripple current and how/why is that bad?

Only ripple I know is a bad/cheap wine.

Lighty

370 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
I have noticed that Euro car parts have Ctek chargers for sale.