Canadian Palm Treo
Author
Discussion

W111AAM

Original Poster:

670 posts

263 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Currently use a Palm Treo 650 and very much like it. I've had it for 2 years nearly and its looking a bit tired.

Off to Canada next week and thought about buying one a Treo 680, or 700p there. With the exchange rate been so good, they work out a lot chepaer than over here!

However, in buying one over there, is the phone going to work back here. I'm currently with Orange.

Cheers.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
I'm currently running a Treo 680 as my business phone. Before that, had two 650s, and before that pretty much the first 600 in the UK. Imported the 650 6 months before UK availability.

So you could say I'm keen on the Treo (but this iPhone on my desk is eagerly waiting for a SIM unlock...) wink

The Treo was always available in GSM and CDMA flavours. Obviously only the GSM version will work in Europe. It's only got GPRS data speed, as you know from the 650. Now they've switched the product numbers - the 680 is GSM, the 700p is CDMA (and useless in Europe).

In terms of the benefits of the 680 over the 650, the phone GUI is nicer and faster to use. There is no aerial to stick in your pocket, and the phone is slimmer.

However there is a BIG BIG BIG disadvantage with the 680. The battery life sucks. If you use *any* data-related application (I use Chattermail to get IMAP push mail from my servers) then forget it. I get a grand 5-6 hour battery life with the standard (tiny) battery on my 680, which makes it unusable as a business phone - it dies half way through the business day.

I've bought two extended batteries (2400 mAh, with a fat battery cover so the phone looks like shit), neither work properly. The Palm OS on the 680 has a problem with these big capacity batteries.

The only thing I've managed to get working is to use the original battery out of the 650 with the extended battery cover from the 680 extended batteries. This works, most of the time.

The 680 is fine if you're happy with shorter battery life and don't use the data connection 24/7 like I do, but be very aware of the battery limitations before buying.

W111AAM

Original Poster:

670 posts

263 months

Monday 6th August 2007
quotequote all
Thank you for that.

I don't use the phone as you appear to. I've always had a palm of some description and really only use the diary and address book features. Having it double as a phone is a bonus.

So, when going to Canada the 680 is the one to go for, and I can simply plug my Orange Sim card straight into it?

Cheers.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Monday 6th August 2007
quotequote all
W111AAM said:
Thank you for that.

I don't use the phone as you appear to. I've always had a palm of some description and really only use the diary and address book features. Having it double as a phone is a bonus.

So, when going to Canada the 680 is the one to go for, and I can simply plug my Orange Sim card straight into it?

Cheers.
An unlocked Palm-branded one - yes, plug in the SIM and go. No problems whatsoever.

But you *will* find the battery life lower on the 680 than the 650, for the simple fact that the 650 has 50% more battery capacity. Also there is a bug in the firmware on the 680 that keeps the camera activated after you take a single picture (that drains the battery faster)... there's a patch and new firmware available on Palm's website, though newly bought phones may be up-to-date.

I do think they made good progress with the phone UI on the 680 though, it's a lot faster to use as a phone (call history / contacts / favourites / etc. are much more usable).

Haven't come across many Palm app incompatibilities either - if anything, apps that were flaky on the old 650 are more reliable on the 680.