New Desktop - dual monitors - suggestions
Discussion
Reading the development thread I realised that my PC at home is now hopelessly out of date.
Still running an early version of Advanced Server only recently upgraded to SPII it's rather an antiquity, and is showing it's age.
Also, for 3 years I've had two nice big lcd 19" monitors, but they ahve been both running on crappy machines with a combine graphics capability of 8Mb. All in all a poor show.
So, want to use the monitors on a new system - so will need to graphics cards.
I will do some gaming (bit of half life etc - not online just single player at home) - butmain usage will be photoshop, web surfing bit of development etc.
So, is it worth spending out 1500 quid on a decent alienware system with 2Ge8600 cards on board?
Or shoudl I just continue with my usual tack of buying some ex business 3 year old machines for <50 quid, and try and stick another graphics card in it?
I guess what I'm saying is - what is the real world performance improvement available from the latest dual core chipsets?
Still running an early version of Advanced Server only recently upgraded to SPII it's rather an antiquity, and is showing it's age.
Also, for 3 years I've had two nice big lcd 19" monitors, but they ahve been both running on crappy machines with a combine graphics capability of 8Mb. All in all a poor show.
So, want to use the monitors on a new system - so will need to graphics cards.
I will do some gaming (bit of half life etc - not online just single player at home) - butmain usage will be photoshop, web surfing bit of development etc.
So, is it worth spending out 1500 quid on a decent alienware system with 2Ge8600 cards on board?
Or shoudl I just continue with my usual tack of buying some ex business 3 year old machines for <50 quid, and try and stick another graphics card in it?
I guess what I'm saying is - what is the real world performance improvement available from the latest dual core chipsets?
Edited by mr_tony on Thursday 9th August 17:42
Any half-decent graphics card today has two output ports (and can output independently to both), so you don't need a machine with two cards.
In fact, in the case of the Alienware system you mention with two 8600s, in order to realise the main benefit of having two cards (increased graphics processing performance for gaming), you have to enable a setting which only allows for one screen to be used at a time!
And you don't need to spend anywhere near 1500 quid for a decent machine! I'm sure others will be along to advise you of much cheaper alternatives.
In fact, in the case of the Alienware system you mention with two 8600s, in order to realise the main benefit of having two cards (increased graphics processing performance for gaming), you have to enable a setting which only allows for one screen to be used at a time!
And you don't need to spend anywhere near 1500 quid for a decent machine! I'm sure others will be along to advise you of much cheaper alternatives.
you can get a lot for you money these days. I recently bought these part for a great pc. And all for £600.
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?M...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?S... two of and then setup for raid
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?J...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?H...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?S... you may change to a better graphics card for gaming
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?P...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?N...
Looks the business and is a super quick machine, to be honest you could do it cheaper if you needed to.
Hope it gives you a start point.
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?M...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?S... two of and then setup for raid
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?J...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?H...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?S... you may change to a better graphics card for gaming
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?P...
http://www.novatech.co.uk/novatech/specpage.html?N...
Looks the business and is a super quick machine, to be honest you could do it cheaper if you needed to.
Hope it gives you a start point.
First of all, forget Alienware. They were brought out be Dell a few years back and the reviews of their machines I've seen since don't inspire me to fork over that quantity of cash; it looks 'neat' but inside are some very generic (very good but generic) components. Dell's XPS's will have pretty much the same basic components and build quality... potentially cheaper if you poke around their factory outlet.
But, AW and XPS are more gaming machines. If gaming isn't your main drive then ignore them the same way you would blue downlighters for your car (thus say's she with an XPS laptop... and blue bling)
Virtually any Core 2 Duo or AMD X2 based machine will be light years ahead of the machine you're using, C2D is very impressive and my system feels exceptionally snappy and quick to respond, even when alt-tabing from an intensive game. I'm given to understand the X2's are almost as good, but I've only had a quick play with one so can't give an indepth comparison I'm afraid.
Virtually all graphics cards these days come with dual (or triple in the case of either S-video or HDMI TVOut) outputs, often it's either 2xVGA (15pin D-sub connectors), 2xDVI or a mixture of the two. You might need to check compatibility with your older 19" monitors and will most likely need at least one D-sub <-> DVI convector, but those are pretty cheap and you can get one from Maplins amongst other places. The only time you might find a single VGA output is either on an extreme budget card or a computer using an integrated chipset (the VGA port will be up amongst the PS/2 and USB connectors and is quite common in cheapy business machines).
As to running twin monitors, any version of Windows from 98 Second Edition (First could, but it kept falling over on me) to Vista can do either 'clone' which repeats the primary display on the secondary or 'big screen' which bolts the two displays together. Interestingly I've discovered that DirectShow is dual screen aware, if you maximse a video playing in WMP (or VLC) it will take control of the secondary display, quite handy for video presentations on a projector whilst I'm faffing on the primary
As to the budget for this hyper mega beast of a machine? Meh... Call if £500. Ok, ok, £600 tops for one with a very nice GFx card and lots of RAM in it, possibly even less than £500 if you spot a good un' on Dell's factory outlet thingie.
But, AW and XPS are more gaming machines. If gaming isn't your main drive then ignore them the same way you would blue downlighters for your car (thus say's she with an XPS laptop... and blue bling)

Virtually any Core 2 Duo or AMD X2 based machine will be light years ahead of the machine you're using, C2D is very impressive and my system feels exceptionally snappy and quick to respond, even when alt-tabing from an intensive game. I'm given to understand the X2's are almost as good, but I've only had a quick play with one so can't give an indepth comparison I'm afraid.
Virtually all graphics cards these days come with dual (or triple in the case of either S-video or HDMI TVOut) outputs, often it's either 2xVGA (15pin D-sub connectors), 2xDVI or a mixture of the two. You might need to check compatibility with your older 19" monitors and will most likely need at least one D-sub <-> DVI convector, but those are pretty cheap and you can get one from Maplins amongst other places. The only time you might find a single VGA output is either on an extreme budget card or a computer using an integrated chipset (the VGA port will be up amongst the PS/2 and USB connectors and is quite common in cheapy business machines).
As to running twin monitors, any version of Windows from 98 Second Edition (First could, but it kept falling over on me) to Vista can do either 'clone' which repeats the primary display on the secondary or 'big screen' which bolts the two displays together. Interestingly I've discovered that DirectShow is dual screen aware, if you maximse a video playing in WMP (or VLC) it will take control of the secondary display, quite handy for video presentations on a projector whilst I'm faffing on the primary

As to the budget for this hyper mega beast of a machine? Meh... Call if £500. Ok, ok, £600 tops for one with a very nice GFx card and lots of RAM in it, possibly even less than £500 if you spot a good un' on Dell's factory outlet thingie.
Others have suggested the fact that you can get damn cheap PC hardware these days and you don't need multiple graphics cards for two monitors.
However - from an ergonomic point of view, you're going to be looking at these screens, not at some blinged up fancy case, so my main concern would be whether the outputs are digital and whether the card has enough video memory to run both screens comfortably, and my perennial bugbear - noise.
If your existing LCDs have DVI inputs, then I wouldn't even consider getting a graphics card with VGA analogue outs - just get one with TWO DVI outputs and both pictures will be jitter-free and perfectly clear. Good LCDs do a good job of matching clock and sync with analogue VGA, but what's the point when loads of cards have dual digital outputs these days?
Secondly, it doesn't sound like you need the latest most expensive gamer's card, but make sure it's got loads of onboard RAM if you're driving two screens - the memory will be split in half for each screen.
Thirdly, and this may not bother you like it does me - cheap or high-performance graphics cards often have tiny fans running at very high speed mounted on the GPU and/or memory - there is a wide variation in the noise they make. If you like comfortably quiet computing then get opinions from owners (or just check out the fan config, it's usually pretty obvious which ones are going to be noisy, and you can always modify the cooling afterwards). A screaming fan on a graphics card can be the loudest, most irritating component in the whole system. If you are into modifying your machine there are always options to replace standard coolers with 'quiet' or even silent passive coolers, of course.
However - from an ergonomic point of view, you're going to be looking at these screens, not at some blinged up fancy case, so my main concern would be whether the outputs are digital and whether the card has enough video memory to run both screens comfortably, and my perennial bugbear - noise.
If your existing LCDs have DVI inputs, then I wouldn't even consider getting a graphics card with VGA analogue outs - just get one with TWO DVI outputs and both pictures will be jitter-free and perfectly clear. Good LCDs do a good job of matching clock and sync with analogue VGA, but what's the point when loads of cards have dual digital outputs these days?
Secondly, it doesn't sound like you need the latest most expensive gamer's card, but make sure it's got loads of onboard RAM if you're driving two screens - the memory will be split in half for each screen.
Thirdly, and this may not bother you like it does me - cheap or high-performance graphics cards often have tiny fans running at very high speed mounted on the GPU and/or memory - there is a wide variation in the noise they make. If you like comfortably quiet computing then get opinions from owners (or just check out the fan config, it's usually pretty obvious which ones are going to be noisy, and you can always modify the cooling afterwards). A screaming fan on a graphics card can be the loudest, most irritating component in the whole system. If you are into modifying your machine there are always options to replace standard coolers with 'quiet' or even silent passive coolers, of course.
Thanks for the advice guys. Went back to my old employers and bought a dell xps 210 of the outlet - saved around 250 quid over a new machine so total cost 600 including vat and delivery.
Dual 2.66Mhz core, 256Mb Radeon card. 300Gb HDD, 8x DVDRW, Network card keyboard mouse etc etc comes with Vista (so far so good for most of the machines I've used it on).
Dual 2.66Mhz core, 256Mb Radeon card. 300Gb HDD, 8x DVDRW, Network card keyboard mouse etc etc comes with Vista (so far so good for most of the machines I've used it on).
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



