Vista x64 - Go or no go?
Author
Discussion

-DeaDLocK-

Original Poster:

3,368 posts

282 months

Thursday 9th August 2007
quotequote all
Have landed a copy of Vista Ultimate. As long as I can get WHQL device drivers for my bits and as long as I am willing to forgo 16-bit legacy support, is there any real reason NOT to go with x64?

Also, will an upgrade from 2GB to 4GB make an appreciable difference in the performance of Vista?

Thanks.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 9th August 2007
quotequote all
If all of your applications will run in either 64bit native OR are known to be good in WOW32 emulation (Windows On Windows for those wondering) and all you're drivers are good to go. Nowt stopping you and it shouldn't misbehave any more than a Windows install can do.

I honestly don't think 4GB will offer you anything new unless you're running lots of memory intensive applications. But it'll give you bragging rights so why the hell not? smile Now I'm not sure if Vista can do this, but if you can designate a whole partition to be nothing more than swap space... that will speed you up noticeable especially if you have a old drive you can dedicate to the task (swap files tend to be slower than swap drives/partitions).

roadsweeper

3,790 posts

305 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
IIRC can't Vista use flash memory as RAM?

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
roadsweeper said:
IIRC can't Vista use flash memory as RAM?
I think it's called ReadyBoost? By the sound of it it's some sort of hybrid between RAM & swap partitions.

To the OP, have thought about it, I wouldn't expect to see a dramatic performance difference between 32bit and 64bit incarnations, a 32bit app might well be a little slower due to the emulation. Not appreciably slower but just a tiny bit.

Edited by ThePassenger on Friday 10th August 01:14

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
roadsweeper said:
IIRC can't Vista use flash memory as RAM?
I think it's called ReadyBoost? By the sound of it it's some sort of hybrid between RAM & swap partitions.

To the OP, have thought about it, I wouldn't expect to see a dramatic performance difference between 32bit and 64bit incarnations, a 32bit app might well be a little slower due to the emulation. Not appreciably slower but just a tiny bit.

Edited by ThePassenger on Friday 10th August 01:14
Yep, it is called readyboost. IIRC it recommends 2* the amount of RAM for the flash memory but I use 1Gb RAM and a 1Gb USB stick. I think it gives about 10% performance increase but I haven't tested it. Personally I would get as much proper RAM as possible as it it cheap these days. ( I remember buying 4MbRAM for £150 eek)


Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 10th August 2007
quotequote all
Readyboost does very little above 2Gb RAM.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 12th August 2007
quotequote all
Tycho said:
I remember buying 4MbRAM for £150 eek
I paid about the same for 2x1mb SIMMs. Horribly ripped off I was, but I could play Syndicate! Woot! (4x1MB).

God I feel old now, :sits on park bench waving walking stick at people whilst muttering: hehe

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Sunday 12th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Tycho said:
I remember buying 4MbRAM for £150 eek
I paid about the same for 2x1mb SIMMs. Horribly ripped off I was, but I could play Syndicate! Woot! (4x1MB).

God I feel old now, :sits on park bench waving walking stick at people whilst muttering: hehe
Words to strike fear:

"The Atlantic Accelerator".

Jesus, that level was hard.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Sunday 12th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Tycho said:
I remember buying 4MbRAM for £150 eek
I paid about the same for 2x1mb SIMMs. Horribly ripped off I was, but I could play Syndicate! Woot! (4x1MB).

God I feel old now, :sits on park bench waving walking stick at people whilst muttering: hehe
I still remember the fun you used to have with multiple config.sys and autoexec.bat files for different games trying to load everything in himem.... biggrin

I was so chuffed when I could get X-Wing to run!!!!

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 12th August 2007
quotequote all
Tycho said:
ThePassenger said:
Tycho said:
I remember buying 4MbRAM for £150 eek
I paid about the same for 2x1mb SIMMs. Horribly ripped off I was, but I could play Syndicate! Woot! (4x1MB).

God I feel old now, :sits on park bench waving walking stick at people whilst muttering: hehe
I still remember the fun you used to have with multiple config.sys and autoexec.bat files for different games trying to load everything in himem.... biggrin

I was so chuffed when I could get X-Wing to run!!!!
DEVICE=
The mysteries of Smartdrv.exe and EMM386.EXE RAM ....

That fcensoredk we don't have that any more eh? hehe

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Sunday 12th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Tycho said:
ThePassenger said:
Tycho said:
I remember buying 4MbRAM for £150 eek
I paid about the same for 2x1mb SIMMs. Horribly ripped off I was, but I could play Syndicate! Woot! (4x1MB).

God I feel old now, :sits on park bench waving walking stick at people whilst muttering: hehe
I still remember the fun you used to have with multiple config.sys and autoexec.bat files for different games trying to load everything in himem.... biggrin

I was so chuffed when I could get X-Wing to run!!!!
DEVICE=
The mysteries of Smartdrv.exe and EMM386.EXE RAM ....

That fcensoredk we don't have that any more eh? hehe
Heh - I remember the look on my college mates' faces when I showed them Doom running *within a window* whilst other apps were open.... no 16 bit hackery required... and I had a cheap, nasty no-name PC with 4 megs RAM IIRC, this particular tech demo swapped like buggery.

What was I running? OS/2 Warp hehe My engineer mate had just 'found' Linux (very early days, he couldn't get a stable system compiled until well into his 3rd year, and that was still very dodgy (1996, so probably the very first 2.0 kernels) biggrin

Back on topic - lots of RAM is very useful on a workstation even if your apps can't directly map more than 2 GB in their own process - you can just run more apps and avoid swappery.

I've been running a 64 bit OS with 4.5 GB RAM since 2005. Not until later this year will all the apps and frameworks be fully 64-bit clean, but for the time being it works just brilliantly.

Apart from particular scientific and media apps, large memory space support isn't the real issue, it's simply total RAM capacity of the machine. My main box can take shed loads so I'm not worried here - however Intel's ubiquitous laptop northbridge can only deal with two 2 GB so-dimms, meaning a max of 4 GB RAM in any Intel-based laptop. This is going to be (and already is) a limitation well before Vista or other 64 bit OS support - enough people are using virtualisation in their primary OS that sheer memory capacity is a problem. I have 4 GB RAM in my laptop, though due to the older Intel chipset only 3 GB is usable by the OS... this is barely enough if I'm running loads of apps and multiple virtualised systems.

As more and more people use laptops as main work machines, that 4 GB limitation (due to hardware i.e. only 2 so-dimm slots, and only 2 channels on the northbridge IIRC) is going to be a much bigger issue than whether you can get 8 GB RAM in an über-PC running Vista x64...

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
As more and more people use laptops as main work machines, that 4 GB limitation (due to hardware i.e. only 2 so-dimm slots, and only 2 channels on the northbridge IIRC) is going to be a much bigger issue than whether you can get 8 GB RAM in an über-PC running Vista x64...
Quite agree. Mine's limited to 2GB RAM, I'd wager the latest BIOS would bring support for 2GB SO-DIMMS but sod it. And yeah a few virtual machines going and swap city, even with Linux's psychopathic memory manager frown

jimmyjimjim

8,351 posts

269 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
DEVICE=
The mysteries of Smartdrv.exe and EMM386.EXE RAM ....

That fcensoredk we don't have that any more eh? hehe
And the great delight of finding QEMM386, and not having to do much, except for the occasional game which realllllllly pushed the limits!

A year after I finished Uni I went to work for a company that made a DOS based voicemail application.
It was then I really found out how to work config.sys - the main executable was 695Kb...then you had a 30Kb+ driver for the voice cards, and another 17Kb+ for the bespoke remote access system...that was an ordeal getting that thing to work on some pcs; the BIOS became a deciding factor as some wouldn't let you steal the video memory.
It used 4 serial ports as well. F*cking thing. Never made it easy for you.

Windows, derided as it may be on occasion really does have a lot of plus points.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
jimmyjimjim said:
ThePassenger said:
DEVICE=
The mysteries of Smartdrv.exe and EMM386.EXE RAM ....

That fcensoredk we don't have that any more eh? hehe
And the great delight of finding QEMM386, and not having to do much, except for the occasional game which realllllllly pushed the limits!
Ultima 7 and all the other games that wouldn't let you use EMM386 and QEMM386. GAH! GAH! I say.

Windows is good for somethings, but it still after all these years has a habit of falling over and you're left going "Eh?" and modern versions of Windows? Pah! You call THAT a crash? DOS'd lock the whole sodding thing up yes Proper job yesyes