Ipod help
Author
Discussion

warren182

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

241 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
Ipod has gone up the spout, the motherboard has developed a fault. If I connect my hard drive to another Ipod, will I be able to access my music that way? No music is saved on my PC, it's all in the Ipod.

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
If you have no music on the PC, and plug a fresh iPod in - then you will still have no music.

warren182

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

241 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
Sorry, wasn't very clear. If I remove the ipod hard drive, and connect it to another ipod, will the music be accesible?

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
Possibly, although I wouldn't like to rip open a new iPod. Are you sure it is dead, and not just the screen/battery?

warren182

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

241 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
Yeah, hard drive is clicking. Already taken it apart, the menu system doesn't work with the drive removed, so deffo needs to be scrapped.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Monday 13th August 2007
quotequote all
How do you know the problem is with the motherboard?

Have you run the iPod test suite (can't remember the key combo from the top of my head but it's on the Apple support page).

Basically there are two issues. Either it's a Mac-formatted iPod (in which case the hard drive will be formatted using HFS+) or it'll be a Windows-formatted iPod (in which case it'll be FAT32, I believe, though don't quote me on this).

My 1st gen iPod started to fail, typical hard drive age failure, I pulled it apart and extracted the hard disk, which was a commodity item. However since the failure was with the hard drive, extracting data would be tricky at best (i.e. platter removal, expensive job).

Assuming your 'clicking hard drive' doesn't mean the hard drive is knackered (which is the more likely fault), yes you can remove the hard disk, acquire an appropriate connector and connect it to either a USB bridge or directly to your PC (assuming IDE, there are multiple different options here, I don't know which revisions of iPod use PATA, SATA, and whether size-change connectors are available for the small HDs that iPods use).

The iPod stores the tunes in a directory structure that is obfuscated to make it more difficult for people to copy music from one iPod (mounted as a disk) onto another's computer. However there are loads of tools out there that can do this. Even a simple search and import into iTunes will do it if you've taken the entire directory tree off the iPod disk.

What you *will* lose is the iTunes Music Library file unless you can transfer that across without the new computer's iTunes rejecting it - i.e. you'll lose your ratings etc.

Also there may be an issue with protected AAC files i.e. Music Store DRM'd music. I don't use it and only have unprotected ripped music on my iPod, but again I back all my data up.

warren182

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

241 months

Tuesday 14th August 2007
quotequote all
If you remove the hard drive from the ipod, the menu system should still work if the motherboard is functioning. Removing the hard drive leaves the unhappy ipod logo still displayed, so the hard drive should be ok. Cheers for the advice, I'll give it a whirl.