Corporate Anti-Spam Product
Discussion
Hi everyone
First post in this forum...
Have any of you guys got any recommendations for a corporate anti spam solution? We're only a small company (10 mailboxes) but do get a lot of email. We run Exchange Server 2003 and have been using Symantec Corporate Edition to do anti virus and anti spam. It's now up for renewal and seeing as it does a poor job of blocking the e-card and pdf spam we've been using I thought I'd try another product.
I've downloaded the trial of Sophos PureMessage but that's pretty awful. It's letting a lot of the stuff that Symantec used to block through. I've heard good things about Symantec Brightmail but I can't find any prices online for that so that worries me a bit and I'm not ready to start talking to vendors yet.
I'm not massively keen on greylisting or tarpitting and the connection filtering lists I've used have not been great.
And finally, I'm really looking for a software solution rather than a hardware one.
So, any suggestions? Thanks in advance.
First post in this forum...
Have any of you guys got any recommendations for a corporate anti spam solution? We're only a small company (10 mailboxes) but do get a lot of email. We run Exchange Server 2003 and have been using Symantec Corporate Edition to do anti virus and anti spam. It's now up for renewal and seeing as it does a poor job of blocking the e-card and pdf spam we've been using I thought I'd try another product.
I've downloaded the trial of Sophos PureMessage but that's pretty awful. It's letting a lot of the stuff that Symantec used to block through. I've heard good things about Symantec Brightmail but I can't find any prices online for that so that worries me a bit and I'm not ready to start talking to vendors yet.
I'm not massively keen on greylisting or tarpitting and the connection filtering lists I've used have not been great.
And finally, I'm really looking for a software solution rather than a hardware one.
So, any suggestions? Thanks in advance.
There is Spamcop, which I haven't used.. and GFI MailEssentials, which I have used.. GFI is quite good, but does involve a learning process and there are a large number of features and processes to be defined. Initially with the PDF SPAM it didn't filter it, but over time it did.. It uses something termed "Bayesian Analysis" to learn what you consider SPAM and what is not. I would suggest looking at their forums, they're quite active.
Mostly it comes down to cost...
hth
Mostly it comes down to cost...
hth
One free option which would certainly be worthwhile investigating is the Intelligent Mail Filter which works along with Exchange 2003.
http://www.microsoft.com/technet/prodtechnol/excha...
Works reasonably well.
http://www.microsoft.com/technet/prodtechnol/excha...
Works reasonably well.
GFI isn't foolproof, but it does learn what SPAM is, over a period of time, depending on mail volume. The company where I saw it in operation had about 9k mails a day. It does need to be set up properly, and effectively tuned/learn what the company considers SPAM and isn't... It has some good reports - showing the percentages of SPAM and classification of SPAM. Some of it can be deleted immediately, some of it can be put in to a specific mailbox. I wanted to further filter some of the SPAM by known keywords, but it wasn't my decision, this could then mean that checking SPAM for proper email, was made easier. It did bring up 2/4 false positives a day, which is the sticking point... It would have helped if the Users hadn't signed up to LOTS of newsletters and so on, which the company considered SPAM, but that's another story!!
The other point about GFI is to get the ordering of the modules correctly set up. Initially it will check for whitelisted items and _not_ check them further, i.e. if sent from a trusted email address.. Then there are about 9 SPAM checks, if it fails one of those it will put the mail to one side and deal with it with the appropriate action (i.e. delete or put in to a central/IT team mailbox or on to the User, in an appropriate subfolder).
The choice is yours if you want to place the mail in a User subfolder or in a central IT team folder.... To be checked by an IT person or by the User - depends on who's time is more valuable!!!
Of course you need to try and ensure that your email addresses aren't publicly available, otherwise you'll always attract SPAM and they seem to enjoy thinking up new ways of getting it through a SPAM filter!!
GFI has a "this is SPAM" "this is legitimate" pair of folders, so that it can learn from what has been sent. Seems good, but must be used correctly, otherwise it won't learn properly (obvious, but you would be surprised!!)
HTH
The other point about GFI is to get the ordering of the modules correctly set up. Initially it will check for whitelisted items and _not_ check them further, i.e. if sent from a trusted email address.. Then there are about 9 SPAM checks, if it fails one of those it will put the mail to one side and deal with it with the appropriate action (i.e. delete or put in to a central/IT team mailbox or on to the User, in an appropriate subfolder).
The choice is yours if you want to place the mail in a User subfolder or in a central IT team folder.... To be checked by an IT person or by the User - depends on who's time is more valuable!!!
Of course you need to try and ensure that your email addresses aren't publicly available, otherwise you'll always attract SPAM and they seem to enjoy thinking up new ways of getting it through a SPAM filter!!
GFI has a "this is SPAM" "this is legitimate" pair of folders, so that it can learn from what has been sent. Seems good, but must be used correctly, otherwise it won't learn properly (obvious, but you would be surprised!!)
HTH
mouseymousey said:
Thanks for that. I'll look at GFI.
I already use the IMF on exchange 2003 - unfortunately it gives pdf spam an SCL rating of 0!
I'd say imf too as it's free and works very well, changes significantly with exchange 2007 (if you decide to updgade) and is much more granular.I already use the IMF on exchange 2003 - unfortunately it gives pdf spam an SCL rating of 0!
you can always use rbl lists too.
edit: scl of 0 for pdf, never knew that....
goes off to test.
ok checked and I do have some that have been given "0" but I also have many instances that are stopped by the IMF and do not get to mailboxes, I even have some rated 5 which will get to mailbox but then go straight to junkmail folder.
are updates enabled?
Edited by David Godfrey on Wednesday 15th August 13:34
Thanks for all your input on this.
I'm playing with GFI now. It looks pretty powerful so hopefully could be the one. I know it's not going to be perfect but then nothing is...
David Godfrey - when you say are updates on, what updates do you mean? Windows auto update is all switched on.
Buggalugs - PureMessage initially looked great but having had it running for a day the main problem is in the rating that it gives the emails. For example, the ratings go from 0 to 100 with 100 being the most likely spam, it gave a rating of 8 to an email with no message body and only a PDF attachment (which was spam), it also gave a rating of 8 to another bit of spam with the standard random words in the message body, but it gave a rating of 41 to a proper email from our solicitors. It just seems too hit and miss. I know you have this problem with all scanners but from what I can see PureMessage doesn't do any learning so will never get better.
I'm playing with GFI now. It looks pretty powerful so hopefully could be the one. I know it's not going to be perfect but then nothing is...
David Godfrey - when you say are updates on, what updates do you mean? Windows auto update is all switched on.
Buggalugs - PureMessage initially looked great but having had it running for a day the main problem is in the rating that it gives the emails. For example, the ratings go from 0 to 100 with 100 being the most likely spam, it gave a rating of 8 to an email with no message body and only a PDF attachment (which was spam), it also gave a rating of 8 to another bit of spam with the standard random words in the message body, but it gave a rating of 41 to a proper email from our solicitors. It just seems too hit and miss. I know you have this problem with all scanners but from what I can see PureMessage doesn't do any learning so will never get better.
Thinking back, those e-card ones might be tough to crack.. In the end I put in some "brute force" blacklist keyword checking rules to stop those coming through, of course the danger is with those is that there's no "intelligence" in those checks, so if they alter them ever so slightly, they'll start to get through again.. I think I covered most/all of the bases...
It's definitely worth checking things on the GFI forum, it's open and has some very good nuggets of useful information on it.
It's definitely worth checking things on the GFI forum, it's open and has some very good nuggets of useful information on it.
Well I found how to enable the IMF updates. You have to create a new registry value. Obvious really 
I'm just importing 17000 known spam mails that I've collected into MailEssentials to train the Bayesian Filter so I hope I will start seeing an improvement soon. If not I'll put in some blacklists for the obvious e-cards spam.
Great fun this

I'm just importing 17000 known spam mails that I've collected into MailEssentials to train the Bayesian Filter so I hope I will start seeing an improvement soon. If not I'll put in some blacklists for the obvious e-cards spam.
Great fun this

Do you want something that runs on Windows or do you have a dedicated box to run something on?
Also what level of control do you want and how much time do you want to spend looking after the thing?
I've put in a box using a mix of Linux/Postfix/Spamassassin/MailScanner/ClamAV and granted it's not a "drop in" solution, but it does a very good job for what it costs vs. the sort of money commercial software would have cost us for 600 or so mailboxes, plus (call me paranoid) I'm not a huge fan of connecting an Exchange box directly to the Internet.
If it's only 10 mailboxes, I'd be sorely tempted to look at some sort of outsourced solution.
Also what level of control do you want and how much time do you want to spend looking after the thing?
I've put in a box using a mix of Linux/Postfix/Spamassassin/MailScanner/ClamAV and granted it's not a "drop in" solution, but it does a very good job for what it costs vs. the sort of money commercial software would have cost us for 600 or so mailboxes, plus (call me paranoid) I'm not a huge fan of connecting an Exchange box directly to the Internet.
If it's only 10 mailboxes, I'd be sorely tempted to look at some sort of outsourced solution.
mouseymousey said:
Well I found how to enable the IMF updates. You have to create a new registry value. Obvious really 
Updates help allot, there generally released 20 something every month.
hutchingsp said:
plus (call me paranoid) I'm not a huge fan of connecting an Exchange box directly to the Internet.
That's exacly what ISA server is for 
Edited by David Godfrey on Wednesday 15th August 20:33
I want something to run on windows, I can't really be bothered with creating a complex-ish solution on a separate box. Outsourcing is also a bit of a no-go because although it's only 10 or so mailboxes there are 4 domains and quite a strange setup.
Anyhow, IMF is now set up to update and I'm still looking at the eval of MailEssentials so that'll do me for now.
Thanks all.
Anyhow, IMF is now set up to update and I'm still looking at the eval of MailEssentials so that'll do me for now.
Thanks all.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


