Mac RAM - Crucial?
Author
Discussion

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,670 posts

241 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
Need to upgrade the iMac as 1gb isn't cutting it any more.

Haven't needed to buy RAM as a consumer for ages - presume Crucial are still the best for compatibility/service/price, end of story?

TheLearner

6,962 posts

266 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
Crucial / Fleabay / Whatever. Mac's take bog standard DIMM's, probably either DDR or DDR2 depending on it's generation.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
Just a note to say that some Macs were *very* picky about RAM. In other words, make sure you get the correct speed rating / latency / etc. The G4 towers were a pain for this.

It was most likely due to those machines having Apple-designed northbridges so they were less tolerant of out-of-spec RAM. If you're talking about a newish machine then it'll have an Intel northbridge so use any RAM that's compatible.

I've always used Crucial because most hardware issues I've seen are bad RAM, and I've had a couple of bad sticks that Crucial replaced immediately without quibbling. I don't think they're massively more expensive than anywhere else are they? Good customer service is worth a bit to me.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
I bought an additional 1GB stick for my MacBook Pro from Crucial, and it started to intermittently freeze dead in its tracks shortly after - in both Vista and OSX. Removed and reseated, made no difference. Eventually swapped the two sticks over into the opposite slots, and it's been perfect ever since.

Haven't worried too much about it, I'd guess at some sort of timing issue.

edit to add that I've pretty much always bought RAM from Crucial for Intel PCs and for our our old G3 tower and G5 iMac, and never had a problem before. They'd definitely be my first choice.


Edited by jamieboy on Tuesday 21st August 20:12

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
TheLearner said:
Crucial / Fleabay / Whatever. Mac's take bog standard DIMM's, probably either DDR or DDR2 depending on it's generation.
Just spotted. Started driving lessons then Sarah?

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,670 posts

241 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
TheLearner said:
Crucial / Fleabay / Whatever. Mac's take bog standard DIMM's, probably either DDR or DDR2 depending on it's generation.
It's a 9 month old 24" C2D iMac so compatibility shouldn't be an issue. Tbh I'm a little old fashioned where memory is concerned having been burned (not literally smile) in the past by the cheap cheerful stuff.

At work we just order the Kingston part as it's what our supplier tends to stock, but as a personal purchase I wanted to check I hadn't missed some "new kid on the block".

TheLearner

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
TheLearner said:
Crucial / Fleabay / Whatever. Mac's take bog standard DIMM's, probably either DDR or DDR2 depending on it's generation.
Just spotted. Started driving lessons then Sarah?
yes Booked for the 5th Sep. Going to be weird, the last thing I had on the roads had hand controls hehe (motorbike).

hutchingsp said:
TheLearner said:
Crucial / Fleabay / Whatever. Mac's take bog standard DIMM's, probably either DDR or DDR2 depending on it's generation.
It's a 9 month old 24" C2D iMac so compatibility shouldn't be an issue. Tbh I'm a little old fashioned where memory is concerned having been burned (not literally smile) in the past by the cheap cheerful stuff.

At work we just order the Kingston part as it's what our supplier tends to stock, but as a personal purchase I wanted to check I hadn't missed some "new kid on the block".
These days most RAM suppliers have got the right idea, the days of Hynix dumping a shed load of shitty modules on the market (any one remember those double density suckers that mapped around the bad blocks?) are long gone. Personally my two laptops came with Crucial and all my DIY kit has Samsung branded units in it..... no issues to speak of (other than a crash happy Ubuntu build, yay for SiS chipsets :S )

The C2D will be an Intel chipset inside so very tolerant of fooling around, obviously, get the type of memory mentioned in the manual, but other than that... which ever your supplier of choice is will in all likleyhood be fine.