Partitioning hard drives,advice please
Partitioning hard drives,advice please
Author
Discussion

That Daddy

Original Poster:

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
I have currently got 2 Western Digital 10k Raptors in Raid 0 (yes i know bad idea but i have a big ext drive for b/up)i do however play games and speed is what i need,now when it come to partitioning the array do i have a small partition just for windows,then a 2nd partition for games documents itunes etc,or do i not partition and have 148gb(2x74gb) of space,i did this in the past on another system and had no problems,i am getting differing opinions on this can one of you guys help please as i am about to put a fresh install of Xp pro,i tend to know more about the hardware on PC,s than the software can any of you IT guys help,thanks.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Yes its not a problem, I build games machines with exactly the same config as yours. The steps are simple:

1) Build the array in the hardware - RAID 0 in the RAID BIOS.
2) Load Windows and hit F6 to load the RAID driver when prompted. When Windows asks you which hard disk to use it will also show you a box with the size of (your combined) RAID drive. Select this disk and put in the amount out of the total thats offered ie of the 150gig enter the amount your require then proceed with the install as usual.
3) When Windows has installed right click on My Computer and choose Manage. On the left hand pane, choose Disk Manager and when loaded click on the empty unallocated drive space and follow the prompts.

More here smilehttp://support.microsoft.com/kb/313348

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Rather that partition the RAID at all why not just another drive? YOu will soon use 150 gig.

Drives are peanuts now, my local store is doing 320gig SATA/EIDE's for £45 eek

Also I wouldn't store 'mission critical' stuff on the RAID disk, the likelyhood of recovering it is 1000 to 1 compared to a nornmal standalone disk.

Once you have built your system and gotten the software on teh RAID drive how you like it, simply do a FULL backup using MS backup and store the image on the other drive. Then if all goes tits up simply restore the backed up image.

NickFRP

5,156 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
i thought todays operating systems and games it doesnt matter like the old days when you really needed to have 2 partitions (1 for windows and the 2nd for games music)

or is it still good practice to have a Raid 0 with 2 partitions?

That Daddy

Original Poster:

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Thanks chaps,sorry i may have posted this badly,but what i need to know is do i partition or not, some say to have windows on a small partition and every thing on the 2nd or 3rd partition,so as you have less chance of corrupting the windows files true/false,or just load windows on the array with no partition and why not?oh thanks SS HSV, but loading the array i have no problems with sussed that one years ago(another story),storage driver 1st raid driver 2nd back to front,thanks in advance chapswinkone more question 64k stripe or 128 for the array?

Edited by That Daddy on Wednesday 22 August 13:30

TheLearner

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Personally I wouldn't be all that worried. Windows is pretty dense when it comes to swap management (i.e. you can't make a swap partition/drive) and you've already got a backup solution in place and working.

Considering how large programs (games) and the output of some (video editing) can be, I'd leave the suckers as one large volume and run the risk. My opinion is that with a sufficiently fast disk (which you've got) any tricks you could pull off with clever partitioning and RAID configs would just offer diminishing returns and add complexity to any reinstall plans.

Now if this was a mission critical server type thing, I'd be smacking you with a RAID5 controller about now... but for a desktop, that's backed up... screw it smile

Edit: And also, the number of programs that, despite being pointed to another drive, insist on littering \Windows\ and C:\ with crap... might as well just have C:\ and backup regularly.


Edited by TheLearner on Wednesday 22 August 14:33

That Daddy

Original Poster:

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Sarah, thats just the help i needed,you made up my mind thanks,one big un/patitioned drive it is then,(same as i had before on another machine)

JamieT

1,536 posts

283 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
TheLearner said:
you can't make a swap partition/drive
Not sure what you mean by that. You could make a partion and have only the page file on it if you wanted to (still have a small page file on C: though otherwise Windows can ingore your settings and create it's own). However, it wouldn't really be any benefit if it's on the same drive as everything else. Moving page files only really makes sense if you can have a dedicated drive for them, but that is complete overkill. It's all relative though with the amount of RAM in modern machines. I've tried all sorts of configurations on both servers and desktops and I've never really noticed much difference.

Stay away from RAID0 unless you're doing major video editing. It doesn't even have much effect on the speed of most games, which is far more likely to be dictated by your GPU. In other scenarios speed increase is negligable and data loss always becomes more likely. To be honest I'd just use one drive for OS and apps and one for storing data, with the data drive backed up to the external drive using msbackup. Simple as that. The main benefit being that you can re-install OS withought messing about with your data.

Edited by JamieT on Wednesday 22 August 18:36

TheLearner

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
JamieT said:
TheLearner said:
you can't make a swap partition/drive
Not sure what you mean by that. You could make a partion and have only the page file on it if you wanted to (still have a small page file on C: though otherwise Windows can ingore your settings and create it's own). However, it wouldn't really be any benefit if it's on the same drive as everything else. Moving page files only really makes sense if you can have a dedicated drive for them, but that is complete overkill. It's all relative though with the amount of RAM in modern machines. I've tried all sorts of configurations on both servers and desktops and I've never really noticed much difference.
Under the "Only so many ways to skin a cat" principal (I mean, there are only so many mouse control routines you can write that actually work), I've tried a similar thing on a Linux system, disabled the swap partition and created a swapfile (of equal space). Same drive as the partition, definite performance hit whenever the OS swaps... which all modern OS's do regardless of the amount of RAM.
Their is a performance difference between a dedicated partition and a file, even if it is on the same drive; always was (I knocked up my own swapper code and tried it once, many moons ago). As to what causes that I couldn't say; perhaps the partition method gives the drive heads time to move? Or because it's a whole partition you don't have to be that careful about writing gibberish to it?

Vista and it's ReadyBoost system seems to be a swap drive/partition mechanism judging by the bumpf and using it does net a small increase in performance.