Processor upgrade - options?
Author
Discussion

Stig

Original Poster:

11,823 posts

315 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
In anticipation of receiving my copy of Bioshock and Crysis - which are both bound to be mega-power hungry, I'm considering an upgrade to my gamer rig.

It's not too shabby at the mo, but I'm thinking that the processor could perhaps be upgraded?

Currently, spec is:

AMD Athlon 63 X2 4200+
ASUS A8N32 SLI Deluxe mobo
2GB Ram
2 x 512Mb GeForce 7900GTX graphics cards (dual SLI)

The ASUS has the 939 socket, so am I right in thinking that a logical upgrade would be to replace the processor with something like an AMD FX-60?

Any other suggestions?

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
You could get an AMD X2 600+ CPU for that mobo, that runs at 3 GHz and should be a fantastic compliment to that board, for just over £100. That would handle Bioshock no prob, better than my quad core extreme sitting in my dead mobo at the mo, frownhehe

TheLearner

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
To be honest, the two games you've mentioned have DX10 capabilities in them. If you wanted to get the best from them, I'd suggest moving to Windows Vista and buying an 8000 series card (or two) would be in order.

I've a Core 2 Duo 2.0 and 7900 GS, Bioshock runs great at 1280x8?? (Widscreen). I can probably go higher but meh smile So other than the SLi thing our CPU's are pretty much neck and neck.


LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Not quite true Chris, the 6000+ is an AM2 mobo CPU.
As far as I know the FX-60 series were the fastest available for 939 skt.
I believe of the "normal" Athlon X2's the 4200+ was the top.
A new mobo and a 6000+ can be had for around £140-150, which would be be a fair step up for not much £ smile

rsv gone!

11,288 posts

272 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
4800+ was fastest s939 Athlon 64 X2

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
LukeBird said:
Not quite true Chris, the 6000+ is an AM2 mobo CPU.
As far as I know the FX-60 series were the fastest available for 939 skt.
I believe of the "normal" Athlon X2's the 4200+ was the top.
A new mobo and a 6000+ can be had for around £140-150, which would be be a fair step up for not much £ smile
Yes, you're right, sorry boxedin, am all in a dither!
And you're right about a new mobo and 6000+, a year ago, the price would have been at least triple what it is now.

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
chris watton said:
Yes, you're right, sorry boxedin, am all in a dither!
And you're right about a new mobo and 6000+, a year ago, the price would have been at least triple what it is now.
hehe Don't worry, no one died! wink
I'm still tempted by a 6000+ even though I know the C2D's (specifically the E6750/6850 is what i'd look at) are technically better! Tempted to stay with AMD, thats all!

P.S. Have you bought GTR2 yet? Or still enjoying GTR?
I bought a G25 week before last, bloody great fun with TDU smile

Stig

Original Poster:

11,823 posts

315 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
chris watton said:
LukeBird said:
Not quite true Chris, the 6000+ is an AM2 mobo CPU.
As far as I know the FX-60 series were the fastest available for 939 skt.
I believe of the "normal" Athlon X2's the 4200+ was the top.
A new mobo and a 6000+ can be had for around £140-150, which would be be a fair step up for not much £ smile
Yes, you're right, sorry boxedin, am all in a dither!
And you're right about a new mobo and 6000+, a year ago, the price would have been at least triple what it is now.
Thanks chaps, but I'd like to limit the spend to the processor only.

Looking at the performance stats on the AMD site, the FX-60 is only 2nd to the FX-57 in performance terms, whilst still being 939 compatible.

Seems like the most cost effective upgrade as I'd also need to replace my RAM with DDR2 to get the best from an AM2 mobo?

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
With regard to DDR2 RAM, yeah if you were going to upgrade it would be a very good idea!
Not entirely sure if many (any) AM2 mobo's support DDR400 RAM...
Maybe just an Fx-60 then!

Stig

Original Poster:

11,823 posts

315 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
As usual, it boils down to the best bang for my errr... pound smile

Looking at the Tomshardware CPU charts, there's only 5fps difference between my 4200+ and the FX-60 when runninf F.E.A.R (and this is a gaming driven upgrade). Even the chart topping Intel QX6850 isn't 'that' much better. Thing is, most games are written for single or at most, dual core - so quad is of little benefit.

After doing more research, it doesn't sound as if there's a great deal of benefit given the £200 odd quid it's going to cost me to upgrade?

Unless someone can explain an alternative???

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
eBay... smile
You can't buy series 60 AThlon FX's any more, there are new FX's out now...
For £200, that would just about get you a mobo, 6000+ and 2gb DDR2 RAM

Athlon - http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...
Mobo - http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...
RAM - http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...

smile

TheLearner

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Stig said:
As usual, it boils down to the best bang for my errr... pound smile

Looking at the Tomshardware CPU charts, there's only 5fps difference between my 4200+ and the FX-60 when runninf F.E.A.R (and this is a gaming driven upgrade). Even the chart topping Intel QX6850 isn't 'that' much better. Thing is, most games are written for single or at most, dual core - so quad is of little benefit.

After doing more research, it doesn't sound as if there's a great deal of benefit given the £200 odd quid it's going to cost me to upgrade?

Unless someone can explain an alternative???
The games you specifically mentioned should make use of a dual core system (the Bioshock demo even comes with the AMD X2 timing patch for Windows), to be honest, I don't really think plunking down £200 for an FX-60 will net you £200's worth of improvement TBH. You'll be better off getting Bioshock/Crysis on your current X2 (Dual Core) and putting that £200 towards are more total overhaul further down the line (CPU/MOBO/RAM/GFX).

Stig

Original Poster:

11,823 posts

315 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
TheLearner said:
Stig said:
As usual, it boils down to the best bang for my errr... pound smile

Looking at the Tomshardware CPU charts, there's only 5fps difference between my 4200+ and the FX-60 when runninf F.E.A.R (and this is a gaming driven upgrade). Even the chart topping Intel QX6850 isn't 'that' much better. Thing is, most games are written for single or at most, dual core - so quad is of little benefit.

After doing more research, it doesn't sound as if there's a great deal of benefit given the £200 odd quid it's going to cost me to upgrade?

Unless someone can explain an alternative???
The games you specifically mentioned should make use of a dual core system (the Bioshock demo even comes with the AMD X2 timing patch for Windows), to be honest, I don't really think plunking down £200 for an FX-60 will net you £200's worth of improvement TBH. You'll be better off getting Bioshock/Crysis on your current X2 (Dual Core) and putting that £200 towards are more total overhaul further down the line (CPU/MOBO/RAM/GFX).
Sounds like we've reached the same conclusion then smile

Better off spending the £200 on pizza and beer whilst I play the aforementioned hehe

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
Stig said:
TheLearner said:
Stig said:
As usual, it boils down to the best bang for my errr... pound smile

Looking at the Tomshardware CPU charts, there's only 5fps difference between my 4200+ and the FX-60 when runninf F.E.A.R (and this is a gaming driven upgrade). Even the chart topping Intel QX6850 isn't 'that' much better. Thing is, most games are written for single or at most, dual core - so quad is of little benefit.

After doing more research, it doesn't sound as if there's a great deal of benefit given the £200 odd quid it's going to cost me to upgrade?

Unless someone can explain an alternative???
The games you specifically mentioned should make use of a dual core system (the Bioshock demo even comes with the AMD X2 timing patch for Windows), to be honest, I don't really think plunking down £200 for an FX-60 will net you £200's worth of improvement TBH. You'll be better off getting Bioshock/Crysis on your current X2 (Dual Core) and putting that £200 towards are more total overhaul further down the line (CPU/MOBO/RAM/GFX).
Sounds like we've reached the same conclusion then smile

Better off spending the £200 on pizza and beer whilst I play the aforementioned hehe
I really don’t think you’d notice much, if at all difference in the games if you had upgraded.
I can say this because our home PC can play any game at top whack, and if I’m honest, I can’t tell the difference having a game like, say, STALKER on maximum setting to a few notches below, as I had to before.

If a game is good from the off, a few barely noticeable graphical tweaks turned on isn’t going to make it any more or less playable, or noticeably prettier, to the normal eye anyway.

Buy the game and enjoy it on the system you have, it’s not a bad set up you have anyway. smile

ETA, I have an E6750 C2D in one Pc and a QX6700 Extreme quad core CPU in another. you know what the difference is between these two CPU's when playing games, Zilch!


Edited by chris watton on Wednesday 22 August 16:43

jimmyjimjim

8,352 posts

269 months

Wednesday 22nd August 2007
quotequote all
I went from a 4400+ to an FX-60 - if you can do it relatively cheaply (about £160 for me a few months back, when the supplier were selling out the last of their stock), I'd throughly recommend it.
Have a look oneBay and see what you can find.
Responsiveness has defintely improved, and everything seems smoother now.
Not bothered running any benchmarks or anything, as they never show any real differences, but FEAR, supreme commander, stalker all seem to run more smoothly now, and at higher resolutions than with the 4400.
I went for the FX-60 as a mid life upgrade; I'm going to see what Crysis is like on it before deciding to upgrade further.

rsv gone!

11,288 posts

272 months

Thursday 23rd August 2007
quotequote all
jimmyjimjim said:
I went from a 4400+ to an FX-60 - if you can do it relatively cheaply (about £160 for me a few months back, when the supplier were selling out the last of their stock), I'd throughly recommend it.
Have a look oneBay and see what you can find.
Responsiveness has defintely improved, and everything seems smoother now.
Not bothered running any benchmarks or anything, as they never show any real differences, but FEAR, supreme commander, stalker all seem to run more smoothly now, and at higher resolutions than with the 4400.
I went for the FX-60 as a mid life upgrade; I'm going to see what Crysis is like on it before deciding to upgrade further.
I'm in a similar position. I have a s939 3800+ (why did you have to change the bloody socket, AMD?). I have an 8800GTX, 3G Corsair etc and I'm sure my CPU is the weak point in the system. Stalker runs with all the options on outside but inside, with dynamic lighting enabled, it falls over. FPS must be down in single figures.

I'm undecided on getting a FX57 or FX60 or just getting a C2D 6750 and new mobo, but then do I get a DDR2 mobo or DDR3 with greater futureproofing but current DDR3 is expensive and no quicker than decent DDR2

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Thursday 23rd August 2007
quotequote all
I bought a Gigabyte GA-P35C-DS3R mobo for my 6750 - it has slots for both DDR2 and DDR3 (I have DDR2 in mine), and I can tell you that if you already have an 8800GTX, you 'can' have Stalker ramped up to the full with absolutley no performance issues, inside or out - and that's with the CPU at stock speed. The performance difference between AMD and Intel is very noticable. (Although, as I said before, slightly prettier graphics do not make an already great game any greater, IMOHO smile

Edited by chris watton on Thursday 23 August 09:13

That Daddy

19,466 posts

252 months

Thursday 23rd August 2007
quotequote all
rsv gone! said:
jimmyjimjim said:
I went from a 4400+ to an FX-60 - if you can do it relatively cheaply (about £160 for me a few months back, when the supplier were selling out the last of their stock), I'd throughly recommend it.
Have a look oneBay and see what you can find.
Responsiveness has defintely improved, and everything seems smoother now.
Not bothered running any benchmarks or anything, as they never show any real differences, but FEAR, supreme commander, stalker all seem to run more smoothly now, and at higher resolutions than with the 4400.
I went for the FX-60 as a mid life upgrade; I'm going to see what Crysis is like on it before deciding to upgrade further.
I'm in a similar position. I have a s939 3800+ (why did you have to change the bloody socket, AMD?). I have an 8800GTX, 3G Corsair etc and I'm sure my CPU is the weak point in the system. Stalker runs with all the options on outside but inside, with dynamic lighting enabled, it falls over. FPS must be down in single figures.

I'm undecided on getting a FX57 or FX60 or just getting a C2D 6750 and new mobo, but then do I get a DDR2 mobo or DDR3 with greater futureproofing but current DDR3 is expensive and no quicker than decent DDR2
Go with that core duo,you will be amazedbow

rsv gone!

11,288 posts

272 months

Thursday 23rd August 2007
quotequote all
chris watton said:
I bought a Gigabyte GA-P35C-DS3R mobo for my 6750 - it has slots for both DDR2 and DDR3 (I have DDR2 in mine), and I can tell you that if you already have an 8800GTX, you 'can' have Stalker ramped up to the full with absolutley no performance issues, inside or out
I didn't realise you could get boards which would take DDR2 and 3. I thought I'd have to chose one or the other.

1333FSB as well!

You're going to cost me a load of money!!

Edited by rsv gone! on Thursday 23 August 10:30

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Thursday 23rd August 2007
quotequote all
rsv gone! said:
chris watton said:
I bought a Gigabyte GA-P35C-DS3R mobo for my 6750 - it has slots for both DDR2 and DDR3 (I have DDR2 in mine), and I can tell you that if you already have an 8800GTX, you 'can' have Stalker ramped up to the full with absolutley no performance issues, inside or out
I didn't realise you could get boards which would take DDR2 and 3. I thought I'd have to chose one or the other.

1333FSB as well!

You're going to cost me a load of money!!

Edited by rsv gone! on Thursday 23 August 10:30
hehe, But the price isn't bad at all, especially if I compare it to my useless Striker Extreme mobo;

http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?Web...

from scan website said:
The GA-P35C-DS3R is GIGABYTE high performance platform based on the killer combination of the new Intel P35
chipset plus support for the latest multi-core processors up to FSB 1333MHz, including the upcoming 45nm
platform.

In addition, the GA-P35C-DS3R ultimate scalability with both DDR2 and DDR3 memory support for running next
generation applications with lower power consumption. The GA-P35C-DS3R is also part of the GIGABYTE Ultra
Durable 2 Series of motherboards, featuring top quality electronic components which provide optimized power
savings, ultra cooling and extended system durability.