E38 1996 728 'clunking' noise
E38 1996 728 'clunking' noise
Author
Discussion

fogster

Original Poster:

60 posts

293 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Ok - here's a good 'un!

I have a 1996 UK spec BMW 728i (E38) (steptronic). I purchased the car in September 2002 and since then the car has developed a "clunk" that can be felt coming through the floor, it appears this eminates from the front right hand side (drivers side) of the car, although this is not definite.

Originally the problem was very slight but has developed with use. The noise is not evident from start-up and occurs once the car has been driven in stop-start traffic for a short period of time. I can do a trip of 250 miles on the motorway at 70-90mph with no sound at all. Returning to city driving in normal / light traffic and the car is very well behaved (with only the occasional hint of the noise from the front). However, take the car out in rush hour and after only about five or ten minutes and the noise starts.

The car has been to four garages (two independent garages, an independent specialist and a main dealer) - all could clearly hear the noise when I delivered the car, but on inspecting the car none could find anything amiss at all (in 2 cases they actually rang me up the following day when they started work on the car to check the description of the fault as they couldn't hear anythng at all!). The noise is now so bad as to be embarrassing and quite worrying.

BMW-728i-1996

1 posts

120 months

Saturday 26th November 2016
quotequote all
Dear Steve, (fogster)

Re: Cluncking noise in my BMW728i, November 2016

Your description of the fault in your old BMW728i (2003), describes precisely the noise and time of occurrence as I am experiencing with my now 20 year old BMW728i.

Still a lovely car to drive after all these years. (I owned it from new in 1996, and have cared for it very well)… you would never know, it’s that old.

I hope you are still a member of this forum, and wanted to ask, if you can recall which parts you had replaced to remedy the issue. BMW New Zealand, as well as my suspension/muffler repair-shop, have heard the cluncking noise after driving the vehicle for a while in city traffic and mainly when it is hot. But they too can't identify where the noise comes from.

Quietly hoping that you can recall the issue after all these years… and how you managed to fix it.

I would be most appreciative to hearing from you, so that I can get the garage to fix it for me.

Sincerely,
Bart Blommaert




Regarding your
Wednesday 18th June 2003 Blog note

quote:

I have a 1996 UK spec BMW 728i (E38) (steptronic). I purchased the car in September 2002 and since then the car has developed a "clunk" that can be felt coming through the floor, it appears this eminates from the front right hand side (drivers side) of the car, although this is not definite.

Originally the problem was very slight but has developed with use. The noise is not evident from start-up and occurs once the car has been driven in stop-start traffic for a short period of time. I can do a trip of 250 miles on the motorway at 70-90mph with no sound at all. Returning to city driving in normal / light traffic and the car is very well behaved (with only the occasional hint of the noise from the front). However, take the car out in rush hour and after only about five or ten minutes and the noise starts.

The car has been to four garages (two independent garages, an independent specialist and a main dealer) - all could clearly hear the noise when I delivered the car, but on inspecting the car none could find anything amiss at all (in 2 cases they actually rang me up the following day when they started work on the car to check the description of the fault as they couldn't hear anythng at all!). The noise is now so bad as to be embarrassing and quite worrying.