993 RS or 997 GT3
993 RS or 997 GT3
Author
Discussion

rsr 9

Original Poster:

78 posts

254 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Seriously thinking of getting into a 997 GT3 and out of a 993 RS, anybody been down this road,
would appreciate any comments ?

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
No, but familiar with both.

Whilst the 993RS is pretty special and without question one of the best 911s ever, the 997GT3 has a much greater breadth of abilities, enabling you to get much more use out of it, whether in every day use, as a continental GT, or as a track day toy.

Future values are impossible to predict, but a 993RS is unlikely to depreciate. 997GT3 residuals could well remain fairly strong, but they are more likely to slip in time. ,

ScottL

814 posts

261 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
Come along to Donington on the 24th if you fancy some px laps.

Be very interested to hear your own thoughts in due course, as once you experience a 997, there will be no turning back! hehe

Slippydiff

16,497 posts

254 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
993RS more tactile and focused, but positively asthmatic compared to even a Mk1 996 GT3 (never mind the 997 version)

Having sold my 993 and swapped to a MK1 GT3 (and thence onto the GT2) I can honestly say (from a driving perspective) I don't miss the older car.
If I had to have an aircooled and watercooled car in my stable I'd have a 964RS over the 993 as my car of choice.

Edited by Slippydiff on Wednesday 3rd October 01:00

RSPhilip

252 posts

238 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
Agree on the speed front...more modern, quicker etc etc but that is the forward march of improvement. 993RS is the legend in my mind! the prettier car more tactile, not inhibitied by electronic gubbins and will always continue the walk up the appreciation ladder. Last of the aircooled greats, never to be repeated.

997RS special as it is and believe me I would love to have one too..however im not going to sell my 964RS and the 993RS..However its a vehicle that seems too compromised for an RS. There is a quote above saying its a great continental cruiser...surely the RS badge on the back means motorsport? Not the ability to drive huge distances in a straight line.

Speed on the track means nothing when you have feel and a car that communicates to you! give me a 550Spyder over a carrera gt anyday!! actually scratch that...can I have both ;-)

Stick with it Steve...get the Gold BBS rims (they will look awesome), drive your car...enjoy it...and happily giggle that its a working investment for you aswell.

See it looks friggin awesome ;-)





Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
RSPhilip said:
There is a quote above saying its a great continental cruiser...surely the RS badge on the back means motorsport? Not the ability to drive huge distances in a straight line.
I think he was referring to the 997 GT3 not the 993RS

RSPhilip

252 posts

238 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
I gather...that's why Steve should stick with the 993RS. More RS i suppose.

apologies for the confusion

rsr 9

Original Poster:

78 posts

254 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for all the advice, very hard decision to make, need a test drive of a 997 gt3 soon.

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
rsr 9 said:
Thanks for all the advice, very hard decision to make, need a test drive of a 997 gt3 soon.
If you contact Porsche you may still be able to do Millbrook or MIRA in a GT3. You'll need to pay (c.£500+) but you'll get a good day out and the best opportunity to try the car under the widest range of conditions. Small price to pay to help you make the right decision.

vpr

3,935 posts

269 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
Problem is that these apreciating classics are a bit of a liability to own.

They're not the kind of car that you can run all year round, pop down the shops or pub etc. These old aircooled cars will deteriorate and then values will be affected.

At least with the 7RS it's a car that you can use and abuse to a certain extent.

I know where your coming from. I have a similar dilema with my CSL. The car is over 3 yrs old and will further deteriorate this winter and I can't handle the thought so it has to go. And in with the new.

johnny senna

4,073 posts

303 months

Wednesday 3rd October 2007
quotequote all
993 RS is going UP in value. 997 GT3 is going DOWN in value. This very fact alone is why my missus will allow me to have a 911 at all. She wouldn't tolerate losing 30K in 4-5 years, whis is what will happen to the 997 GT3.

G T 3

2,142 posts

285 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Johnny dont use that losing value arguement not to buy a car,its a cop out..How much does every thing else loose ie big tellies,computers ,stereos, holidays,posh food,going to restaurants etc etc,all a waste of money if you add them up....Bet your house goes up in value more in a year than you would loose in 4 years on a top end 911.....Plus we are a long time dead...I say do it.

Edited by G T 3 on Thursday 4th October 09:14


Edited by G T 3 on Thursday 4th October 09:14

vpr

3,935 posts

269 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
G T 3 said:
Johnny dont use that losing value arguement not to buy a car,its a cop out..How much does every thing else loose ie big tellies,computers ,stereos, holidays,posh food,going to restaurants etc etc,all a waste of money if you add them up....Bet your house goes up in value more in a year than you would loose in 4 years on a top end 911.....Plus we are a long time dead...I say do it.

Edited by G T 3 on Thursday 4th October 09:14


Edited by G T 3 on Thursday 4th October 09:14
Spot on.

Anyhow you don't realise the loss till you sell.......so don't sell.

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Whether a car goes up or down in value is really only relevant when you come to sell it.

If you are buying a car to use, then the question has to be, which will you use most and which will provide the most enjoyment. The financial aspect should be secondary.

I've got an RS and it's been a very good 'investment', (although I do think the market has got a bit inflated), but the 997GT3 is such a clever package that you could use and enjoy it every day for years to come. And there's every possibility you may never want to sell it.

johnny senna

4,073 posts

303 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
I don't agree. There's a lot of psychology at work here. Knowing that you car isn't losing ££££££££s all the time helps you feel better, no question. Gives you a nice smug feeling. I recommend it to you.

G T 3

2,142 posts

285 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
My 965 turbo,which I sold 3 years ago with only 23k miles cobalt blue,was minter,only one owner before me,is now worth a lot more than I sold it for as those older turbos are now sort after ,where as some people wouldnt touch them before....thats the way of the 911.They come and go..

Steve Rance

5,453 posts

262 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Two completely different cars. The 993 will be more involving, the 997 better road manners. very difficult to compare until youv'e driven both

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Steve, at least try one...I went from a 3.2 CS to a kettle and came back to an aircooled RS or 2, JohnnyP had the sense to keep his sublime RS, when he realised the newer cars didn't have the same magic smile

You can always get another car, better to scratch the itch than forever wonder smile

Essential

1,084 posts

241 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Easy really.

993rs going up in value, possibly.
997 gt3 going down in value, probally.

Therefore have both and be net flat on the depreciation angle.

Nice

Loach

3,357 posts

247 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
johnny senna said:
I don't agree. There's a lot of psychology at work here. Knowing that you car isn't losing ££££££££s all the time helps you feel better, no question. Gives you a nice smug feeling. I recommend it to you.
I completely agree with that. Any other serious commitments dependent on a finite supply of money make it a far more relaxing and comfortable proposition to invest in something that isn't sitting on the drive with little '€' signs evaporating around it 24/7. Where the 911 is concerned, there at least 10 different varieties of the breed that I'd be thrilled to own, so up to a point, the sort of tenacity with which one will hold on to its value over another has real relevance.

On the question at hand, I'd give my vote to the 993RS because it's fast enough, has limits that can be explored at relatively low speeds making it a really fun drive IMO, and the 993RS give me wood in any event so that's always a plus. The 997 GT3 is brilliant (haven't driven the 997 GT3 RS) and looks fantastic, but Jesus - by the time you feel you're really driving it, time has slowed down and the tarmac is rippling behins you Matrix-style. Plus - I know they're great and all, but I hate in principal that I have to push buttons in the new GT3s to activate this and deactivate that. Seems a bit of a cheat. If I could afford both, I'd be swayed by the merits of each - but with one to go in the garage, it'd be the older car.