987 Boxster market liquidity
Discussion
I've had a decent-spec 2005/55 Boxster S advertised on here, eBay and Autotrader for a week with a handful of enquiries. I put it up for the CAP black book price adjusted for mileage and options. http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/236618.htm
I was expecting a few more enquiries to be honest... is anyone else selling something similar, if so just wondering how many private enquiries you're getting?
Is the market 'slow' at the moment or have I done something crazily wrong? Is the black book wrong? It seems in line with Parkers, although a bit lower.
I was expecting a few more enquiries to be honest... is anyone else selling something similar, if so just wondering how many private enquiries you're getting?
Is the market 'slow' at the moment or have I done something crazily wrong? Is the black book wrong? It seems in line with Parkers, although a bit lower.
No centre caps on the wheels in the photo because someone pinched them - I have since replaced them. (£130 for 4 bits of plastic!)
Cheapest 987s on pistonheads:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/241913.htm - Poverty spec, 54k miles, £24750
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/253875.htm - Mid spec, 20k miles, £29995
Both are 05 reg and mine is a 55 reg. Mine is 40k miles, higher spec, and I am pricing at £27950... doesn't seem too crazy to me?
Cheapest 987s on pistonheads:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/241913.htm - Poverty spec, 54k miles, £24750
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/253875.htm - Mid spec, 20k miles, £29995
Both are 05 reg and mine is a 55 reg. Mine is 40k miles, higher spec, and I am pricing at £27950... doesn't seem too crazy to me?
Two things you need to get right, price and advert:
On the ad I'd say:
- No mileage shown (Buyers assume it's a problem) - add the mileage
- Photos show no hub caps (Buyer thinks uncared for) - add some better photos
- Full Porsche Service History - At which dealer, what was done and when?
- Porsche warrenty - How much is left?
- Presume all those options are real options not standard spec? - If not show what is standard spec and what is options
- Don't repeat facts (year/model)
Price:
Look at others on Autotrader prices as AT ads are paid for and so people don't want to keep paying and are often more realistic than Pistonheads.
Good luck
On the ad I'd say:
- No mileage shown (Buyers assume it's a problem) - add the mileage
- Photos show no hub caps (Buyer thinks uncared for) - add some better photos
- Full Porsche Service History - At which dealer, what was done and when?
- Porsche warrenty - How much is left?
- Presume all those options are real options not standard spec? - If not show what is standard spec and what is options
- Don't repeat facts (year/model)
Price:
Look at others on Autotrader prices as AT ads are paid for and so people don't want to keep paying and are often more realistic than Pistonheads.
Good luck
This is my take on the market - for what it is worth and offered to help - although what I have to say will not please everyone - sorry.
Every year Porsche sell more new cars than the old ones that get scrapped - so it is a growth market overall year on year.
For people wanting a new car - despite the increase in sales - the volume may only increase or decrease by a small amount each year compared to the previous year - so it may go up or down by say 5% OR 10%. But for old or second hand cars - it grows by the numbers sold the previous year every single year (except for the few that are scrapped) therefore may increase by say 90% of the new cars sales (just a guess to make the point - no lengthy inquisitions that go off the point please).
Consequently the number of cars at any one time in the used Porsche car market is relentlessly growing each year - and each year ALL the cars in that market are a year older - so eventually there are far more cars in every price bracket (under new car prices) and the older they get and the lower the price - the more of them at the lower end there are - and the numbers in say the £10K to £20K bracket increase enormously.
Previously there were a few 968's, 944 turbo's and 922 3.2 carerra's in that bracket - now there are also all models of Boxsters, 964's, 993's and even some 996's. The Boxster represented a lower price Porsche option new that the previous years models - so it enters that lower used car price bracket with all the other cars already there - sooner.
Many buyers in that market already own their dream Porsche and want to keep it for years - so the market for new buyers is relatively low. There is less movement in the market once someone owns their dream car - so the number seeking such a car lowers.
Furthermore the market for all cars has moved up a few years as the public have learned about the benefits of a newer car rather than an older one at current (and future) high labour repair rates and parts prices etc.
In any market too much supply and too little demand - lowers prices and so buyers can pick and choose the best cars. There are now too many Porsche's in the older and cheaper end of the market for the number of serious buyers. There are still some seeking a particular car who will pay for the one they want (if it is in the condition they seek) but there are many other more speculative buyers just seeking a bargain sports car.
That is why for several years - we have only sold popular models in excellent condition, colours and specs - to preserve the value and that is why there are 2 markets emerging - top spec and condition popular cars still attracting good prices and all the others just simply selling on price. The difference between those two prices can be several thousands - even in the sub £20K bracket but - so the best advice to sell a car in the current market is - be realistic and decide which category your car is in and advertise accordingly.
High mileage, poor colour, weak history, poor spec, stone chipped, worn tyres, some faults, umpopular model = cheap concentrate on low price in advert - lower than similar cars already advertised. In contrast, low mileage, popular model, good colour, good history etc - explain all that in the advert, price accordingly and await interest or keep until there is some - as it will not depreciate as quickly as those at the cheaper end and will sell eventually.
All this has simply exagerated the old but true addage that to own a good Porsche with minimum depreciation ahead you have to find the right car and pay for it - bargains these days are hard to find and those that bought a cheapo will only suffer at the other end when it comes to selling again - perhaps even more so than before whereas those paying good money for a great car may even do better than before.
Hope that helped.
Baz
Every year Porsche sell more new cars than the old ones that get scrapped - so it is a growth market overall year on year.
For people wanting a new car - despite the increase in sales - the volume may only increase or decrease by a small amount each year compared to the previous year - so it may go up or down by say 5% OR 10%. But for old or second hand cars - it grows by the numbers sold the previous year every single year (except for the few that are scrapped) therefore may increase by say 90% of the new cars sales (just a guess to make the point - no lengthy inquisitions that go off the point please).
Consequently the number of cars at any one time in the used Porsche car market is relentlessly growing each year - and each year ALL the cars in that market are a year older - so eventually there are far more cars in every price bracket (under new car prices) and the older they get and the lower the price - the more of them at the lower end there are - and the numbers in say the £10K to £20K bracket increase enormously.
Previously there were a few 968's, 944 turbo's and 922 3.2 carerra's in that bracket - now there are also all models of Boxsters, 964's, 993's and even some 996's. The Boxster represented a lower price Porsche option new that the previous years models - so it enters that lower used car price bracket with all the other cars already there - sooner.
Many buyers in that market already own their dream Porsche and want to keep it for years - so the market for new buyers is relatively low. There is less movement in the market once someone owns their dream car - so the number seeking such a car lowers.
Furthermore the market for all cars has moved up a few years as the public have learned about the benefits of a newer car rather than an older one at current (and future) high labour repair rates and parts prices etc.
In any market too much supply and too little demand - lowers prices and so buyers can pick and choose the best cars. There are now too many Porsche's in the older and cheaper end of the market for the number of serious buyers. There are still some seeking a particular car who will pay for the one they want (if it is in the condition they seek) but there are many other more speculative buyers just seeking a bargain sports car.
That is why for several years - we have only sold popular models in excellent condition, colours and specs - to preserve the value and that is why there are 2 markets emerging - top spec and condition popular cars still attracting good prices and all the others just simply selling on price. The difference between those two prices can be several thousands - even in the sub £20K bracket but - so the best advice to sell a car in the current market is - be realistic and decide which category your car is in and advertise accordingly.
High mileage, poor colour, weak history, poor spec, stone chipped, worn tyres, some faults, umpopular model = cheap concentrate on low price in advert - lower than similar cars already advertised. In contrast, low mileage, popular model, good colour, good history etc - explain all that in the advert, price accordingly and await interest or keep until there is some - as it will not depreciate as quickly as those at the cheaper end and will sell eventually.
All this has simply exagerated the old but true addage that to own a good Porsche with minimum depreciation ahead you have to find the right car and pay for it - bargains these days are hard to find and those that bought a cheapo will only suffer at the other end when it comes to selling again - perhaps even more so than before whereas those paying good money for a great car may even do better than before.
Hope that helped.
Baz
Another important feature to buyers is whether the car is manual or tip - without description or interior pictures, unable to tell from the advert. Although this is easily checked by contacting the seller, it is an additional factor that a prospective buyer will be looking for whilst reviewing the classifieds. 

Mine's been up for a couple of weeks now on PH and Autotrader.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/221976.htm
Better spec than the OP's and only 9k miles, but 05 plate.
Had a few calls from people who'll get back to me at the weekend but don't.
It's £4 or £5k cheaper than lower spec cars at OPC's and the local indy, but just no punters with cash. Autotrader / top marques this weekend then I'll just keep it if it doesn't go.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/221976.htm
Better spec than the OP's and only 9k miles, but 05 plate.
Had a few calls from people who'll get back to me at the weekend but don't.
It's £4 or £5k cheaper than lower spec cars at OPC's and the local indy, but just no punters with cash. Autotrader / top marques this weekend then I'll just keep it if it doesn't go.
[quote=Wanta996(Gotta)]Also remember the competition nowadays, although there is more money around there is also more choice from BMW,Audi and Lotus BUT in that price bracket - your main rival maybe used 996's as i wanted a 987 to begin with BUT just couldnt pass by the thought of actually owning a 911.
[/quote]
Maybe, but as an enthusiast I personally didn't consider an older 911. Everyone that's phoned about mine doesn't have a clue, they just want something with a Porsche badge on it. I think I'm in competition with e.g. '07 plate 2.7 Boxsters.
[/quote]
Maybe, but as an enthusiast I personally didn't consider an older 911. Everyone that's phoned about mine doesn't have a clue, they just want something with a Porsche badge on it. I think I'm in competition with e.g. '07 plate 2.7 Boxsters.
[quote=Wanta996(Gotta)]Also remember the competition nowadays, although there is more money around there is also more choice from BMW,Audi and Lotus...
[/quote]
For some (i.e. those not determined solely on getting a Porsche), this will certainly be true... There is a HUGE market of possible alternative cars in the £20k to £30k bracket
[quote=Wanta996(Gotta)]... BUT in that price bracket - your main rival maybe used 996's as i wanted a 987 to begin with BUT just couldnt pass by the thought of actually owning a 911.
[/quote]
And that, for some, is a real pull on the heart - newer Boxster or older 911??!!
[/quote]
For some (i.e. those not determined solely on getting a Porsche), this will certainly be true... There is a HUGE market of possible alternative cars in the £20k to £30k bracket
[quote=Wanta996(Gotta)]... BUT in that price bracket - your main rival maybe used 996's as i wanted a 987 to begin with BUT just couldnt pass by the thought of actually owning a 911.
[/quote]
And that, for some, is a real pull on the heart - newer Boxster or older 911??!!
Workshy Fop said:
Maybe, but as an enthusiast I personally didn't consider an older 911. Everyone that's phoned about mine doesn't have a clue, they just want something with a Porsche badge on it. I think I'm in competition with e.g. '07 plate 2.7 Boxsters.
Why as an enthusiast didn't you consider a 911?A 911 will always be the enthusiasts choice (although the Cayman isn't bad).
Hi, I'm not personally in the market for a Boxster just now (although I think they are a great car, and great value) for 2 reasons:
1. Tried to persuade the wife to have one, but she insisted on an Audi A4 Cabriolet
2. I run a long term 993 and have no plans to part with it, so couldnt justify a 3rd car with the mileage we do these days.
HOWEVER
Does anyone realise the stupendous the value of 987 Boxsters (especially the 'S') are in todays market compared to a Cayman?
I think this is a blatant example of the general public being taken in by Porsches very clever marketing department! Porsche has always charged about 6k extra above the coupe for a 911 cabriolet - YET it takes the lid off the Boxster, gives it the name of a South American Lizard, and charges 5k more for it! And gets away with it!
Pure genius!
So, buy your Boxster now while prices are low!!!
1. Tried to persuade the wife to have one, but she insisted on an Audi A4 Cabriolet
2. I run a long term 993 and have no plans to part with it, so couldnt justify a 3rd car with the mileage we do these days.
HOWEVER
Does anyone realise the stupendous the value of 987 Boxsters (especially the 'S') are in todays market compared to a Cayman?
I think this is a blatant example of the general public being taken in by Porsches very clever marketing department! Porsche has always charged about 6k extra above the coupe for a 911 cabriolet - YET it takes the lid off the Boxster, gives it the name of a South American Lizard, and charges 5k more for it! And gets away with it!
Pure genius!
So, buy your Boxster now while prices are low!!!
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



