Which Classic Porsche?
Which Classic Porsche?
Author
Discussion

mph

Original Poster:

2,382 posts

313 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm looking to buy an air cooled 911.It won't be my only car although I intend to use it regularly.
Which model is likely to be the best investment ?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
mph said:
I'm looking to buy an air cooled 911.It won't be my only car although I intend to use it regularly.
Which model is likely to be the best investment ?
I would buy the best 993 you can find. Most modern car. Last of the air-cooled with that cachet. They will always be worth money (although I'd find it hard to call one an "investment"!) and also happen to be rather beautiful.

mr pg

2,068 posts

236 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
That would have to be a 964 then.

rubystone

11,254 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
mr pg said:
That would have to be a 964 then.
?


What's your budget? From the way prices seem to be going, a good spec G50 3.2 Carrera Coupe in a "safe" colour with sub 100k miles/few owners might be a safe-ish bet.


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
mph said:
use it regularly...best investment
if you use it regularly, realisticly, running costs will likely be more than any increase in value. by 'best' if you mean 'lose least' then i'd guess 964 - modern enough that its fast, reliable and spares easily available, old enough that nice ones are getting rare, cheapish parts and very cheap classic insurance. depends on budget i suppose

mph

Original Poster:

2,382 posts

313 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Budget max would be 35k.I would go more if I thought car was likely to appreciate. What about the Turbo/RS versions are they likely to become collectable in future?

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
35k? 993C2S?

ian964

534 posts

283 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
mph said:
Budget max would be 35k.I would go more if I thought car was likely to appreciate. What about the Turbo/RS versions are they likely to become collectable in future?
964RS are appreciating at the moment, but 35K probably not enough for a good one. You'd be looking at 40K+ for a straight, original LHD.

The rarer turbos (e.g. 964 Turbo 3.6) seem to be holding their value, but again looking at 40K+

seawise

2,284 posts

237 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
i'd buy the car that appeals most, rather than the one that will potentially appreciate most - however saying that my take on a classic aircooled 911 for occassional use is:

964 rs - lhd for yr budget, and it'll be a fairly well-used car unless yr willing to stretch to £40k - the prices seem quite toppy now, but demand remains strong on the continent so reckon it's a safe investment, as well as probably the most enjoyable car on this list to drive (imho).

993 turbo - great roadcar, not much cop on the track though. should be able to get a half decent rhd for 35-40k.

911 clubsport ('88-89) - another car that's shot up in value over the past 3 years, not that quick but quite special. safe long term bet, and u won't bore of it. actually i'd quite like one, the more i think about it.

964 turbo - sorry i've never driven one so can't comment.

911 2.4 s ('73) - this is a very old car now, not sure if it's really comparable to the above.

or, god forbid watercooled, how about a lhd mk1 996 gt3....

+

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
This is a HUGE subject! "Classic 911" covers everything from original '60s 911, through the 70's glory years, 80's middle age spread and 90's modernisation!

Personally I think the '72/73 2.4S is the best of the true classics, with it's light weight, quick handling, glorious high revving engine and timeless looks. Also has the most stylish interior with the original Recaros and superb dials. On a Sunday morning blast along a twisty country road, it's very hard to beat. Unfortunately for a buyer, people seem to have finally realised this and you've well and truly missed the boat as far as investment goes! You need around £50K to get a good LHD, £60K+ for RHD!! The nearest you'll get for your budget is the lower powered 2.4E, which to be fair is almost as good and a solid investment. You could also consider a 2.4S Targa or one of the very early impact bumper 2.7 Carreras (but the latter have also recently hiked in price)

Moving on a decade, the classic 3.2 Carrera is still great value for money at around £20-25K for a mint example. A bit softer and more civilised than the earlier cars, but still a proper 911. With £35K you could consider the Clubsport version too, which is rare and more collectable. But again, the prices have already risen, so I think the standard 3.2 is much better value now.

Into the 90's and 964 territory. I find the standard 964 boring both to look at and drive, sorry! On the plus side they're cheap. But the 964RS is a fantastic trackday car if you can put up with it's harsh ride on the road. I owned one for 5 years back in the day and found it exciting, but tedious on the road. So not a keeper for me. Prices are silly for the RS now too, especially since most have been heavily tracked.

The 993 has the cache of being the last air cooled 911, but I've never driven one, other than a quick blast in a Turbo, so wouldn't like to comment.

I haven't really mentioned Turbos in all this, but they're not really my thing. The original 930 Turbo is a quirky old beast, with it's lag, weight and 4-speed box, but some people love them. I never really got it myself. As mentioned above I had a quick go in a 993 Turbo and it was extremely fast and efficient, but nowhere near as involving as a 964RS. In fact that was the reason for the drive. A guy with a 993 Turbo wanted to buy my RS because he thought the Turbo was a bit too soft! We drove both back-to-back and he was right. The RS just felt more alive on the road. The only Turbo I might consider would be the 965, but that's mainly on looks, I've only had a very brief drive in one.

I've only dusted the surface, but I hope this helps a little. For £35K, I'd put it in a '73 2.4E. You'll get a proper classic 911 and won't lose a penny in the medium term. You'll at least cover your running expenses with appreciation too.


mph

Original Poster:

2,382 posts

313 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for all the advice so far - looks like I may have to increase my budget.
The only Porsche I have ever owned was a 996 and I have to say I found it rather bland, probaly wasn't helped that my previous car was a Tuscan! Anyway (like most of us I suspect) I have blown so much money on cars I'm trying to be a bit sensible and consider the resale value for a change.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
If resale value is important, I'd stick to the proper classics and rule out 964s and 993s. Prices of the earlier cars are definitely on the rise. As I mentioned a 2.4E would be a wise investment and should just fall within your £35K budget. Hardcore enthusiasts and collectors will always recognise the 2.4 as the definitive original 911, so its long term value is pretty well assured. Of course the 2.7RS stands out as a very special derivative of this car, hence the astronomical prices!

RT

919 posts

276 months

Thursday 4th October 2007
quotequote all
Tuscan and a 996 - I can understand why you're worried about depreciation!!

No-one has mentioned it yet, but I have a 930 (1988 911) turbo which has gone up in value in the past couple of years.

cheers

SEE YA

3,522 posts

276 months

Friday 5th October 2007
quotequote all
I have a 87 Model 911/930 black turbo seem to hold there money well between £15k-£20k .There not many good ones out there either I looked at 12 before my one .But you cannot put a price on the joy factor and every mile for me is a smile.

SEE YA

Lostusernamedamn

4,364 posts

237 months

Friday 5th October 2007
quotequote all
I think the wisest move, if you want to get in before the top of the "wave", i.e. before 964RS and 73 RS-style fever kicks in, is a late 993. Prices are firm and have remained pretty much so over roughly the last 5 years and I'm sure these are bound to start moving towards classic status, i.e will start rising. It shouldn't be too difficult to get a late one, though there do seem to have been a lot less over the last 6 months. A lot of the earlier model 911s have the "classic" price already built in (as you will see if you see how prices have risen over the last 5 to 10 years). However, they may of course carry on rising anyway.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 5th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm sure 993 prices will hold well, but I'd be surprised to see them rise for a long, long time. Still too many around. Great car though and shouldn't be much of a loss. If you look back on the value of classic Porsches, it's only relatively rare and desirable models that really rise in value eg. 2.7RS, 2.4S, 3.2 Clubsport, 964RS, 993RS. The standard cars tread water pretty well eg 3.2 Carerra, but haven't really risen much in value over the last 10 years. So I certainly wouldn't consider a standard 993 as an "investment", but it's not going to lose much either.

mph

Original Poster:

2,382 posts

313 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
There's a 1989 930Turbo LE with very low miles for sale at 911 Heaven (Burgundy)

http://www.911heaven.net/porschestock.php

Price seems a little on the high side but I would prefer a low mileage original car.

Can anyone offer advice/insight on the car or the dealer ?

Thanks

PH5121

2,007 posts

244 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
The dealer is Sambaman, who is a regular poster around these parts.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Bit of an acquired taste, but looks like it could be a good one. Hard to judge price on these, but I'd say it's not too far off the mark if it really is immaculate. A bit of a risky choice if you're worried about future resale. These are not particularly popular cars and this is priced largely on its low mileage and condition. So if you're planning to drive it much, it's likely to depreciate. But I suppose that's the downside of any very low mileage original. On the plus side, these things were astronomically expensive when new, so if it is your thing it could be a bargain!

Boo152

979 posts

230 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
mph said:
I'm looking to buy an air cooled 911.It won't be my only car although I intend to use it regularly.
Which model is likely to be the best investment ?
Most cars are not investments. Instead, they are a collection of consumable items that cost money to buy, run, and maintain, and which you will eventually sell for less than you paid for.

So rather than looking for an investment return, you should start by asking yourself some questions, to decide what you want the car for. For most people, if asked what their car means to them, answers would be as follows:

A) A convenient way of getting people and goods from A to B

B) A fashion Statement (designer gear) to make friends/neigbours/etc jealous

C) A magnificent obsession that you want to drive as often as you possibly can

For most of us on here, (C) would be the correct answer.
So, assuming you are the same, test drive all the models you can, then buy the one that you feel you can't live without.....