Sell my Exige & go 996?
Discussion
I've had my Exige for a few months & although it's good, it's not great in my eyes. Sure a great handling car & turns heads, but I feel it's missing something (although I don't know what).
Before I bought it I toyed with the idea of a 996 & now am thinking about them again.
I've got a budget of £22-£25k max. Either C2 or C4 manual (may consider Tiptronic if you provide positive comments). Not Cabrio, any ideas?
Seen the following on PH, any advice gratefully received.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/256912.htm
Before I bought it I toyed with the idea of a 996 & now am thinking about them again.
I've got a budget of £22-£25k max. Either C2 or C4 manual (may consider Tiptronic if you provide positive comments). Not Cabrio, any ideas?
Seen the following on PH, any advice gratefully received.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/256912.htm
Edited by Muz_Wez on Friday 5th October 08:38
Looks good for the price. I discovered following a Yellow 997 through Germany that a yellow Porsche is the best thing to get others out of your way in the fast lane.
Just makes sure you do your checks (Peter Morgan's 996 buying guide is a good starting point and well worth every penny) and get an OPC 111 point check done (about 130 GBP) and the porsche warrantee (895 per annum), available up to the car's 9th birthday and sounds you can't go wrong.
Def go for manual, coupe. Some say C2 is best driving experience, but the C4 is not far behind. Luggage space in the C4 is depleted due to transmission components in bottom of boot, but I'm sure that's not a concern if you're coming from an exige.
Just makes sure you do your checks (Peter Morgan's 996 buying guide is a good starting point and well worth every penny) and get an OPC 111 point check done (about 130 GBP) and the porsche warrantee (895 per annum), available up to the car's 9th birthday and sounds you can't go wrong.
Def go for manual, coupe. Some say C2 is best driving experience, but the C4 is not far behind. Luggage space in the C4 is depleted due to transmission components in bottom of boot, but I'm sure that's not a concern if you're coming from an exige.
OPC = Official Porsche Centre
Car check is usually 2 hours labour - about £250. If it passes it's £895 for cover.
www.petermorgan.org.uk A better inspection (and mobile too) as it will look at cosmetic condition and previous paintwork etc as well (OPCs care not about this, only about the bits they'll be at risk for on a warranty).
Car check is usually 2 hours labour - about £250. If it passes it's £895 for cover.
www.petermorgan.org.uk A better inspection (and mobile too) as it will look at cosmetic condition and previous paintwork etc as well (OPCs care not about this, only about the bits they'll be at risk for on a warranty).
Muz Wez - Sure a great handling car & turns heads, but I feel it's missing something (although I don't know what).
Unless its more comfort and practicality that you think is missing then stick with the Lotus.
P.S. Currently have a 2007 Boxster Tip courtesy as my 996 is in my local OPC and would personally not recommend it.
Unless its more comfort and practicality that you think is missing then stick with the Lotus.
P.S. Currently have a 2007 Boxster Tip courtesy as my 996 is in my local OPC and would personally not recommend it.
Edited by Wanta996(Gotta) on Friday 5th October 10:29
I'm toying between these two cars, love the Exige but the non-supercharged engine doesn't feel particularly special (apart from on cam!) and doesn't sound that great. With the 911 the engine is far superior IMO and it's so much more comfortable. I could easily justify having both cars in the garage if i could afford it!
I think you've almost hit the nail on the head! Yes the Exige it good, but you've got to work it a lot to keep it on the 2nd cam. I've even had the ECU upgrade on mine that both brings in the cam 500rpm lower & blends it better. However it still means revving between 5800 to 8000rpm all of the time to press on or get the best from the car. This makes it sound like you're thrashing the car all the time even though you not! I think I'm after a car that offers good performance without it having to be worked so hard all the time. Some of this comes from the fact that as you have to work the car hard, it also means that you're working hard & at times you want a more relaxed drive, but still with the performance which is a combination I haven't found yet with the Exige.
MD San said:
I'm toying between these two cars, love the Exige but the non-supercharged engine doesn't feel particularly special (apart from on cam!) and doesn't sound that great. With the 911 the engine is far superior IMO and it's so much more comfortable. I could easily justify having both cars in the garage if i could afford it!
Yep, I thought that. But hey if he's a to**er then perhaps I might be able offer him some fine wines & Belgiums choclates for him to pass onto his ladies & get the car a bit cheaper?!?!?
TTTurbo said:
My only proble is with all the bullshit the guys is talking about women.
FFs who is he fooling , they were probably laughing
FFs who is he fooling , they were probably laughing
Muz_Wez said:
I've had my Exige for a few months & although it's good, it's not great in my eyes. Sure a great handling car & turns heads, but I feel it's missing something (although I don't know what).
Before I bought it I toyed with the idea of a 996 & now am thinking about them again.
I've got a budget of £22-£25k max. Either C2 or C4 manual (may consider Tiptronic if you provide positive comments). Not Cabrio, any ideas?
Seen the following on PH, any advice gratefully received.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/256912.htm
Buy mine.Before I bought it I toyed with the idea of a 996 & now am thinking about them again.
I've got a budget of £22-£25k max. Either C2 or C4 manual (may consider Tiptronic if you provide positive comments). Not Cabrio, any ideas?
Seen the following on PH, any advice gratefully received.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/256912.htm
Edited by Muz_Wez on Friday 5th October 08:38
Muz_Wez said:
I've had my Exige for a few months & although it's good, it's not great in my eyes. Sure a great handling car & turns heads, but I feel it's missing something (although I don't know what).
Before I bought it I toyed with the idea of a 996 & now am thinking about them again.
I've got a budget of £22-£25k max. Either C2 or C4 manual (may consider Tiptronic if you provide positive comments). Not Cabrio, any ideas?
Seen the following on PH, any advice gratefully received.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/256912.htm
Nothing wrong with a 22k 996 - mine was fantastic (still miss it), great fun when you needed and practical and sensible when that was required.Before I bought it I toyed with the idea of a 996 & now am thinking about them again.
I've got a budget of £22-£25k max. Either C2 or C4 manual (may consider Tiptronic if you provide positive comments). Not Cabrio, any ideas?
Seen the following on PH, any advice gratefully received.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/256912.htm
Edited by Muz_Wez on Friday 5th October 08:38
Depending on where in Wilts that car is, I can give it a once over for you if your genuinely interested - to save you a long journey for a dog

Though the seller does sound a knob

Muz_Wez said:
I think you've almost hit the nail on the head! Yes the Exige it good, but you've got to work it a lot to keep it on the 2nd cam. I've even had the ECU upgrade on mine that both brings in the cam 500rpm lower & blends it better. However it still means revving between 5800 to 8000rpm all of the time to press on or get the best from the car. This makes it sound like you're thrashing the car all the time even though you not! I think I'm after a car that offers good performance without it having to be worked so hard all the time. Some of this comes from the fact that as you have to work the car hard, it also means that you're working hard & at times you want a more relaxed drive, but still with the performance which is a combination I haven't found yet with the Exige.
If you're problem is with the Exige's performance then a 3.4 996 might not be the cure as I don't find mine all that quick and needs revving to get the best out of it. Yes, of course, it's a lot better than the peaky Exige but it doesn't haul from lower revs with the conviction I expected, I think it's the long gearing that causes this.You'll also be sacrificing the steering feel and handling compared to an Exige, mine is on standard susp and wallows a fair bit when pressing on.
On the plus side, it's a lot more practical (esp the C2) and sounds nicer than an Exige ever will!
Agree with Chris - An exige accelerates to 60 quicker and i guess to 100 almost equally to a 3.4 996 and i gaurantee the Exige will feel quicker - Its after 120mph that a Porsche comes into its zone. Like i have said, if you want comfort and practicality - buy the Porsche, if you want drama and sense of occasion when driving on more demanding roads - Keep the Exige.
Try and take a 911 out on a longer test drive and you will be suprised with how normal it feels BUT maybe you like normal. Dont get me wrong, they are great cars but i will defineatly be changing next year due to as you put it - something missing.
Try and take a 911 out on a longer test drive and you will be suprised with how normal it feels BUT maybe you like normal. Dont get me wrong, they are great cars but i will defineatly be changing next year due to as you put it - something missing.
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




