well, i finally went and drove one
well, i finally went and drove one
Author
Discussion

kryten

Original Poster:

597 posts

256 months

Friday 5th October 2007
quotequote all
Beautiful day on Thursday so went and had a drive of a 2004 996 Carrera 4 a local independant dealer had in.

I've held off posting this whilst I reconsider my opinion but <flameproof suit on> ...

I was quite unimpressed to be honest. It was a lovely car but wasn't really any fun to drive and didn't even really feel that quick. I'm sure it was certainly a car you could go very fast in but there was no impression of speed and it didn't seem that responsive to steering or throttle inputs. Don't really know what else to say but it just didn't grab me as a driving experience.

Now, I'm somewhat spoilt by currently having a 2001 S2 Elise which is wonderful but what I can't get over is the fact I was in a 911 and it just didn't feel at all special.

The only 911 I've driven before was a GT3 on track a couple of years back and it felt _so_ good but the C4 just didn't impress in the same way.

So, was it a 'bad-un' or am I expecting too much of the non GT versions?

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Nope ... sounds about right


boxedin

turbo-ww

1,766 posts

247 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Meethinks the Elise is a more extreme vehicle than a 'cooking' 996 - Maybe it depends on your expectations.


turbo-ww

1,766 posts

247 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Sorry I didn't mean that to be as patronising as it looks.

When I was looking for the 964 (Turbo) replacement the general consencus was that if you want a daily driver take the 996, if you want more involving drive, take the 993.

Lights blue touchpaper and retires...................

baptist

632 posts

287 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Was it just a 4, or a 4S?
If its just a 4, you are driving the least powerful engine hooked upto a 4 wheel drive system. Its not going to be the quickest 911 ever.

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
baptist said:
Was it just a 4, or a 4S?
If its just a 4, you are driving the least powerful engine hooked upto a 4 wheel drive system. Its not going to be the quickest 911 ever.
Not so .. The 4S has the same engine ... Heavier car.

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Try a C2, ideally with PSE, and perhaps sport suspension - should be lighter, quicker, more informative, and great noise.

Catherine197

9,586 posts

274 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
I drove a 997 CS Covertable when we bought the Boxster last year.

It was part of their test drive plus programme where you go out with a driving instructor, in my case it was Dicky Attwood. I have to say I also was totally underwelmed and at £80k including all the options on it, I felt that just wasn't right.

Interestingly enough Dicky Attwood's ideal Porsche would have been a 2.7 Boxster with the smallest possible wheels and as few extras as possible.

Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Catherine197 said:
Interestingly enough Dicky Attwood's ideal Porsche would have been a 2.7 Boxster with the smallest possible wheels and as few extras as possible.
I drove a 997 C4 as was more than underwhelmed. In my view the 911 is the car for the "I've got 80K + to spend and want to advertise it" bracket.

The 997 comes alive when you press on and you are in licence losing territory. Dicky Attwood's comments further underline my opinion that its not the drivers car in the porsche range. Boxster/Cayman is now more "Porsche" than 996/997.

I'd try a Boxster S 986 or 987. Coming from the Elise, you may prefer the 986 as its slightly more "raw".

FLAME_ON

pishflapsh

68,496 posts

241 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Catherine197 said:
Interestingly enough Dicky Attwood's ideal Porsche would have been a 2.7 Boxster with the smallest possible wheels and as few extras as possible.
I'll remember that next time someone says I've got a poverty spec car smile

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Flame suit firmly zipped up - Try a 993 it just oozes character and will provide feedback that has been Engineered out of a 996.

pp

chinoloco

88 posts

233 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
i felt same way when i looked at 996s. bought a 993, still feels special every time i get in it and when you press on it feels like its wrapped round you.

baptist

632 posts

287 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
Ive got a 4S, and the engine isnt the same as the C4.

Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
baptist said:
Was it just a 4, or a 4S?
If its just a 4, you are driving the least powerful engine hooked upto a 4 wheel drive system. Its not going to be the quickest 911 ever.
They all have exactly the same 2450kw engines. There was an optional power upgrade to 254kw, available on all models. And the C4 Anniversary had a power upgrade.

Subjectively, the Porsche Sports Exhaust system does make the 996s appear faster.

IMO, though, coming from an Elise, only a GT3 will replicate that special 'feel' - brilliant chassis, steering and the fantastic GT1 derived engine.

baptist

632 posts

287 months

Saturday 6th October 2007
quotequote all
You learn something everyday!
I just assumed it would be like the 997 range, where the S models had a different engine.
smile

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Sunday 7th October 2007
quotequote all
It's a funny one to quantify, this.
My 996 C4s doesn't feel that fast to me. The problem is i'm used to 1000 cc superbikes. So when I bought my car, on the drive home, I was a little disappointed. I would describe it as 'sprightly' with 'useable power' but no more.
However, some days it feels lacking, other days, it surprises me.
For example, i'm giving it beans down an 'A' road. I come to a corner, brake, power on through the turn, and find myself pinning the pedal quite early, then saying out loud 'come on, come on!'
But then sometimes, i'm doing .8 or .9 leptons on the motorway, and just for the hell of it, drop it down 2 and boot it, and it accelerates from .8 leptons with real vigour to license losing speeds in the blink of an eye, and I think, actually, it's not too bad after all.
Personally, I would have lower gearing throughout, as it tops at 1.75 leptons, which is pointless really. I would gear it to top at about 1.4 to 1.5 and enjoy the brisker acceleration on 'A' roads.

HTH


kryten

Original Poster:

597 posts

256 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. My only real concern with getting a 993 is I can't get a porsche warranty on it, whereas I can with a 996.

Think I need to be looking at gt3 or turbo 996 or some sort of 993 though...



Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
Listen, i aggree with your thoughts on the 996 when comparing it to an Elise, they do seem very normal - i comapare them to a fast 3 series to be honest but a 993 is not the answer either. They are strange cars wich in my opinion only come into there own after 100 mph.

Just noticed Ray-Luxurys comments - That is exactlt how i feel with the C4S. GT3 or a TT is the way to go and thats where i will be heading next year. Good car but not a great car.

Edited by Wanta996(Gotta) on Wednesday 10th October 15:32

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
You need a turbo if you want fast. Or a GT2. I happen to have a GT2 for sale at a sensational price...

SM

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
supermono said:
You need a turbo if you want fast. Or a GT2. I happen to have a GT2 for sale at a sensational price...

SM
Selling again so soon?