Is the 996 911 a 'Supercar'??
Discussion
I had a heated discussion with a friend of mine recently.
He maintaines that a 996 911 is not a supercar and could only be called a sports coupe. His theory is that it is too practical to be called a supercar and that it also doesnt cost enough to be classed as a supercar.
Mine is an 'entry' level 996 C2 and only cost mid £30's so apparently that could never be classed as a supercar. He said that the only one that could ever be called a supercar is the TT (and only a maybe on that one).
To be honest I argued with him because it was fun (especially over a beer!!) but to be totally honest I am not sure myself!
So what are your thoughts??
He maintaines that a 996 911 is not a supercar and could only be called a sports coupe. His theory is that it is too practical to be called a supercar and that it also doesnt cost enough to be classed as a supercar.
Mine is an 'entry' level 996 C2 and only cost mid £30's so apparently that could never be classed as a supercar. He said that the only one that could ever be called a supercar is the TT (and only a maybe on that one).
To be honest I argued with him because it was fun (especially over a beer!!) but to be totally honest I am not sure myself!
So what are your thoughts??
Having owned one your friend is right. The 911 is almost where a 3 series coupe was 6 years ago....a premium product from an aspirational brand.
Remember, the sticker price on a 911 has hardly changed in 20 years!
The TT just about makes it.
For supercar I would read Lambo, Murci or above, Fezza (anything other than 360, Carrera GT.
Edited to add - FLAME SUIT ON
Further edited - 993 - Supercar for beardies
Remember, the sticker price on a 911 has hardly changed in 20 years!
The TT just about makes it.
For supercar I would read Lambo, Murci or above, Fezza (anything other than 360, Carrera GT.
Edited to add - FLAME SUIT ON
Further edited - 993 - Supercar for beardies
Edited by Irish on Tuesday 9th October 08:15
Edited by Irish on Tuesday 9th October 08:15
I don't think the 911 is a supercar, but i think its a better car than many of those mentioned.
F'rinstance I think a Zonda is a fantastic looking machine, a wonderful device to make a statement about yourself in somewhere like Monte Carlo. But would a Zonda be as much fun as a 911 up in the hills above Monte? I don't think so.
And of course the 911 has history and heritage associated with those hills above Monte, something like Zonda and Lambo will never have.
F'rinstance I think a Zonda is a fantastic looking machine, a wonderful device to make a statement about yourself in somewhere like Monte Carlo. But would a Zonda be as much fun as a 911 up in the hills above Monte? I don't think so.
And of course the 911 has history and heritage associated with those hills above Monte, something like Zonda and Lambo will never have.
For many years the 911 has been described as a 'junior supercar'.
Maybe familiarity has diluted the image, but I would say that the TTs, GT2s and GT3s are up there with the Gallardo, F430, AMs, etc, and 'Junior Supercar' is an apt category.
Something like the Veyron is in a league of its own.
Maybe familiarity has diluted the image, but I would say that the TTs, GT2s and GT3s are up there with the Gallardo, F430, AMs, etc, and 'Junior Supercar' is an apt category.
Something like the Veyron is in a league of its own.
So the £24k 996s you find on Autotrader are regarded as Supercars to some? I drive a 996 C4S and i personally do not regard it as a supercar. For me, 360's and Gallardos dont even make it into supercar territory never mind 993s and 996s(No matter which varient).
Murci's,Carrera Gts's,Enzo's,SLR's are Supercars.Old school super cars were the 512TR,Diablo,Countach,959,XJ220,Mclaren F1,F40's.
Murci's,Carrera Gts's,Enzo's,SLR's are Supercars.Old school super cars were the 512TR,Diablo,Countach,959,XJ220,Mclaren F1,F40's.
I would disagree with the GT3/TT etc being a supercar, the carrera GT is Porsches 'current' supercar -i would also say the 959 was their supercar and even that le mans replica thing they did (GT 1?)
A supercar is not just about 'performance' otherwise shirley the top caterhams/ariel atom would be classed as supercars - it is about exclusivity, drama, 'looks' even... A supercar would be the sports car manufacturers flagship car though not every manufacturers flagship is a supercar (i.e. BMW M6 is not a supercar)
Modern design does blur the lines somewhat, im not convinced a 599 is a true 'supercar' perhaps because of its GT styling or perhaps the presence of the Enzo as Ferraris true supercar 'demotes' the 599 somehow?
A supercar is not just about 'performance' otherwise shirley the top caterhams/ariel atom would be classed as supercars - it is about exclusivity, drama, 'looks' even... A supercar would be the sports car manufacturers flagship car though not every manufacturers flagship is a supercar (i.e. BMW M6 is not a supercar)
Modern design does blur the lines somewhat, im not convinced a 599 is a true 'supercar' perhaps because of its GT styling or perhaps the presence of the Enzo as Ferraris true supercar 'demotes' the 599 somehow?
Edited by Mattmeister on Tuesday 9th October 11:00
MaxAndRuby said:
I think that Evo's definitions are spot on.
Sports Coupes :
Carrera
Carrera S
Supercars :
GT2
GT3
Turbo
CGT
I'd go along with that, but then there is a class above that with the 'mega-cars'.Sports Coupes :
Carrera
Carrera S
Supercars :
GT2
GT3
Turbo
CGT
Suppose the benchmark is always moving. There was a time when a £1 million made you one of the 'super-rich'

Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



