944 Decision HELP!!
944 Decision HELP!!
Author
Discussion

andymg

Original Poster:

266 posts

244 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi All,

I have searched the other threads for definitive views on this but they all seem to spiral into the old 968/944 debate.

By April, I will have around £5,000 - 5,500 to throw at 944, I have been hankering after one for years and my heart is completely set, all I need to know is what model to go for.

I know that I want a post 1986 model as the old 924 dash looks horrid IMO, but thats where it all gets muddled. I hear that the 1989 2.7 engine is much stronger but with a 0-60 of 7.5, it really is not much quicker than my current car (albeit much better looking wink )

There seems to be conflicting advise as to which is the best N/A model. I would obviously love a 951 but I fear running costs/ insurance would render me bankrupt - feel free to correct me though!

So that leaves me the 2.5 8v, the 2.7, the 'S' 2.5 16v and the S2.
I've read about the early 944 S models having timing problems and generally being troublesome so that may well be out.

I am only 22 and can budget £4,000 running costs per year of which I hope will be feasible, I just need to know what model will pose the least problems and what offers the best overall driving experience.

Any past experinces/info would be great!

Cheers all,

Andy

pips1970

57 posts

240 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
type

Hi Andy

I own an early 944 1983 with the old stlye dash, people hold differing views on that or the newer oval dash, personally i like mine.
Your purchase budget would probably buy you a resonable 944 & your running cost budget sounds ok as well.
Look at as many as you can before you decide on the one for you, when i bought mine, she was immaculate inside apart from the usual dash splits, but you will be hard pushed to find a 944 with a near perfect dash.
Test drive & look for the dreaded blue smoke, rev the engine over 4,000rpm & check the rear view mirror.
When you find the one, you will know & enjoy her, they are an 80`s classic.

Good Luck

Pip

driving

iguana

7,368 posts

291 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
That budget would get the nicest 2.5 lux in the world, can get decent ones for half that, ive had 2.5 lux, S2, 220 Turbo & 250 Turbo all for within your budget, not minters but solid cars, well except for the 220 but £2k for a 944t & 200+k miles on the clock what did I expect biggrin

Personally I love the early lux dash but maybe im odd.

For your budget I'd go straight to a decent S2, but a 2.5 lux, especially an early car has a special someting the other 944 models- despite all being quicker, just dont have (early 944 lighter too)

pcn1

1,346 posts

250 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Your budget should buy a nice S2. I have spent about £1.5K in running costs over 2 years, but thats all my own spanner work !

PH5121

2,007 posts

244 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
I would get the S2, as my S2 was a great car, being both practical and quick.
The 2.5/2.7 are finely balanced cars, but the extra oomph of the S2 is nice to have for overtaking manouvres and will do 150mph.

lanesra10

314 posts

262 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
At your age you need to check out your insurance costs for the respective cars as this could effect your choices.

With an allowance of £4k for running costs you can buy a £4/5k Turbo which I did in May but I spent £2k on maintenance(cambelt, water pump etc) and paintwork to bring it up scratch i.e total £6.5k.

Personally I would spend the money on a decent S2 c £4k thats had its belts done and your running costs should be under £1k pa, mine averaged £600 pa over 4 years inc tyres.

With most of the 944 even if an engine went you can source replcements under a grand so you should never need to spend £4k pa on running costs unless the insuarnce is £2k+

ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
hi there, most of the lads have just given some sound advice especially lansera. i own a s2 944 turbo on the last of the 1991 j plates and its kept me more than happy. you will definately get a nice s2 with your budget. like lansera said try an get one thats had the cam belts and balance belts done and make sure u check the diff for whining noises. i think u might be able to geta decentish 944 turbo s2, but like the lads said check the insurance first. maybe with limited mileage u could qualify for classic car insurance,,save u a hell lot of money. HEGARTY, and also Footman james do good quotes. good luck.

JED944

12 posts

233 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
Looks like the overwhelming concensus is for a decent S2. I paid just over £5k for a nice example about 8 months ago. Mine's a weekend car so I my running costs will be relatively modest, but I did take it to Hartech for a 24,000 miler. I had them take the head off and look at the cams etc. Apparently there is no published wear limits on the cam sprockets, so it's a matter of experience and judgement. They advised me that mine were probably at their limit so I had them changed (plus chain, cam belt and so on) That set me back £1,800 in total. The design at the top end of the engine, i.e. with chain which links the two cams together seems to be a difinite weakness that you need to make sure you have covered off. Hartech showed me one camshat that had only 3 teeth left on it, but the engine was still running! The other weak area (but this may be true of other 944's) is the brake calipers. They are of alloy construction, but have a steel 'lift plate' on them which, over time, reacts with the alloy. My rear calipers will need changing before the next MOT and that, along with discs and brake hoses, is likely to come to about £1,200.

I regard it as coming with the territory. All this notwithstanding, the car is still putting out 212bhp (109,000 miles) and slightly above factory spec torque figures.... no mods on the engine. The chassis is sublime and so controllable and can handle way more power. The 16" wheels really need to be uprated to 17" and the tyre profile lowered. The ride will get a little harsher, but the increased stiffness of the tyre wall should sharpen the handling up.

Make sure whatever you buy has lots of hitory (preferably main dealer, but specialist is still good) and go for something that has had as much work done on the top of the engine as possible and as recently as possible.... by a reputable garage.

Hope this helps. Anyone with differing views (or better technical knowledge) feel free to correct me. smile

andymg

Original Poster:

266 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
Thats a great help guys, thanks alot.

It appears I can insure it on a limited mileage classic car policy, for around £1,200 so it all looks very possible.

Even though I wont be looking to buy this year, I think i'll start poking around at a few.

Now i'm excited...........


ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
£1200 pound for limited mileage on classic insurance seems a bit high ..did u try the companies i listed for you. if u doing less than 2000 miles it should be lot more less than that. recheck if i were you.

Li Moo Bai

847 posts

236 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
If you sign up with a club i.e. PCGB or TIPEC, many modern classic insurers will give you a 10% or so discount on your premium - a no brainer really as the cost of membership is £40 to £50 at present, and you then get all the attendent club discounts too smile

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm agreeing with an S2.
My 944 is older, and slower, but it's such a joy to drive. Sometimes I go around corners with so much grip balance and speed that I just giggle to myself.

alanruss

1,138 posts

257 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
JED944 said:
My rear calipers will need changing before the next MOT and that, along with discs and brake hoses, is likely to come to about £1,200.

...

Hope this helps. Anyone with differing views (or better technical knowledge) feel free to correct me. smile
Good advice.. although eek £1200! I did mine myself for under £200 from the Haynes Manual with recon calipers and new everything else from GSF. I am well up for spending money on paintwork or engine stuff I can't do myself, but £1200 bought my whole car!

Not a criticism at all though, hats off to you keeping classics on the road this way. For me that would be like pissing a kidney stone. wink

Oh and insurance (in sleepy Berks where its stored) for me is £190-odd with Peter Best ( I am a TIPEC member), try them out..

[edited to add insurance]

Edited by alanruss on Wednesday 10th October 16:04

Hammerwerfer

3,234 posts

271 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
Go for a turbo. You can easily turn up the wick if you get tired of 220 or 250 HP. It's virtually impossible to get anything more out of the naturally aspirated ones for reasonable outlay.

softinthehead

1,550 posts

270 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all
if getting a car significantly quicker than your current one is a consideration then you can rule out three of your four options immediately since the 2.5, 2.5 16v and 2.7 have virtually identical 0-60 times. however, given the age of the cars, how it has been cared for will be a far greater determinant of the percentage of original bhp left than the factory stats.

availability is also an issue. lots of very tired S2 about but also plenty of good ones. you would have a harder job sourcing a really good 2.5 simply cos they are so much older.

and the 2.7 was manufactured for a relatively limited time so again hard to get a good one.

Power delivery may be a consideration. Though on paper the 2.5 and 2.7 have virtually the same performance, the 2.7 IMHO was much more torquey low down, and so much more fun as a daily drive. all very well talking about 150mph top speed but really, when could you? a little extra away fro the lights would be a bigger selling point for me.

just some random thoughts but S2 seems far and away the best option for you. but i would be happy with any of them if i found a minter

RatLad

Original Poster:

266 posts

244 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Looks like it is definitely going to be an S2 then. I'll hunt for for insurance but what is worrying me slightly still is that I am inexperienced with these cars and really dont want to buy a pup.

I now know i'll be looking at the top end of the market at one that has been well cared for with full Porsche or specialist history but there must be some on here that have needed help with viewing possible purchases.

This will be the first car I will have bought that is not for 'throwaway' money thus really dont want to get it wrong. Is their any safeguards against this to check the major mechanical condition of the car. Would an AA or RAC check suffice?

(I am the orgional OP incase you're wondering, Ive just changed my name as I hopefully wont have an MG for much longer smile )

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Hammerwerfer said:
Go for a turbo. You can easily turn up the wick if you get tired of 220 or 250 HP. It's virtually impossible to get anything more out of the naturally aspirated ones for reasonable outlay.
This could be sound advice. The usual line is that you buy an S2 if you want a rapid car that is good to drive all the time but that can't really be modified. Buy a turbo if you have more money and are looking at modifying it. A stock turbo isn't that good to drive - the 220's are better than the 250's, but they have huge turbo lag and are hard to drive on the limit because they are a little unpredictable. (A stock turbo of either flavour is no quicker than an S2 in real driving.) BUT either variety of turbo allows HUGE scope in terms of tuning, and can be made to go very very fast indeed (if you have the cash!)

Having said all that, your budget would get you into a good S2 but a slightly chance-y Turbo, so an S2 could be the better bet.

FWIW, I bought my S2 18 months ago for well within your budget and have loved every mile since. Last weekend it made an impressive 219.6bhp on the Weltmeister Rollers of Truth, and is better to drive than ever ... look at my profile for more info.


Oli.

RatLad

Original Poster:

266 posts

244 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
zcacogp said:
Hammerwerfer said:
Go for a turbo. You can easily turn up the wick if you get tired of 220 or 250 HP. It's virtually impossible to get anything more out of the naturally aspirated ones for reasonable outlay.
This could be sound advice. The usual line is that you buy an S2 if you want a rapid car that is good to drive all the time but that can't really be modified. Buy a turbo if you have more money and are looking at modifying it. A stock turbo isn't that good to drive - the 220's are better than the 250's, but they have huge turbo lag and are hard to drive on the limit because they are a little unpredictable. (A stock turbo of either flavour is no quicker than an S2 in real driving.) BUT either variety of turbo allows HUGE scope in terms of tuning, and can be made to go very very fast indeed (if you have the cash!)

Having said all that, your budget would get you into a good S2 but a slightly chance-y Turbo, so an S2 could be the better bet.

FWIW, I bought my S2 18 months ago for well within your budget and have loved every mile since. Last weekend it made an impressive 219.6bhp on the Weltmeister Rollers of Truth, and is better to drive than ever ... look at my profile for more info.


Oli.
Sadly, I think the 944 turbos ability would seriously outweigh mine. Going from a convertible Metro into something that falls under pretty much 'supercar' classification would have be hunting hedges within the few corners.

Dont get me wrong I yearn for performance like that but at my age I dont think i'm quite ready for it. Definitely something to work up to after the S2.

Edited by RatLad on Thursday 11th October 15:05

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
RatLad,

The jump from Metro to S2 is going to be pretty big, but it's not that easy to lose it in a 944, you'll be glad to hear. They are MUCH more stable than an equivalent 911, although you do need to exercise some respect on wet roads and in icy conditions.

Having said that, the jump from Metro to S2 will be huge, the jump from S2 to Turbo quite small by comparison ...


Oli.