Audi R8 the New Boy?
Audi R8 the New Boy?
Author
Discussion

carreraboy

Original Poster:

826 posts

249 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
R8 V 997C2/4S/GT3... What do you think? Top Gear this Sunday 14th October...

Edited by carreraboy on Friday 12th October 22:31

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
I think the R8 is in a different category to the C2 and the c4s. Having seen one in th emetal recently, looks wise it is on par with a Gallardo. Performance-wise it will probably out do a std C2 or C4S - the GT3 will probab;yu out do it - but it depends on your needs.

They are overpriced for an 'Audi' though a great car.

Big Brin

529 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Tiff Niddell tested the R8 vs the 997 C4S and couldn't get a feeler gauge between them. They are very closely matched.....

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
I bow to Tiff's comments. For the money, I'd rather have a used Gallard- - or a MK1 GT3 and £45k change!!

Big Brin

529 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Gallardo vs R8? Gallardo any time, every time...... cloud9

Boo152

979 posts

230 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
The R8 does look brilliant in the metal though don't you think?
Be interesting to see how the prices hold when the novelty wears off.

AND remember both the Lambo and the Audi are made by Audi....

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
johnfm said:
I think the R8 is in a different category to the C2 and the c4s. Having seen one in th emetal recently, looks wise it is on par with a Gallardo. Performance-wise it will probably out do a std C2 or C4S - the GT3 will probab;yu out do it - but it depends on your needs.

They are overpriced for an 'Audi' though a great car.
I always like the its 'overpriced for an Audi" comment..surely with the massive amount of 997's produced the term should be its "overpriced for a Porsche now they are so common".No-one seems to comment on how expensive Porsches are considering there are hundreds kicking about on the roads and hardly a rare commodity..i suppose the poor second hand values of 997's is showing how over-priced these cars are new relative to their exclusivity.

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Fantastic cars - on a different level to all 997's bar the TT/GT2. The 5th Gear test was againt a 997S Powerpack model. Nearly every motoring publication has had the R8 winning against anything that its come up against. Great car but fully specced can touch £90k.

The R10 will be released early next year so i guess this will affect the current R8's used values.

968CSReading

3,088 posts

249 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Parked next to one last week, looks amazing, much more presence that a 997. Sounded awesome when he started up and LED Day lights look good.


Koln-RS

4,129 posts

243 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Agree, the R8 is another challenge to Porsche, but this is nothing new - remember how everyone predicted the Honda NSX would end the 911's dominance?

This sector is now a big market, and there is no doubt that the R8 will attract some people away from Porsche, if only because it is the latest, headline grabbing, new kid on the block.

But it won't appeal to many traditional 911 buyers, who prefer the 911's lineage and practicality, and don't want a mid-engine 2-seater, don't want 4-wheel drive, don't want the ubiquitous Audi badge, etc.

Looks are personal. I think the R8 looks striking, but a bit too contrived. Still prefer the 'classic' 911 shape.

Whilst it might match the basic 997s in performance, it would struggle against the GT3 and TT. And, remember, Porsche never stand still, they will be plotting for the future....


968CSReading

3,088 posts

249 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
I think Audi have done pretty well on the first attempt though.

You say Porsche dont stand still but how long can they go on producing a car whose looks date back so far (stands back and waits for the abuse). The tradional Porsche fan will stay loyal but can they go on for so long with the same format, espicially with the Gallardo and the new baby Fezza coming along.

I guess many non enthusiasts buy a Porsche because of the name but maybe they should start to be a little more daring on the looks department.

(After all, a GT3 cant keep up with a 968, let alone an R8)boxedin

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Most cars with ultra-contemporary styling date very quickly. Much like modern furniture. Porsche are conservative on styling, but the cars look great for many years. The original 911 is a styling masterpiece, completely timeless. I like the Audi, but I suspect it's more a car for the moment.

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Porsche are conservative on styling?

GT3,GT3RS,GT2 conservative in styling.scratchchin

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
[quote=Wanta996(Gotta)]Porsche are conservative on styling?

GT3,GT3RS,GT2 conservative in styling.scratchchin
[/quote]

You're confusing bright colours and add-on bodykits with styling. The underlying car still has quite conservative styling.

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
I think 911 styling,especially 997 is still superb and imo makes the R8 look over-styled for the sake of it.Having said that ive seen so many 997's on the road that i dont even bother to look at them anymore..

Ultra Violent

2,827 posts

300 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Was considering the R8 against a Gallardo. Spent some time looking over an R8 and it did absolutely nothing for me. It looks like a cut and shut job. As if another car fell of a transporter at 30deg angle and fused with the front of just about any other Audi in the range. I have no doubt it handles well but fully expect it to have the same fate as the Audi TT, VW Phaeton, there just isn't the pedigree.

So in the end I went for the Gallardo and very glad I did.

PolarExpress

6,796 posts

258 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
kayc said:
johnfm said:
They are overpriced for an 'Audi' though a great car.
I always like the its 'overpriced for an Audi" comment..surely with the massive amount of 997's produced the term should be its "overpriced for a Porsche now they are so common".No-one seems to comment on how expensive Porsches are considering there are hundreds kicking about on the roads and hardly a rare commodity..i suppose the poor second hand values of 997's is showing how over-priced these cars are new relative to their exclusivity.
Today, Audi is commonly known for their 1.9TDi A3/4 or maybe TT (sometimes Quattro). (sadly no longer their S1 Quattro)
Porsche is commonly known for the 911.

About £55k difference between the 2.
==> yes, the R8 is an overpriced Audi.

For the money, a used Gallardo every day.

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
PolarExpress said:
kayc said:
johnfm said:
They are overpriced for an 'Audi' though a great car.
I always like the its 'overpriced for an Audi" comment..surely with the massive amount of 997's produced the term should be its "overpriced for a Porsche now they are so common".No-one seems to comment on how expensive Porsches are considering there are hundreds kicking about on the roads and hardly a rare commodity..i suppose the poor second hand values of 997's is showing how over-priced these cars are new relative to their exclusivity.
Today, Audi is commonly known for their 1.9TDi A3/4 or maybe TT (sometimes Quattro). (sadly no longer their S1 Quattro)
Porsche is commonly known for the 911.

About £55k difference between the 2.
==> yes, the R8 is an overpriced Audi.

For the money, a used Gallardo every day.
Gallardo?Also an Audi.I think you may find that apart from on so-called enthusiast Porsche forums Porsche is now more known for the Cayenne and boxster.

Edited by kayc on Friday 12th October 11:28

K Man S

175 posts

241 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
Perhaps the VAG should have put a Bugatti badge on it and charged £150k phone

trackdemon

13,494 posts

292 months

Friday 12th October 2007
quotequote all
carreraboy said:
R8 V 997C2/4S/GT3... What do you think?
Having just spent a very enjoyable 300miles in an R8 on some great roads, would have to say that the R8 has the crown as an all rounder (ie what the 911 has always been great at) with the caveat that the 911's rear seats are surplus for most. For a Sunday morning blast, GT3.

I hope the R8 does suffer the same depreciation as the NSX did - 4 year old, 30k miler sitting in the garage @ £40k? Deal!!!