DRT - Cayman S with LSD or 996 RS
DRT - Cayman S with LSD or 996 RS
Author
Discussion

barrythompson

Original Poster:

455 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Following a good season of travelling to the ring in my 996RS (and storing it for a few months at Manthey)i am considering leaving a car over there full time with another race outfit.

I want to leave my current car at home as i like to use it in the uk and cherish it, but i am considering either

1. Buying a new Cayman S with ceramics, fitting an LSD, upgrade the suspension and fit buckets seats or.

2. Buy another 996 RS.


I know how good the 996 is but, will the above cayman give similar or more satisfaction cost wise. I.e 55k for a modified Cayman or 65k for a 996 4 year old car.

Cheers

BT


DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
haha your ring tool budget is impressive! If you are going to spend that much the GT3 surely as Porsche have done all the development work for track usage. For what you propose I'd even prefer a cheap LHD mk1 GT3 to the cayman. Would leave you 30k change too wink

Or how about a CSL for a bit of variety?

I'm feeling insecure about my low budget e36 DRT now lol.

Edited by DanH on Wednesday 17th October 12:20

willr

363 posts

284 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Barry - why buy a new Cayman, when you can get a 1 or 2 year old one at bargain price? Mine was a perfect example smile

Would suggest you don't bother with ceramics, although if you do then again a used model might be interesting - one dealer told me that they actually hurt resell values! With proper pads the standard steel Cayman S brakes are fine.

If I'd kept the Cayman I would have changed the suspension - probably gone for the Manthey KW setup and LSD. You just can't get enough camber on the standard setup.

Of course the Cayman won't be as fast as the RS round the ring in the dry, but in any other condition would be my choice. It's so wonderfully balanced and forgiving, you have time to have fun!

sambaman

3,991 posts

255 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
barry..i reckon you should come buy my 996RS .............be a bit like swapsies i suppose as i have your 997RS ;-)

ScottL

814 posts

261 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
As per Dan's comments, bear in mind the engine and gearbox on the Cayman are not engineered for hard track work. Less of a problem at the Ring I suppose.

Having said that I would be very tempted to go down the used Cayman S route. Buy privately (and aggressively) and you can pick one up for £35K, less if LHD.

Then fit an LSD, KW's, upgrade the brakes, roll cage, recaro's, harnesses, new wheels and MPSC's.

Good post on Rennteam from someone who's done just that.

http://www.rennteam.com/showflat.php?Cat=0&Num...

willr

363 posts

284 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Plenty of Caymans have had track usage by now and I haven't heard of any track-related engine or gearbox problem. The Cayman should be a lot cheaper to maintain, too.

barrythompson

Original Poster:

455 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
DanH said:
haha your ring tool budget is impressive! If you are going to spend that much the GT3 surely as Porsche have done all the development work for track usage. For what you propose I'd even prefer a cheap LHD mk1 GT3 to the cayman. Would leave you 30k change too wink

Or how about a CSL for a bit of variety?

I'm feeling insecure about my low budget e36 DRT now lol.

Edited by DanH on Wednesday 17th October 12:20
I have done the cheap ring nail and tbh it does not work - you just dont get the same experience plus you can spend more making it half decent with no market for it come sale time.

As for CSL - i had a ride a couple of weeks ago around the ring and i am not a fan. SPB2's dad was driving and he can go pretty quick but its not the car for me. + i think the gearbox is sh*te

Common sence tells me 996RS - a years motoring for limited depreciation.

BT

Hammerwerfer

3,234 posts

271 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
RS all the way. It was built to take it, is a rarer beast, and I would think much less expensive in the long run especially if you factor in depreciation on a used RS v a new Cayman.

Factor in the costs of bringing the Cayman up to spec and it should b a no brainer.

barrythompson

Original Poster:

455 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
sambaman said:
barry..i reckon you should come buy my 996RS .............be a bit like swapsies i suppose as i have your 997RS ;-)
Theres only yours and Steve R's in the running at the moment if i decide 996

sambaman

3,991 posts

255 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
cool..im sure you wont be dissapointed ...........

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
barrythompson said:
DanH said:
haha your ring tool budget is impressive! If you are going to spend that much the GT3 surely as Porsche have done all the development work for track usage. For what you propose I'd even prefer a cheap LHD mk1 GT3 to the cayman. Would leave you 30k change too wink

Or how about a CSL for a bit of variety?

I'm feeling insecure about my low budget e36 DRT now lol.

Edited by DanH on Wednesday 17th October 12:20
I have done the cheap ring nail and tbh it does not work - you just dont get the same experience plus you can spend more making it half decent with no market for it come sale time.

As for CSL - i had a ride a couple of weeks ago around the ring and i am not a fan. SPB2's dad was driving and he can go pretty quick but its not the car for me. + i think the gearbox is sh*te

Common sence tells me 996RS - a years motoring for limited depreciation.

BT
I know what you mean about the experience. Made the mistake of taking my RS around recently and now makes me question whether I'll enjoy my m3 'race car' as much. Having said that I can't afford to crash my RS so I'll just have to make do.

Not sure I can see the argument for going to the trouble of modding a cayman to be worse than a GT3 though, as it will cost more and be inferior. Well unless you have a real hankering for one. I doubt there will be much market for it later either...



Edited by DanH on Wednesday 17th October 15:26

willr

363 posts

284 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Wait until winter, then take a 34k Cayman S, still under manufacturer warranty, add around 6k for cage, suspension, diff & seats. It still won't be an RS, but it'll cost a lot less to run...

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
willr said:
Wait until winter, then take a 34k Cayman S, still under manufacturer warranty, add around 6k for cage, suspension, diff & seats. It still won't be an RS, but it'll cost a lot less to run...
Do that and the warranty is a bit irrelevent and you've thrown 6k at a car you'll find hard to sell. Crazy!

An early GT3 has to make more sense than that, and no one will blink that its been used on track.

willr

363 posts

284 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
...but in comparison with a 65k RS? A nearly-new 40k DRT that could lap the ring as fast as a mk1 GT3 (or faster, in the wet).

You'd only need to dispose of the cage and seats separately if you came to resell the car.

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
willr said:
...but in comparison with a 65k RS? A nearly-new 40k DRT that could lap the ring as fast as a mk1 GT3 (or faster, in the wet).
I wouldn't have guessed that. Also 40k would get an LHD mk2 I would think?

barrythompson

Original Poster:

455 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
willr said:
Barry - why buy a new Cayman, when you can get a 1 or 2 year old one at bargain price? Mine was a perfect example smile

Would suggest you don't bother with ceramics, although if you do then again a used model might be interesting - one dealer told me that they actually hurt resell values! With proper pads the standard steel Cayman S brakes are fine.

If I'd kept the Cayman I would have changed the suspension - probably gone for the Manthey KW setup and LSD. You just can't get enough camber on the standard setup.

Of course the Cayman won't be as fast as the RS round the ring in the dry, but in any other condition would be my choice. It's so wonderfully balanced and forgiving, you have time to have fun!
Thats what i am thinking, i have been on trips to the ring this year and only managed a couple of laps in the 996 on cups because of the weather. A cayman with ps2's on will be good in the dry and okay in the wet. I just wanted advice on caymans as i have seen them on track and they look great fun.

As for second hand ones, there aren't many in white.....and it has to be white!


I have the KW's on my 996 and think they improve the car (in track) immensly, the first thing i would do is change the suspension and fit an LSD.

thanks for your advice.

BT

barrythompson

Original Poster:

455 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
ScottL said:
As per Dan's comments, bear in mind the engine and gearbox on the Cayman are not engineered for hard track work. Less of a problem at the Ring I suppose.

Having said that I would be very tempted to go down the used Cayman S route. Buy privately (and aggressively) and you can pick one up for £35K, less if LHD.

Then fit an LSD, KW's, upgrade the brakes, roll cage, recaro's, harnesses, new wheels and MPSC's.

Good post on Rennteam from someone who's done just that.

http://www.rennteam.com/showflat.php?Cat=0&Num...
Cheers for that Scott - i have not been on that site before, good link.


flattotheboards

6,689 posts

237 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
its an interesting and very fortunate postion to be in.i would have said for an extra 10k or so a 996 rs would be better over a new cayman, but if you could find a second hand cayman in good condition in the spec you want ie the ceramics etc, then id go for that and save a chunk of cash.