Tyres questions
Author
Discussion

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all

Right, need to clear this up. The boots on my 996 C4 are 225-40/zr18 front and 265-35/zr18 rears. They're P Zero rosso, not very good, and down to the limits.

We're not 100% sure this is the correct size but it looks like it.

Anyway have ordered up Mich Pilot sports from Micheldever. I did say they need to be Porsche spec i.e 'N' grade, matey did seem to know what I was talking about, but how do I check that they are 'N' spec? Is there a marking or number on the tyre or what? confused

Anyway £640 odd for a set fitted and balanced, thought that was quite good, what do you think? Anyone paid less anywhere else?

Cheers! thumbup


Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
Hi smile

Falken 452`s in same sizes but NOT N rated (means little) = £350....(a set)

All the best Brett smile

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
Hi smile

Falken 452`s in same sizes but NOT N rated (means little) = £350....(a set)

All the best Brett smile
These any good though? Looking through previous posts most people have said that it's important to have the correct 'N' grade tyres. I don't know why though??

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
I think the 'N' rating signifies that Porsche have approved the tyre with use on their cars. In itself, it doesn't mean they are 'better' than non-N rated tyres, but that Porsche advise their use.

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
Brett928S2 said:
Hi smile

Falken 452`s in same sizes but NOT N rated (means little) = £350....(a set)

All the best Brett smile
These any good though? Looking through previous posts most people have said that it's important to have the correct 'N' grade tyres. I don't know why though??
Hi smile

Well I use them on mine....over 500hp but thats mostly for straight lines and mine only last around 6 months (3000 miles)

I do use mine as a daily driver and the Falkens are GREAT in the dry and GOOD in the wet...

The only reason there is a difference in the above is that I cannot use all my power in the wet anyway lol...

As far as N rating is concerned....it means little...IMHO....certainly not £300 more for a set of tyres...

All the best Brett smile

OrangeBob55

206 posts

230 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Those sizes look right for a pre-facelift on 18" wheels.

Michelin Pilot Sport's are highly rated on the 911.

The 'N' mark will be clear on the sidewall of the tyre.

The 'N' Rating is given by Porsche to tyres that they have tested and passed their quality and handling requirements - Most important here is the reference to the 'handling' element - As we all know, the 911, being rear-engined, has handling characteristics particular to the car/chasis.

Note, that the 'N' rating is not just a stamp of approval, but 'N' rated tyres are normally 'developed in conjunction' with Porsche - i.e. an 'N' rated tyre can actually be different to a non-'N' rated tyre of the same type/size.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
OrangeBob55 said:
Those sizes look right for a pre-facelift on 18" wheels.

Michelin Pilot Sport's are highly rated on the 911.

The 'N' mark will be clear on the sidewall of the tyre.

The 'N' Rating is given by Porsche to tyres that they have tested and passed their quality and handling requirements - Most important here is the reference to the 'handling' element - As we all know, the 911, being rear-engined, has handling characteristics particular to the car/chasis.

Note, that the 'N' rating is not just a stamp of approval, but 'N' rated tyres are normally 'developed in conjunction' with Porsche - i.e. an 'N' rated tyre can actually be different to a non-'N' rated tyre of the same type/size.
Is exactly the answer I was looking for, thanks for that thumbup


Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
OrangeBob55 said:
Those sizes look right for a pre-facelift on 18" wheels.

Michelin Pilot Sport's are highly rated on the 911.

The 'N' mark will be clear on the sidewall of the tyre.

The 'N' Rating is given by Porsche to tyres that they have tested and passed their quality and handling requirements - Most important here is the reference to the 'handling' element - As we all know, the 911, being rear-engined, has handling characteristics particular to the car/chasis.

Note, that the 'N' rating is not just a stamp of approval, but 'N' rated tyres are normally 'developed in conjunction' with Porsche - i.e. an 'N' rated tyre can actually be different to a non-'N' rated tyre of the same type/size.
Hi smile

That large first paragraph ref...tested and passed is correct...

The second paragraph ref...developed in conjunction with is NOT..

The tyre manufacturer develops the tyre ....THEN they are given to Porsche to test.....Porsche has NO input into the actual development...

Most tyre makers don't bother as Porsche is a limited market which is why the ones that do ...charge a fortune...

IMHO....for what its worth....and I DO get through a lot of tyres...of all makes...

N rated tyres are designed to last rather than grip.....

Most non N rated tyres I have personally used.....have better grip but do not last the same mileage.....

So you pays your money and takes your choice...

All the best Brett smile

Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
a) Surely, if you crashed and didn't have the correctly specified tyres, your insurance company would be in their rights to decline the claim - just like they do if your car is nicked if you leave the keys in the ignition when paying for fuel ??

B) I wouldn't risk my life with some cheapo, non-approved, tyres for the sake of a couple of hundered quid. My Michelin PS N rates ones were less than 600 GBP fitted.

OrangeBob55

206 posts

230 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
OrangeBob55 said:
The 'N' Rating is given by Porsche to tyres that they have tested and passed their quality and handling requirements - Most important here is the reference to the 'handling' element - As we all know, the 911, being rear-engined, has handling characteristics particular to the car/chasis.

Note, that the 'N' rating is not just a stamp of approval, but 'N' rated tyres are normally 'developed in conjunction' with Porsche - i.e. an 'N' rated tyre can actually be different to a non-'N' rated tyre of the same type/size.
That large first paragraph ref...tested and passed is correct...

The second paragraph ref...developed in conjunction with is NOT..

The tyre manufacturer develops the tyre ....THEN they are given to Porsche to test.....Porsche has NO input into the actual development...
Okay, semantics maybe, my point is that most 'N' rated tyres have been specifically designed for use on a Porsche. These tyres have then been 'approved' by Porsche for use on the cars. (To assume that the R&D function of a tyre's development will not include involvement from the manufacturer for which it is being specifically developed, is somewhat far-fetched).

I did a quick Google and found this... You might want to take a look, it explains it rather well...

http://www.tyresite.com/tyrearticle.asp?page=14

Extract:
"tyre manufacturers may also build other tyres featuring the same name, size and speed rating as the N-specification tyres for non-Porsche applications. These tyres may not be branded with the Porsche N-specification because they do not share the same internal construction and/or tread compound ingredients as the N-specification tyres"

Pat Cash

312 posts

261 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Diesel130 said:
a) Surely, if you crashed and didn't have the correctly specified tyres, your insurance company would be in their rights to decline the claim - just like they do if your car is nicked if you leave the keys in the ignition when paying for fuel ??

B) I wouldn't risk my life with some cheapo, non-approved, tyres for the sake of a couple of hundered quid. My Michelin PS N rates ones were less than 600 GBP fitted.
Many insurance companies are aware of the N rating and also that it states in the owners manual that Porsche approved tyres must be used - IE N rated.... So in theory they could back out of paying I guess..

Also, I've seen a number of issues with PSM and Tiptronic all down to Non Nrated tyres being used...

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi smile

Insurance companies dont care whether you fit N rated or not...its a choice thing its not mandatory or compulsory...

ALL tyres whether N or not have to meet certain regulations regarding composition/safety/speed ratings etc....

If you want to fit N tyres at £600 plus fine....I will stick with my £350 Falkens...

All the best Brett smile

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Know what you mean about the cost, but I want the proper thing on my bloody expensive car boxedin, plus I need the longevity as I do rack the miles up driving

Spoken to Michelin this aftie, found out a bit more about the 'N' rating.
They ARE developed in conjunction with Porsche. Lots of testing, computer modelling, that kind of thing. They're obviously then approved by Porsche as the only tyre they recommend, obviously that's not to say you HAVE to fit them. It's a grey area about insurance though, and knowing insurance companies and the value of my car, I am not going to test the theory, especially if one day I plough into a bus queue.

The number after the 'N' (i.e 1, 2, 3 etc) is the latest evolution of the tyre. As technology progresses, Michelin will go back to Porsche and test the new development. HEnce, you can get the same tyre but with different numbers.

At the moment on my sizes, 225/35 zr18 front and 265/40 zr18 rear, they are on N1.