Shake in C4S Steering at 50mph+
Shake in C4S Steering at 50mph+
Author
Discussion

PeterGT

Original Poster:

5 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Hi All,

Just bought my first porker. A nice 2003 C4S. Lovely car and great handling but I have an issue which i'm not sure how to resolve.

When I picked it up from the local "Sports Car Dealer" !! (Country wide!!) They'd told me they'd changed the back tyres, all disks and brake pads. Result !! I thought. Tootling round town the car was lovely, but on the motorway above 50+ the steering was a bit shakey. I took it to my mate (works at the local Porsche dealer) who suggested they put on unknown tyres (Kumho Ecsta Spt) on the back and should of matched them up with the PZero's on the front. Front's were slightly worn too so they should change them as well. Anyway, the dealer said that was rubbish and the tyres were fine but did agree to put two new tyres on the front and do the ballancing. Result !! But they put on the Kumho Ecsta Spt tyres as on the back. Waffle waffle I know sorry so heres the point........the car is a little better but not handling how i'd expect a C4S to handle at speed, still a bit shakey..... What should I do?

paultither

1,320 posts

231 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Its an easy problem to solve, take it to get tracked. Anywhere will do it like the local Kwik Fit. Should cost no more than £30 I guess (don't know if they will add more because of the car). Make sure they do laser tracking and the problem should improve, if not totally disappear.

PH5121

2,007 posts

244 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
I cannot believe a dealer put Kumho tyres on a car of that caliber. I put a brand new set of four on my 964 when I traded it in, and felt bad about it. The tyre fitters took the p*ss out of me buying them, calling them 'ditchfinders'.
When finances allowed I would replace the tyres with some that matched the front. My new car has Falkens on the back, I will be swapping them for Bridgestones as soon as I get chance.
It may not effect the ride of the car, and call me a tyre snob, but decent tyres on a 'performance' car are crucial.


Edited by PH5121 on Tuesday 23 October 15:50

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Pzeros are not a good tyre choice for 911's apparently never mind Kumhos???? and you should have the same N Rated tyres front and back BUT it does look like a tracking issue, has your wife maybe kerbed it and not told?hehe Pot Holes maybe?

My C4S although not as exciting as an Elise in the handling stakes is flawless with no shake or shudder whatsover,as smooth as any BMW/Mercedes.

Tip for the moment - When driving on a straight bit of road, let go of the steering wheel for a few seconds and see if the car veers to the side violently.

Edited by Wanta996(Gotta) on Tuesday 23 October 15:24

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
50-60mph is the zone where bad wheel balancing is felt.

Get your wheels balanced and they can often check the tracking for free.

As we all know, this is usually just before they tell you yuor car needs tracking whether it does or not. I find that talking to the guy while he's hanging the lasers on the wheels, and asking what they SHOULD read on the scale prevents them from scamming you.

"Cool they point to 3 just like you said they should, fantastic!"

PeterGT

Original Poster:

5 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Wow, thanks guys. Much appreciated advice.

I'll try the tracking option first. The monkey at the dealer had a right game trying to get the balance right apparently so I'll assume that may be the issue to start with......cheapest option anyway (savings all gonewink)

And once funds are back up I'll get some proper tyres on her I reckon !! Then ebay the unknowns....if that's etiquette wavey

No missus (swapped her for the Porsche LOL) so it's not been curbed (since I had it anyway). Will certainly try the test though.
Thanks again all

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Congrats on buying an ace car. Some cheapo tires will be ok for your first set, means you can really play with the car and feck the tires right up, knowing that theyre only cheapies.

Then when you get good rubber, you'll be further amazed at the grip the car has.

Oh ... and well done for getting rid of the lass. Probably a good idea when you look at some of the recent threads of woe on here.

PeterGT

Original Poster:

5 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Nice one, yeah I agree. Keep these and make the most of them for now.

I'll post an update with progress after the balance !!

Cheers again byebye

bow

PeterGT

Original Poster:

5 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
....oh yeah and the lass stopped me getting this beast for years.......fair trade me thinks !!

All I need now is a bird who likes a bit of speed. Had a few in this already and they ask me to slow down! What's that all about LOL.....I was within all speed limits confused......So it was a redcard to them wink

The cars the only lady I need for now driving

TTFN

Stirlings.co.uk

324 posts

254 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
3 things to check
i have had cars that give a wheel vibration at 60mph plus caused by the brake discs being corroded on the inner edges, new discs and pads £1600 later cured it

tyres Kumho wont be porsche N rated and can affect the handling of the car,
The top techie at my local OPc had a customer complaing about teh handling on his 911, he'd had a 4 wheel alignment done and still the car never felt right,
he told the owner it was the tyres but he wouldn't listen, eventaully, the techie offered to put aset of proper N rated wheels and tyres on the car, and said if it drives right you buy the tyres,
He bought the tyres, its not just a speed rating thing, N rated tyres do make a difference
I vealso heard a story from a techie of a C4 tip, on miss matched tyres that threw up a PASM failure light

Kumho's on a C4S

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Is your problem one of steering shake or some other handling issue? If it is shake, then it is probably wheel balance. All the clues are there. the symptoms sound classic and the fact that the fitter had 'a right game trying to get the balance right' all points to wheel balance.

The problem is almost certainly that the wheels weren't mounted on the balancer correctly, either because the adaptors were worn or maybe it is simply that they used the incorrect type of adaptors. If he had difficulties more likely the former. A very common problem.

I would suggest that you call Haweka UK, Dave Smith on 01242-621001, and ask him to recommend a local operator who has the correct adaptors and is known to do a good job. Haweka make a huge range of specialist adaptors aimed at solving this very common problem.

If the steering issue has now gone and you have a general handling issue then it may well be the alignment but you need a specialist, not one of the high street centres.

One thing for sure? It isn't the Kumhos. Not much wrong with them, certainly as good if not better than Falken and not far behind most of the premium brands.

Final caveat: I am making this judgement on your info and it is always difficult to be precise, but a rebalance by someone with the correct kit and experience is the cheapest next step.



PeterGT

Original Poster:

5 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks stirlings and DSM2, much appreciated.

Brakes and disks seem fine, which I should hope so as they're brand new and I've done the advised gentle 400 miles to run them in. All seems fine under soft and tough braking, no grinding or pulling.

I'll certainly go for the re-balance first. And most likely go to my mate at the local OPC. They'll defo have the right equipment.....and take care of the alloys.....which the dealer I got it from didn't mad

(needed touching up slightly anyway)

And yes, maybe I should of gone for a motor from an OPC but I couldn't quite stretch to the additional 10k they put on them rolleyes

Thanks for the advice on the tyres. I'll see if I can get away with them after the OPC work. If not, i'll try and get my mate to stick his set of Miche's on it to try them out......then I should know for sure if the tyres are duff.

Thanks again. Will update after progress.