GT3 RS - Extra Beans via Manthey / Carpgraphic / Others
GT3 RS - Extra Beans via Manthey / Carpgraphic / Others
Author
Discussion

drhildr

Original Poster:

453 posts

257 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Any comparisons / experiences on the relative merits of Manthey 410 vs Cargraphic (or Others)to breathe a decent extra bit of power into a 996 GT3 Rs without breaking the bank?

Glenn McMenamin

2,305 posts

269 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
drhildr said:
Any comparisons / experiences on the relative merits of Manthey 410 vs Cargraphic (or Others)to breathe a decent extra bit of power into a 996 GT3 Rs without breaking the bank?
I was at Manthey earlier in the year, and they had a 997 GT3 on with their exhaust, but said the rest of a kit was still under development. However, they also said that even they don't think there will be much more than they can eek out of the 3.6, as Porsche seemed to have already taken things pretty much as far as possible this time...


timmo

1,788 posts

265 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
If you Increase the power on a 996 GT3 RS and use it on track you will eat through the standard brakes/discs...
next up is the Alcon/Brembo floating disc conversion with RS29s
after this you will find the chassis wanting and then you are in to 3-4K for a suspension/GEO set up !
then you want a firmer ride on track and then you start looking at Uni Ball bushes and different diffs !!!!!!



What Im saying is once you start its an endless road which costs a lot of money !

Good Luck

drhildr

Original Poster:

453 posts

257 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
It's already got Alcons / 29's, Parr Motorsport Geo and JZM Suspension so I reckon I'm already well up that long, winding and very expensive road!

timmo said:
If you Increase the power on a 996 GT3 RS and use it on track you will eat through the standard brakes/discs...
next up is the Alcon/Brembo floating disc conversion with RS29s
after this you will find the chassis wanting and then you are in to 3-4K for a suspension/GEO set up !
then you want a firmer ride on track and then you start looking at Uni Ball bushes and different diffs !!!!!!



What Im saying is once you start its an endless road which costs a lot of money !

Good Luck

Steve Rance

5,453 posts

262 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
drhildr said:
Any comparisons / experiences on the relative merits of Manthey 410 vs Cargraphic (or Others)to breathe a decent extra bit of power into a 996 GT3 Rs without breaking the bank?
Suspension upgrades are far more effective pound for pound


Glenn McMenamin

2,305 posts

269 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
ooops, just realised this is about 996 sorry frown

As said, you will get a lot more from changing your suspension, than
anything else, especially on track.


The Manthey K410 is a nice addition, and worth while if you are keeping the car for a bit..

SidewaysSid

523 posts

289 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Steve Rance said:
drhildr said:
Any comparisons / experiences on the relative merits of Manthey 410 vs Cargraphic (or Others)to breathe a decent extra bit of power into a 996 GT3 Rs without breaking the bank?
Suspension upgrades are far more effective pound for pound
Anyone can drive fast in a straight line and it's boring. Later braking and the ability to carry more speed through the corners is where you get the rewards. So I agree with Steve and having run the JRZ suspension on my Mk1 GT3 it made a huge difference. To extract small amounts of extra bhp from the GT3 engine requires a shed load of money.

Best get ready to break the bank.

Edited by SidewaysSid on Tuesday 23 October 16:11

timmo

1,788 posts

265 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Basically the best way is to get a new Exhaust system/ECU upgrade this liberates all the BHP ( like they have done on the 997 GT3 )
but the problem is keeping it to 103db-105db its a fine balance between power/db

So If you go this route you can say goodbye to circuits such Bedford,Goodwood,Castle Coombe,Donnington

and hello to the Nurburgring/SPA and most other European trackdays


I got black flagged last time my RS was at Bedford and the noise police nearly had a heart attack - I knew I was getting thrown off so I gave it some more welly !!!

tim





scotty_917

1,034 posts

253 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
leave it as standard and pay for expert driver tuition.....far better IMHO.smile

drhildr

Original Poster:

453 posts

257 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
And the Manthey conversion has a grip of the noise issue - claiming to be as quiet as standard....?

Glenn McMenamin said:
ooops, just realised this is about 996 sorry frown

As said, you will get a lot more from changing your suspension, than
anything else, especially on track.


The Manthey K410 is a nice addition, and worth while if you are keeping the car for a bit..

Glenn McMenamin

2,305 posts

269 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
drhildr said:
And the Manthey conversion has a grip of the noise issue - claiming to be as quiet as standard....?

Glenn McMenamin said:
ooops, just realised this is about 996 sorry frown

As said, you will get a lot more from changing your suspension, than
anything else, especially on track.


The Manthey K410 is a nice addition, and worth while if you are keeping the car for a bit..
Certainly noisier than standard, you won't get on Bedford withough being flagged, unless you lift passed the mics...

Goodwood is another no no, maybe Combe too....


Sounds great though..

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
The obvious solution is to change the final drive ratio in the gearbox. 10-12% acceleration increase with the cup final drive and no messing with an expensive engine.

I find these Manthey type mods extortionate for a remap + exhaust and as mentioned above, you run into trouble with the noise nimbys.

MOD500

2,687 posts

281 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
DanH said:
I find these Manthey type mods extortionate for a remap + exhaust and as mentioned above, you run into trouble with the noise nimbys.
I agree, the German tackle such as Manthey, Cargraphic et al is mad money, but I guess you pay for the huge R&D that went into their power kits off the back of the race experience? I don't doubt there is a big margin on top too!

Edited by MOD500 on Tuesday 23 October 17:50

derestrictor

18,764 posts

292 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
MOD500 said:
I don't doubt there is a big margin on top too!
They have to fund that S&M kit, somehow!

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Steve Rance said:
drhildr said:
Any comparisons / experiences on the relative merits of Manthey 410 vs Cargraphic (or Others)to breathe a decent extra bit of power into a 996 GT3 Rs without breaking the bank?
Suspension upgrades are far more effective pound for pound
2nded

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
scotty_917 said:
leave it as standard and pay for expert driver tuition.....far better IMHO.smile
yesyesyes

You never know, you may become fast enough to even pass 968s on track..............

barrythompson

455 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
I have the K410 on my 996 RS and have done so for nearly 3 years, i love the sound and the extra torque and think the system looks nicer than standard. I also have the KW suspension which transforms the car on track.

It is very expensive though!

Cheers

Barry