Porsche 993 or Maserati?????
Porsche 993 or Maserati?????
Author
Discussion

WBmaserati

Original Poster:

33 posts

255 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I am thinking of swapping my 993 C4S for a Maserati 3200GT or even a 4200 Gransport if my wallet will stretch. Although I am concerned over servicing and general costs of the Maser. Has anyone got any pointers! or can offer any good advice?

Pope

2,653 posts

278 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I know of a 3200GT with skyhook system that needed its front struts replacing - £7800 fitted - !!!!!!!
Clutch: 6 - 12k miles approx £5k
Cambelts and timing chains every 6 years - £5k +

Personally 993 will always be my choice........

jq74

163 posts

260 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Pope said:
I know of a 3200GT with skyhook system that needed its front struts replacing - £7800 fitted - !!!!!!!
Clutch: 6 - 12k miles approx £5k
Cambelts and timing chains every 6 years - £5k +

Personally 993 will always be my choice........
I'd be surprised if it was that expensive to rn one of these cars... £5k+ for cambelts? used to have a Testarossa and cambelts on that were [only] £2k and that involved actually droping the engine out of the car to change the belts.

130R

7,128 posts

237 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
WBmaserati said:
I am concerned over servicing and general costs of the Maser
Then don't get one. They are seriously expensive to maintain.

WBmaserati

Original Poster:

33 posts

255 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I know servicing a new 3200gt at Verdi is 995 pounds and a mid service is about 600 but its the other stuff such as the skyhook system etc this is what costs the money I am guessing! to have this replaced before 12k is very surprising! I thought the newer 3200 and 4200 were more reliable than that????

gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
have retailed a couple of masers dont bother baaaaad car
3200gt poorly finished unreliable,later facelift ferrari engined ones better,
993 engineering excellence wins every time
gary

WBmaserati

Original Poster:

33 posts

255 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for your comments chaps, I am certainly thinking twice about the maser! having said that what a beautifull car albeit baaaad! I suppose I will have to keep barking at the cars.

nine6four

313 posts

241 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Popped into Marinellos in Egham last year to look at a 3200. Even their sales guy told me the 911 was a far better car!

LuckyP

6,243 posts

256 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I had a 2001 3200GT in 2005

£28,000. Thought I'd had the bargain of the century!!!

Two years later, sold it for £18K with another £10K keeping it on the road. £20K down the pan.

Make up your own mind. But if I had that time again. I'd go Pork.

I finally saw the light (well, my g/f saw it for me) and bought a 964.

All that shite for the love of a couple of boomerangs!!!

Pete

Edited by LuckyP on Wednesday 24th October 21:37

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Of course, if you aske this question on the Porsche forum, what do you expect...

The Maseratis is a very different car to the 993. If you stretch to a GranSport, then I think as long as the car works (!) you get something which will make you feel special every time you use it. The exhaust note is just pure p*rn. It's a newer car and the interior - depending on colour - looks more modern and luxurious. However, it will not outperform a well driven 993 and you mentioned its biggest downside: reliability. If you get it as a second car and get hold of a decent example, then go for an extended test drive and see if you like it.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
If you do start looking at them (or want to check into maintenance costs first) speak to Marios at Autoshield in Chorlton cum Hardy. Google them for contact details etc. They used to be authorised service dealers but not sure if they still are since Ferrari bought Maserati and changed the rules/goalposts. Either way they know their stuff on all Maseratis, from the 60s up to date.

He told me once about 3200s going through clutches. They could avoid it by balancing the clutch on the car (!). It lasted a lot longer but most customers weren't prepared to fork out for it - it took at least a day in the workshop to do.

shadowninja

80,188 posts

313 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Pope said:
I know of a 3200GT with skyhook system that needed its front struts replacing - £7800 fitted - !!!!!!!
Clutch: 6 - 12k miles approx £5k
Cambelts and timing chains every 6 years - £5k +
yikes

I knew they were expensive but didn't think they were that expensive!!


sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
WBmaserati said:
my wallet will stretch
maser owner's favourite pass time is wallet stretching

you'll be in good company

mcgus

371 posts

246 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
have you asked this on the Maserati forum?

paultje

1,042 posts

270 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
When my porka was in for paint last year there were a few 3200/4200s in at the same time. A close look at the 'inards' was not very encouraging....'bits of tin' immediately springs to mind. They are also a pig to work on...anyone late for work was given a Masa to repair!! ( including Jodie Kid's ). Talk to a body shop that repairs them first....at least you will get an unbiased view.

SunDiver

780 posts

268 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
A 993C4S for a Masterati?!

A widebody 993...for....a....M a s e r a t i...?!

Good God man, what are you thinking?

;-)


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
have a friend who has run numerous porsche, ferrari, maser over the years... his rule of thumb is the rarris cost double the porsche and the masers double the ferraris.... sold his last modern maser after a near 5 figure service bill

nervous

24,050 posts

261 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
fbrs said:
and the masers double the ferraris
funnily enough, had an off the record chat with a ferrari service chap this week and he said this is exactly the ratio i could expect with a mas.

i still would though.

spydersingh

698 posts

246 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
My 10pence worth.......

Having owned a Maserati Spyder for the last 18m I can say that it can be expensive to maintain if you go through the main dealers, a good independant can do just as well. Like most cars, just try and find a well maintained good example. And buy as new as model as you can as there have been significant upgrades and tweaks in the model history ie Skyhook/Cambiocorsa Software/Suspension etc.

As far as reliabilty goes, you really can't beat the Porsche, in fact, I've been looking for a 964 as an everyday car!

What you are buying is an exclusive car, if you look at the classified, its 787 vs 48 (a 16:1 ratio) so depending on where you drive, you probably won't see another one for a while! People do stop and stare and take the occasional pic when parked and you do get the random coversations when filling up (albeit quite frequently depending on the right foot!).

The fact that there are so many 911's versus Maserati's is a good thing when taking into account part availabilty/independant garages/reliabilty etc. For example, my car was in for servicing this summer and I didn't realise that the factories shut over August so I had to wait until they re-opened until some parts arrived!

In summary, the 911 is tried and tested and will outlive the Maserati but what you are buying is an exclusive Italian car!

PM if you want any more info! Hope that helps!

WBmaserati

Original Poster:

33 posts

255 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Well I think my mind is made up.....To be honest I am a car lover without the wallet to match. I can keep up with the Porsche costs because I had the good sense (second time round) to buy a decent C4S with low miles. Having read the comments above I can see that I do not have the funds to maintain a Maserati (albeit I absolutely love the Gransport).

I guess even as a 39 year old with a nice car I will have to sit back and admire a car for what it is ......unreachable (like a kid looking through the window of a model shop).

I expected the comments to be more one sided than they were having posted on the Porsche slot, so thanks for that. I might post this on the Masser slot and compare.

I have a history of buying with my heart and not my head and much to my wifes dismay the wallet has to catch up (just being honest). Having previously bought a 1978 SC for 10k and spent all told 10k in two years on it (this included everything i.e. insurance (and an accident on the way to a classic show ouch!)) this was a lesson which I nearly repeated with an "old" Maserati 3200GT (ex Arsenal footballers car) I signed on the dotted line kept it for two weeks and sent it back with one problem after another (I got scared and ran away!). I then bought the C4S which was the best around at the time (bias!), this car has been fantastic and therefore I should not be thinking of replacing it also I agree with all of the comments above relating to the 993 its a fantastic looking car. But there is a certain magnetism to a Gransport! But I have decided not to go there............beer