RE: Can't Start, Won't Start
RE: Can't Start, Won't Start
Wednesday 24th October 2007

Can't Start, Won't Start

New cars most likely to have problems starting after four years


C'mo, c'mon, c'mon...
C'mo, c'mon, c'mon...
If you imagine a car not starting on a cold, damp morning you would probably think old British Leyland or a temperamental Italian classic.

But a new survey has revealed that after four years the most common problem for new cars is ignition problems.

Fuel and ignition systems, along with axle and suspension faults, have the highest rate of failure as the car emerges from the protection of a manufacturer’s three-year warranty, it is claimed.

Braking systems become a problem after six years,with the chance of failure rising from 1.3%in year four to a high of 3.2%, or as much as 1 in 10 for some manufacturers.

According to Warranty Direct, a vehicle’s cooling system is nearly twice as likely to need work in year eight compared to year four.

Author
Discussion

StevenJJ

Original Poster:

541 posts

232 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
According to Warranty Direct, a vehicle’s cooling system is nearly twice as likely to need work in year eight compared to year four.

Righty-ho

Insight

608 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Better take out an extended Warranty with Warranty Direct then. Better safe than sorry. I'm glad they brought this to my attention. Oooh and did you see the sexy hand model holding the key, I'd like that sexy hand model to hold my key too... I will imagine that whilst sending them my money so I have added piece of mind. And with the money I spent on them I now have none left to spend on Champagne to woo the sexy hand model. I will have to rely on my warranty to bed her instead.

Bibs_

790 posts

230 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Old cars are more likely to go wrong?

I can see that they've drafted in a heavyweight modern Sherlock!


Timayyyy

36 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
New suspension after 4 years?.....the road surface is to blame for that as it's crap! TIMAYYY!

Adrian W

15,073 posts

251 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Why did they waste the money on a survey, the manufactureres know exactly when the parts will and systems will fail, it's part of the development process, MTBF calculations.

Bigel

120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Is there any danger of them lising such things by manufacturer or are they just going to make a random sweeping statement that most peeps already knew??

march

6 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
So is the moral to buy a car older than eight years old that's had all the work done then ?

rossp

2,596 posts

306 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Warranty direct will have conducted the 'survey' purely as a marketing exercise. They release the 'survey' as a press announcement and hey presto free advertising (if anyone publishes it...)

cowellsj

681 posts

222 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
The plip fobs on my clio seem to have a lifespan like this, they last about 3 yrs and then start to fail. I'm on my third set now and i bet they start pissing about in another 18months or so.

Parts are not designed to last these days, infact i expect a lot of manufacturers put more effort into making parts fail after 3, 4 or 5 yrs than making them last.

You can't win, you either pay for a warranty or for repairs.

190Evoluzione

124 posts

222 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
march said:
So is the moral to buy a car older than eight years old that's had all the work done then ?
No, the moral is to run proper cars that weren't built to a (stupidly low) price and didn't have their genes diluted by fcuking accountants.
Go on, get rid of your silly £500-a-month-on-HP blandmobile and drop a few grand on a nice old BMW E28 M535i.
Or a Mercedes-Benz W124 500E.
Or perhaps even a nice Porsche 911/964...

Edited by 190Evoluzione on Wednesday 24th October 15:06

thegumeister

23 posts

226 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Fuel and ignition failure? Oh they mean alarms/imobilisers that the AA/RAC are already saying are the biggest cause of call outs on all cars regardless of age

jmatras

220 posts

246 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
This is so stupid. Remember, they're talking about what's the most common problem OF THE PROBLEMS THAT THERE ARE. So even if there are fewer problems overall than there were ten years ago, SOMETHING has to be the most common of those that remain. It's just a matter of counting to see what that particular thing is. It's like now that they've controlled, say, the black plague, cancer is a bigger killer. That doesn't mean that cancer is more dangerous, it's that the plague is less so. In fact, cancer is less dangerous now, but compared to the plague, more people are dying from it.

So for automobiles, if fuel system problems decrease by 30 percent but ignition system problems by only 15 percent, the relative incidence of ignition system will increase. It's a bigger slice of a smaller pie.

This is simply how people mess with statistics.

Trundlebug

27 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
The most common cause of breakdowns apart from immobiliser problems is lack of, or poor maintenance.

So perhaps this survey shows us that most cars will last about 4 years before they show obvious signs of poor maintenance... quite a credit to the cars really!!

Not quite such a credit to the garages that take the money for servicing them (and don't do the work), or the owners who can't be a***d to take them in in the first place..

Martin_Hx

4,014 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
"along with axle and suspension faults"

I wonder why with all the super smooth roads we have free of speed bumps....

Fat Audi 80

2,403 posts

274 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
190Evoluzione said:
march said:
So is the moral to buy a car older than eight years old that's had all the work done then ?
No, the moral is to run proper cars that weren't built to a (stupidly low) price and didn't have their genes diluted by fcuking accountants.
Go on, get rid of your silly £500-a-month-on-HP blandmobile and drop a few grand on a nice old BMW E28 M535i.
Or a Mercedes-Benz W124 500E.
Or perhaps even a nice Porsche 911/964...

Edited by 190Evoluzione on Wednesday 24th October 15:06
Or in our case A bulletproof Audi Coupe S2, a 1991 Audi 80 Sport Edition, barely run in at 115,000 and a MK11 Golf GTI 16v with 160,000 on the clock. New cars are rubbish in comparison! biggrin

Droptheclutch

2,621 posts

248 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
190Evoluzione said:
march said:
So is the moral to buy a car older than eight years old that's had all the work done then ?
No, the moral is to run proper cars that weren't built to a (stupidly low) price and didn't have their genes diluted by fcuking accountants.
Go on, get rid of your silly £500-a-month-on-HP blandmobile and drop a few grand on a nice old BMW E28 M535i.
Or a Mercedes-Benz W124 500E.
Or perhaps even a nice Porsche 911/964...

Edited by 190Evoluzione on Wednesday 24th October 15:06
^^^ Oh, you are talkin my language!!!^^^ LOL.

jamcam23

117 posts

230 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Trust me, if you own an Alfa Romeo, none of this surprises me...im shocked when there's a day when something doesn't go wrong....or falls off...or breaks off...or disintegrates..

Frik

13,659 posts

266 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
190Evoluzione said:
Go on, get rid of your silly £500-a-month-on-HP blandmobile and drop a few grand on a nice old BMW E28 M535i.
rofl

Just thinking about how much my work colleague had to spend to keep his on the road before finally giving up...

flattotheboards

6,688 posts

229 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
"they dont make like they used to" wink

Li Moo Bai

847 posts

228 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
190Evoluzione said:
march said:
So is the moral to buy a car older than eight years old that's had all the work done then ?
No, the moral is to run proper cars that weren't built to a (stupidly low) price and didn't have their genes diluted by fcuking accountants.
Go on, get rid of your silly £500-a-month-on-HP blandmobile and drop a few grand on a nice old BMW E28 M535i.
Or a Mercedes-Benz W124 500E.
Or perhaps even a nice Porsche 911/964...

Edited by 190Evoluzione on Wednesday 24th October 15:06
Ahem cough

Ya forgot to mention the venerable 944 cough smile